The waterfall model was first described by Herbert D. Benington in 1956 during a presentation about the software used in radar imaging during the Cold War. Since there were no knowledge-based, creative software development strategies at the time, the waterfall method became standard practice. The waterfall model is a linear and sequential project management framework.
Waterfall Model | Key Elements | Analysis | Implications | Applications | Examples |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Definition | The Waterfall Model is a sequential software development process in which progress flows in one direction through discrete phases: Requirements, Design, Implementation, Testing, Deployment, and Maintenance. Each phase must be completed before moving to the next. | Analyzing the Waterfall Model involves understanding its structured, linear approach. Each phase has defined inputs and outputs, and there is minimal overlap or iteration between phases. It is well-suited for projects with clear and stable requirements. | The Waterfall Model provides a systematic and disciplined approach to software development. It ensures that each phase is completed thoroughly before moving forward, which can lead to high-quality results. However, it may be less adaptable to changing requirements or unexpected issues. | The Waterfall Model is commonly used for projects with well-defined and stable requirements, such as software for regulatory compliance, critical systems, or projects where the cost of errors is high. | – Regulatory compliance software development: Ensuring that software meets specific legal or regulatory requirements. – Aerospace software development: Creating software for critical systems in aircraft. – Embedded software development: Developing software for medical devices with stringent safety requirements. |
Phases | The Waterfall Model consists of distinct phases: 1. Requirements: Gathering and documenting project requirements. 2. Design: Creating detailed design specifications based on requirements. 3. Implementation: Writing and coding the software based on design specifications. 4. Testing: Verifying that the software meets requirements and functions correctly. 5. Deployment: Delivering the software to users or customers. 6. Maintenance: Addressing issues, making updates, and providing ongoing support. | Analyzing the phases involves recognizing their sequential nature. Progression to the next phase typically requires completion and approval of the previous one. The Waterfall Model assumes that requirements are well-understood and stable, which can be a limitation in dynamic environments. | The phase-by-phase structure ensures that each aspect of the project is thoroughly considered and completed before proceeding. This reduces the risk of missing critical requirements or design flaws. However, it may be less flexible in accommodating changes or evolving user needs. | The Waterfall Model is best suited for projects with clear, stable requirements, and minimal uncertainty. It is often used in industries where strict quality control and documentation are essential. | – Medical device software development: Ensuring that software for medical equipment complies with regulatory standards. – Defense and aerospace projects: Developing software for critical systems in military and space applications. – Large-scale infrastructure projects: Managing software development for complex and regulated infrastructure projects. |
Analysis and Design | In the Waterfall Model, the Analysis and Design phases involve creating detailed specifications for the software based on the gathered requirements. It includes architectural design, data design, and user interface design. | Analyzing the Analysis and Design phases emphasizes their importance in translating requirements into a comprehensive design. This phase ensures that the software’s structure, functionality, and user interface are well-defined before implementation begins. | Effective Analysis and Design phases lay the foundation for successful software development. Well-defined specifications guide the implementation process and help identify potential issues early, reducing the likelihood of costly changes later in the project. | Analysis and Design are critical for projects with complex or specialized requirements. They ensure that the software’s structure and functionality align with user needs and project goals. | – Enterprise software development: Creating complex software systems with extensive functionality and user interfaces. – Embedded systems development: Designing software for specialized hardware devices with specific requirements. – Custom application development: Building software tailored to unique business needs. |
Testing | In the Testing phase, the software is rigorously tested to verify that it meets the specified requirements and functions correctly. Testing includes unit testing, integration testing, system testing, and user acceptance testing. | Analyzing the Testing phase underscores its significance in ensuring software quality and functionality. Comprehensive testing helps identify defects, errors, and discrepancies between the software and requirements. It is crucial for validating that the software meets user needs. | Effective testing is essential for delivering high-quality software. Thorough testing reduces the risk of defects and errors in the final product, improving user satisfaction and minimizing post-deployment issues. However, testing can be time-consuming and resource-intensive. | Rigorous testing is particularly important in safety-critical systems, where software failures can have severe consequences. It is also crucial in industries with strict regulatory requirements, such as healthcare and finance. | – Healthcare software testing: Ensuring that medical software functions correctly and complies with regulatory standards. – Financial software testing: Verifying the accuracy and security of financial software systems. – Automotive software testing: Testing software for safety-critical functions in vehicles. |
Deployment | The Deployment phase involves delivering the completed software to users or customers for production use. It includes installation, configuration, user training, and transitioning from development to operational support. | Analyzing the Deployment phase emphasizes its role in making the software available for users. This phase requires careful planning to ensure a smooth transition from development to production, minimizing disruptions and ensuring that users can effectively use the software. | Successful deployment ensures that users have access to the software and can benefit from its features. It involves coordinating various activities, from installation to training, to ensure a seamless user experience. Deployment may require ongoing support to address any issues that arise. | Deployment is critical for delivering the software’s value to users and realizing the project’s objectives. It is essential to consider user needs and ensure a smooth transition from development to production use. | – Enterprise software deployment: Installing and configuring complex software systems in organizations. – Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) deployment: Providing cloud-based software solutions to customers. – Healthcare IT system deployment: Implementing electronic health record (EHR) systems in healthcare facilities. |
Maintenance | The Maintenance phase involves providing ongoing support, updates, and enhancements to the software. It includes fixing defects, addressing user feedback, making updates to meet changing requirements, and ensuring the software remains reliable and secure. | Analyzing the Maintenance phase recognizes its long-term commitment to software quality and usability. It requires a responsive support team, a process for managing change requests, and a proactive approach to addressing issues and evolving user needs. | Effective maintenance ensures that the software remains valuable and continues to meet user needs over time. It requires monitoring for defects and vulnerabilities, applying updates, and making enhancements as technology and user requirements change. Maintenance is ongoing and may extend the software’s lifecycle. | Maintenance is a critical phase for long-lived software systems, including legacy applications and mission-critical software. It supports the software’s sustainability and adaptability in dynamic environments. | – Legacy software maintenance: Supporting and updating older software systems to ensure continued functionality. – Enterprise software support: Providing ongoing support and updates for complex business applications. – Government software maintenance: Ensuring that government software systems remain secure and compliant. |
Understanding the waterfall model
Fourteen years later, American computer scientist Winston Walker Royce published the first formal diagram of the process which would later become known as the waterfall model.
Royce suggested that Benington’s model was flawed because testing only happened at the end of the process.
To address potential sources of failure and mitigate risk, he introduced five steps where progress flows from the top to the bottom like a waterfall.
As significant as the contributions of Bennington and Royce were, it is important to note that neither used the term waterfall to describe their work.
That distinction goes to Bell and Thayer, who mentioned the term in a 1976 paper titled Software Requirements: Are They Really A Problem?
Despite the recent popularity of more iterative agile methods, the waterfall method is still relevant today – particularly for large internal projects that do not benefit from rapid customer feedback or the strict control of materials or distribution.
Furthermore, the model is relatively easy to implement and manage and follows the same sequential steps for each project.
With start and end points clearly defined, project risks, deadlines, and progress are easily communicated to the relevant stakeholders.
The seven phases of the waterfall model
The number and indeed the nature of waterfall model phases varies according to the particular interpretation, business, or industry.
Regardless of the context, each phase in the model is completely dependent on the previous one and must be completed, reviewed, and approved before the next phase can begin.
The seven phases, with a particular focus on software development, include:
Conception
The first phase starts with an idea and a baseline assessment of the project and its costs and benefits.
Initiation
With the project defined, the objectives, purpose, scope, and deliverables must also be defined by assembling the project team.
Requirement analysis
Here, the team identifies project requirements and stakeholder expectations by gathering information from surveys, questionnaires, and brainstorming, among other methods.
Before moving to the next phase, project requirements must be documented and distributed to each member of the team.
System design
Requirements are then analyzed and a system design is prepared, with many companies using a Gantt chart to create a schedule.
Some businesses choose to divide system design into two phases: logical design and physical design.
Logical design involves brainstorming possible solutions, while physical design involves transforming the brainstormed ideas into concrete specifications.
While no coding should occur during software development, the team may establish hardware requirements or a programming language.
Implementation
Here, programmers use the requirements and specifications to create a functional product.
Team members are assigned specific tasks which are monitored and tracked to avoid bottlenecks.
Progress is also regularly reported to stakeholders.
Lastly, code is typically written in small pieces in preparation for the next phase.
Testing
The code is then tested methodically for errors before the product is delivered to the customer.
User acceptance tests can be incorporated during this phase, where users try the product before it is released to the general public.
During the latter stages of the testing phase, any freelance contractors are paid out and a project template is created for use in similar future projects.
Maintenance
In the final phase, customers report additional, real-world usage issues. Based on this feedback, the core project team works to solve problems and modify the software where necessary.
Significant issues may force the team to return to phase three and repeat the process.
Drawbacks of the Waterfall Model
Lack of Flexibility:
- Rigid Structure: The sequential nature of the Waterfall model makes it inflexible, as it typically does not accommodate going back to a previous phase once it’s completed.
- Difficulty Adapting to Changes: The model struggles with adapting to changes in requirements or scope that occur mid-project.
High Risk and Uncertainty:
- Risk of Late Problem Discovery: Issues or misalignments might not be discovered until the testing phase, which can be costly and time-consuming to fix.
- Potential for Escalating Costs: Any significant changes required at later stages can significantly escalate costs.
Inadequate Client Involvement:
- Limited Client Feedback: Clients are typically involved mainly at the beginning and end of the project, leading to a lack of continuous feedback.
- Risk of Not Meeting Client Expectations: The final product may not meet client expectations if requirements were misunderstood or changed over time.
Poor Response to Complexity:
- Not Ideal for Large or Complex Projects: The Waterfall model can be challenging to apply effectively to large or complex projects due to its linear approach.
- Ineffective for Long or Ongoing Projects: For projects with long timelines, the likelihood of changes in market or client requirements increases, making the Waterfall model less suitable.
When to Use the Waterfall Model
Suitable Scenarios:
- Well-Defined Projects: Effective for small to medium-sized projects with well-defined requirements and low risk of change.
- Short-Term Projects: Suitable for projects with short timelines where requirements are not expected to change.
- Sequential Projects: Ideal for projects where each phase needs to be completed before the next begins, such as in certain construction or manufacturing processes.
Strategic Application:
- Requirement-Heavy Initiatives: Can be useful in scenarios where documentation and upfront requirement definition are critical.
- Regulatory or Compliance Projects: Useful in projects where phases are required to be completed and documented before moving to the next, often due to regulatory reasons.
How to Use the Waterfall Model
Implementing the Sequential Phases:
- Requirements Gathering and Documentation: Clearly define and document all requirements at the beginning of the project.
- System Design: Create a comprehensive system design based on the defined requirements.
- Implementation: Develop the system based on the design specifications.
- Testing: Thoroughly test the completed system to ensure it meets the requirements.
- Deployment: Deploy the system in the target environment.
- Maintenance: Provide ongoing maintenance and support post-deployment.
Best Practices:
- Thorough Requirement Analysis: Invest significant effort in the requirements phase to minimize changes later on.
- Regular Documentation: Maintain comprehensive documentation throughout the project lifecycle.
- Client Checkpoints: Establish regular checkpoints with clients or stakeholders to gather feedback and ensure alignment.
What to Expect from Implementing the Waterfall Model
Structured Approach and Planning:
- Predictable Process: Offers a clear, structured approach with well-defined phases.
- Ease of Management: Simplicity in planning and managing due to its linear approach.
Potential Challenges:
- Inflexibility to Changes: Challenges in accommodating changes that arise during the project.
- Late Delivery of Complete Product: The end product is only available at the end of the timeline, potentially delaying time-to-market.
Impact on Project Outcomes:
- Risk of Overruns: Potential for budget and time overruns if significant revisions are required.
- Quality at Project End: High potential for quality outputs if requirements are stable and clearly defined from the start.
Suitability:
- Best Fit for Certain Industries: More suited to industries and projects where change is minimal and requirements are unlikely to be altered.
Key takeaways
- The waterfall model is a linear and sequential project management framework. The waterfall model concept was first described by Herbert D. Benington during a presentation about the software used in radar imaging.
- The waterfall model is still relevant today and is particularly useful for large internal projects that do not benefit from rapid customer feedback or the strict control of materials.
- The waterfall model is comprised of seven phases: conception, initiation, requirements analysis, system design, implementation, testing, and maintenance. Each phase must be completed, reviewed, and approved before the next phase can begin.
Key Highlights
- Introduction and Background:
- The waterfall model was first described by Herbert D. Benington in 1956, inspired by software used in radar imaging during the Cold War.
- It became standard practice due to the absence of knowledge-based software development strategies at the time.
- Understanding the Waterfall Model:
- American computer scientist Winston Walker Royce formalized the model 14 years later.
- Royce introduced a five-step sequential process to address flaws in the original approach.
- The term “waterfall” was coined by Bell and Thayer in a 1976 paper.
- Despite agile methods, the waterfall model remains relevant for certain projects, especially those lacking rapid customer feedback.
- Phases of the Waterfall Model:
- The model consists of seven phases that build upon each other sequentially.
- Each phase must be completed, reviewed, and approved before progressing to the next one.
- The phases are as follows:
- Conception: Idea and assessment of project costs and benefits.
- Initiation: Defining project objectives, scope, and assembling the team.
- Requirement Analysis: Identifying project requirements and stakeholder expectations.
- System Design: Creating a system design based on requirements, often divided into logical and physical design.
- Implementation: Programmers create a functional product based on specifications, with progress tracked and reported.
- Testing: Methodical testing and user acceptance testing occur before product delivery.
- Maintenance: Real-world usage feedback leads to problem-solving, modification, and potential iteration.
- Key Takeaways:
- The waterfall model is a linear and sequential project management framework.
- First described by Herbert D. Benington, it provides a structured approach to software development.
- Comprised of seven phases, the model’s phases must be completed and approved in sequence.
- The waterfall model remains relevant for large internal projects without rapid customer feedback.
Other Time Management Frameworks
Read Next: Business Analysis, Competitor Analysis, Continuous Innovation, Agile Methodology, Lean Startup, Business Model Innovation, Project Management.
Connected Agile & Lean Frameworks
Read Also: Continuous Innovation, Agile Methodology, Lean Startup, Business Model Innovation, Project Management.
Read Next: Agile Methodology, Lean Methodology, Agile Project Management, Scrum, Kanban, Six Sigma.
Main Guides:
- Business Models
- Business Strategy
- Business Development
- Distribution Channels
- Marketing Strategy
- Platform Business Models
- Network Effects
Main Case Studies: