Theory of Constraints And Why It Matters In Business

• The Theory of Constraints is a management philosophy stating that any system is prevented from achieving its full potential by one or more key constraints.
• The Theory of Constraints focuses on constraints in the context of their ability to reduce profits. As a result, the theory focuses on throughput accounting and its core principle of increasing production capacity to generate revenue.
• The Theory of Constraints is a five-step, cyclical process that businesses must consistently use to avoid becoming complacent.

Aspect	Explanation
Concept Overview	The Theory of Constraints (TOC) is a management philosophy and methodology developed by Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt in the 1980s. It focuses on identifying and mitigating constraints or bottlenecks within an organization’s processes to optimize overall performance and achieve strategic goals. The core premise of TOC is that every complex system, including organizations, has at least one constraint that limits its ability to achieve its objectives. TOC provides a structured approach to identifying, prioritizing, and addressing these constraints.
Key Elements	The Theory of Constraints involves several key elements: – Identifying Constraints: The first step is identifying the constraints or bottlenecks within a system, which can be in various forms, such as limited resources, process limitations, or organizational policies. – Exploiting Constraints: Once identified, constraints are “exploited” by ensuring that they are used to their maximum capacity, often by prioritizing work related to the constraint. – Subordinating Other Activities: Non-constraint activities are subordinated to the constraint, ensuring that they do not overwhelm the constraint with excessive work. – Elevating Constraints: If the constraint remains after exploitation and subordination, efforts are made to elevate or remove the constraint, which may involve resource reallocation, process redesign, or investment in additional capacity. – Repeat and Continuous Improvement: The process of identifying, exploiting, and elevating constraints is iterative and continuous, as constraints may shift over time.
Applications	The Theory of Constraints is widely applied in various industries and organizational contexts: – Manufacturing: In manufacturing, TOC is used to optimize production processes, reduce lead times, and improve throughput by addressing bottlenecks in production lines. – Project Management: TOC principles are applied in project management to identify and manage critical project constraints, ensuring projects are completed on time and within budget. – Supply Chain Management: Organizations use TOC to streamline supply chain operations and improve the flow of materials and products. – Service Industries: TOC is relevant in service industries such as healthcare, where it helps manage patient flow, reduce waiting times, and optimize resource utilization. – Sales and Marketing: TOC principles can be applied to sales and marketing strategies to focus efforts on key constraints, such as limited salespeople or production capacity.
Benefits	Adopting the Theory of Constraints offers several benefits: – Increased Throughput: By addressing constraints, organizations can increase the rate at which they produce products or deliver services, resulting in higher throughput and revenue. – Improved Efficiency: Processes become more efficient as constraints are mitigated or eliminated, leading to reduced operational costs. – Enhanced Decision-Making: TOC provides a structured framework for decision-making, helping organizations prioritize actions and investments based on their impact on constraints. – Better Customer Service: Faster delivery times and reduced lead times lead to improved customer satisfaction. – Strategic Alignment: TOC aligns organizational goals and actions with its constraints, ensuring that efforts are focused on what truly matters.
Challenges	Challenges in implementing TOC include resistance to change, the complexity of some constraints, and the need for ongoing monitoring and adaptation as constraints may shift. Additionally, organizations may face resource limitations when trying to elevate constraints through investments in capacity or technology.
Prevention and Mitigation	Overcoming challenges in TOC implementation involves: – Change Management: Addressing resistance to change through effective change management strategies. – Continuous Monitoring: Continuously monitoring and reassessing constraints to adapt to changing circumstances. – Resource Allocation: Allocating resources strategically to elevate constraints while considering budget constraints. – Education and Training: Providing education and training to ensure that teams understand and embrace TOC principles.

The Theory of Constraints was developed in 1984 by business management guru Eliyahu Goldratt in his book The Goal. The Theory of Constraints argues that every system has at least one constraint that hinders high-level performance or profit generation. Fundamentally, the theory advocates identifying constraints and then eliminating them or at the very least, reducing their impact. 

Understanding the Theory of Constraints

The Theory of Constraints was developed in 1984 by business management guru Eliyahu Goldratt in his book The Goal. 

In the book, Goldratt uses the chain metaphor to argue that every business system is only as strong as its weakest link. Here, the weakest link is a constraint that limits the extent of profitability. Since there can only be one weakest link, Goldratt suggests that this is where businesses should focus their efforts to institute significant change.

This change is achieved via throughput accounting, which emphasizes selling more of something to generate higher profits. This approach differs from traditional accounting methods that focus on reducing expenses to generate profit.

However, the capacity to reduce expenses is limited once an expense reaches zero. That is, the ability to increase profits is constrained. 

Conversely, the emphasis on increasing sales revenue via throughput accounting has no such constraint. This is because – at least in theory – there is no limit to the amount of sales revenue a business can generate.

Throughput accounting is comprised of three parts:

• Throughput – or the rate of sales revenue generated by a product or service. 
• Inventory – or money that is tied up in physical things such as raw materials, equipment, distribution facilities, and goods awaiting sale.
• Operating expense – or the money a business spends creating throughput to maintain a desired level of capacity. This may include payroll, depreciation, and utility expenses.

The five steps of the Theory of Constraints

1. Identify the constraint

Which part of the system constitutes the weakest link? Remember, there can only be one.

2. Exploit the constraint

Use available resources to make rapid improvements to the constraint. Reduce or eliminate where possible to avoid expensive wholesale upgrades or process changes.

3. Subordinate the remaining links

The unconstrained (strong) links in a process must be altered so they maximize the output of the weakest link. At this point, the process should be evaluated to determine if the constraint has simply shifted to another location on the chain.

If the constraint has been eliminated, the business can move to step five. Otherwise, they should proceed to step four.

4. Elevate the constraint

If the second and third steps have not been successful, take whatever action necessary to eliminate the constraint. This includes a major overall of an existing system.

5. Beware of inertia

Once a constraint has been removed, avoid becoming complacent. 

Understand that the Theory of Constraints is a cyclical process that stresses the importance of improving one constraint and then moving on to the next. Complacency, which Goldratt calls “inertia”, is a significant barrier to profit generation through increased production.

Theory of constraints examples

Steelo

Steelo is a British company that specializes in 3D printing for structural steel fabrication.

The company’s level of client responsiveness is one of the best in the industry, with lead times between order placement and site delivery as short as one day.

Just as impressive is that parts are routinely delivered within a two-hour time window.

According to Steelo founder Michael Krajewski, these impressive numbers are supported by principles of automotive lean manufacturing, a bespoke IT system, and the theory of constraints. “In our theory, you want one department to be working at 100% capacity, and the rest of the business to be under capacity. This is beneficial, because if there’s a problem, it’s likely to be in the department that is working at 100%. So other departments can take up the slack,” Krajewski explained in a 2019 interview with The Construction Index.

Krajewski initially believed welding bays would be the primary source of production bottlenecks, but after deeper analysis, he realized that the company’s delivery system was its most vulnerable point.

While employee overtime or extra resources could compensate for a broken machine, time lost from a late delivery could never be made up.

This was because council restrictions only allowed Steelo to operate between 8 am and 5 pm.

To reduce or avoid irrecoverable time loss, most of the company’s production staff are multi-talented and can be diverted into other roles as necessary.

In the office, for example, designers are trained as estimators and factory floor staff are also trained in a variety of different roles.

The balance of Steelo’s workforce is also somewhat unusual among manufacturers, with 50% of employees based in the office.

Some of these employees are solely tasked with finding ways to improve operations through innovation.

Mazda

At the 11^th annual conference for theory of constraints professionals in 2013, powertrain division chief engineer Mitsuo Hitomi explained how the company reached a crisis point after reporting financial losses for the previous four years.

Hitomi noted that Mazda had one chance to reverse its fortunes and survive.

This moment called on the company to develop a car that delivered a superb driving experience with an internal combustion engine that had comparable fuel consumption to a hybrid.

Critically, the new model also needed to be affordable for most consumers.

The product development cycle at Mazda was cut by half with the Critical Chain Project Management (CCPM) method where the people, equipment, and physical space required to execute tasks are emphasized.

While there were many subsequent benefits to Mazda’s project management processes, there are two which deserve mention. For one, planning transformed from a management-only task to one where developers were involved in building and creating networks.

Mazda also instituted routine reporting and status mechanisms so that problems could be identified before they were too costly to fix later on. 

These measures, among others, enabled Mazda to return to profit in 2013 after meeting performance objectives related to customer satisfaction, tech development, and more agile product development.

Key takeaways:

• Concept Origin: The Theory of Constraints (TOC) was introduced by Eliyahu Goldratt in his book “The Goal” published in 1984. Goldratt’s ideas revolutionized the field of business management by providing a new perspective on improving organizational performance.
• Central Idea – Constraints: The core premise of TOC is that every system, whether it’s a manufacturing process, a project, or an entire business, has at least one constraint that limits its overall performance. Constraints can be physical, operational, or even conceptual barriers that hinder the system’s ability to generate desired outcomes.
• Weakest Link Metaphor: Goldratt used the analogy of a chain to explain the importance of constraints. Just as a chain is only as strong as its weakest link, a business system’s effectiveness is limited by its weakest constraint. Identifying and addressing this constraint becomes critical for optimizing performance.
• Throughput Accounting: TOC challenges traditional cost-focused accounting methods. Instead of solely cutting expenses, TOC emphasizes increasing throughput, which refers to the rate of sales revenue generated by a product or service. This approach ensures that efforts are directed towards activities that directly contribute to revenue growth.
• Five Steps – Constraint Improvement:
  • Identify the Constraint: Pinpoint the specific aspect within the system that is the constraint limiting performance. It could be a machine, process, or resource.
  • Exploit the Constraint: Optimize the constraint’s usage to achieve maximum output without additional investment. Focus on increasing its efficiency and reducing downtime.
  • Subordinate Other Links: Align the rest of the system’s processes and resources to support the constraint. This ensures that the constraint’s output is not wasted due to imbalances elsewhere.
  • Elevate the Constraint: If the earlier steps don’t yield sufficient improvement, consider investing in expanding or enhancing the constraint’s capacity.
  • Beware of Inertia: Continuously monitor and improve constraints to prevent complacency and ensure ongoing progress.
• Examples – Practical Application:
  • Steelo: The company identified its delivery system as a constraint rather than the expected welding process. By cross-training employees and optimizing delivery operations, they achieved exceptional responsiveness.
  • Mazda: Facing financial difficulties, Mazda employed the Theory of Constraints and the Critical Chain Project Management method to transform product development, leading to profitability and enhanced agility.
• Goal – Enhancing Profitability: The primary objective of TOC is to improve profitability by identifying, addressing, and ultimately eliminating constraints. By doing so, organizations can enhance their operational efficiency and generate higher revenues.
• Cyclical Process: TOC is an ongoing and cyclical process. Constraints can change over time, and even when one constraint is eliminated, new ones may emerge. Continuous improvement and innovation are essential to avoid becoming complacent.
• Practical Application: TOC can be applied to various industries, including manufacturing, services, and project management. It provides a framework for optimizing processes, identifying bottlenecks, and making strategic decisions that drive business success.

Additional Case Studies

Case Study	Description	Application of Theory of Constraints
“The Goal” at UniCo	Novel by Eliyahu M. Goldratt introducing TOC concepts. Plant manager Alex Rogo applies TOC principles to improve UniCo’s manufacturing plant, addressing production delays and financial struggles.	– Identifying and alleviating bottlenecks – Implementing Five Focusing Steps – Drum-Buffer-Rope scheduling system – Improving on-time deliveries, reducing inventory, and increasing profitability
Southwest Airlines	Known for efficient operations in the airline industry.	– TOC principles applied to optimize aircraft turnaround times – Focusing on quick turnarounds and reducing non-value-added activities
Vanguard Group	Prominent investment management company emphasizing low-cost index funds.	– Applying TOC principles to investment strategies – Minimizing transaction costs and fees
Procter & Gamble (P&G)	Multinational consumer goods company with a vast product portfolio.	– Implementing TOC principles in production and supply chain management – Reducing lead times, improving inventory management, and meeting customer demand more effectively
Intel Corporation	Leading semiconductor manufacturer.	– Using TOC to manage manufacturing processes – Identifying constraints and optimizing production schedules
RBC Bank (Royal Bank of Canada)	Applied TOC principles to enhance customer service in call centers.	– Identifying constraints in call center operations – Streamlining processes, reducing waiting times, and improving the customer experience
Nestlé Waters North America	Bottled water company optimizing production lines.	– Applying TOC to production lines – Reducing changeover times and increasing production capacity – Enhancing responsiveness to customer demand and market changes

Related Concepts	Description	When to Apply
Theory of Constraints (TOC)	The Theory of Constraints (TOC) is a management philosophy and methodology developed by Eliyahu M. Goldratt that focuses on identifying and alleviating constraints or bottlenecks that limit an organization’s ability to achieve its goals. TOC posits that every system has a limiting factor, or constraint, that determines its overall performance, and that optimizing the flow through the constraint is critical for improving system-wide efficiency and effectiveness. TOC emphasizes the importance of identifying, exploiting, and elevating constraints through techniques such as the Five Focusing Steps and the Drum-Buffer-Rope approach, enabling organizations to achieve breakthrough improvements in throughput, lead time, and profitability.	– When improving operational performance or resolving production bottlenecks in organizations. – Particularly in situations where traditional optimization approaches fail to deliver desired results or where system performance is constrained by bottlenecks or limiting factors. TOC provides a systematic framework for diagnosing constraints, developing focused improvement strategies, and optimizing system performance to achieve organizational objectives in operations management, supply chain optimization, and project management initiatives.
Five Focusing Steps	The Five Focusing Steps is a systematic approach outlined in the Theory of Constraints (TOC) for identifying and addressing constraints to improve system performance. The Five Focusing Steps include: 1. Identify the constraint, 2. Exploit the constraint, 3. Subordinate all other activities to the constraint, 4. Elevate the constraint, and 5. Repeat the process if the constraint has shifted. These steps guide organizations in systematically identifying, prioritizing, and mitigating constraints to optimize throughput, reduce lead times, and enhance overall system performance.	– When diagnosing constraints or developing improvement strategies in operations or project management. – Particularly in situations where system performance is limited by bottlenecks or constraints, and there is a need to systematically identify, prioritize, and address constraints to achieve performance improvements. The Five Focusing Steps provide a structured approach for organizations to align their improvement efforts with the most significant constraints and drive continuous improvement in system performance and productivity in operations management, supply chain optimization, and project management initiatives.
Drum-Buffer-Rope (DBR)	The Drum-Buffer-Rope (DBR) is a scheduling and coordination mechanism used in the Theory of Constraints (TOC) to optimize production flow and manage variability in manufacturing environments. DBR identifies the constraint, or “drum,” in the production process and establishes buffers, or “buffers,” before the constraint to protect it from disruptions and ensure continuous flow. The “rope” represents the release of work into the system based on the capacity of the constraint, synchronizing production activities to maximize throughput and minimize lead times. DBR helps organizations improve production scheduling, reduce work-in-progress inventory, and enhance on-time delivery performance by focusing resources on maximizing the throughput of the constraint.	– When synchronizing production activities or reducing lead times in manufacturing operations. – Particularly in environments where production flow is disrupted by bottlenecks or variability, and there is a need to optimize production scheduling and coordination to maximize throughput and minimize lead times. DBR provides a structured approach for organizations to identify constraints, establish buffers, and synchronize production activities to improve system performance and responsiveness in manufacturing operations, supply chain management, and lean production initiatives.
Throughput Accounting	Throughput Accounting is a management accounting approach introduced in the Theory of Constraints (TOC) that focuses on maximizing the rate at which the organization generates money through sales, or throughput, rather than on reducing costs or optimizing resource utilization. Throughput Accounting considers three key performance measures: throughput, operating expenses, and inventory investment, and emphasizes the importance of identifying and leveraging constraints to maximize throughput and profitability. Throughput Accounting provides insights into the financial impact of decisions, helps prioritize activities that contribute to throughput, and aligns organizational goals with performance metrics that drive profitability and value creation.	– When evaluating financial performance or aligning management decisions with organizational goals. – Particularly in situations where traditional cost accounting methods fail to provide insights into the financial impact of decisions or where there is a need to align performance metrics with organizational objectives. Throughput Accounting offers a holistic approach for organizations to measure and manage performance, optimize resource allocation, and drive profitability by focusing on maximizing throughput and value creation in financial management, performance evaluation, and strategic planning initiatives.
Critical Chain Project Management (CCPM)	Critical Chain Project Management (CCPM) is a project management methodology derived from the Theory of Constraints (TOC) that focuses on optimizing project scheduling and execution to maximize throughput and on-time delivery performance. CCPM identifies the critical chain, or the sequence of dependent tasks that determine project duration, and protects it from delays by adding buffers and using aggressive resource scheduling. CCPM emphasizes resource optimization, task prioritization, and buffer management to reduce project lead times, improve project flow, and enhance project success rates. CCPM helps organizations streamline project delivery, mitigate project risks, and achieve project objectives with greater efficiency and reliability by applying TOC principles to project management.	– When managing complex projects or improving project performance in organizations. – Particularly in situations where project timelines are frequently delayed or where there is a need to optimize resource allocation and improve project flow. CCPM provides a structured approach for organizations to identify project constraints, prioritize tasks, and manage project buffers to minimize lead times, enhance project reliability, and increase project success rates in project management, product development, and engineering projects.
Constraint Management	Constraint Management is a systematic approach used in the Theory of Constraints (TOC) to identify, manage, and mitigate constraints that limit system performance and productivity. Constraint management involves analyzing system processes, identifying bottlenecks or constraints, and implementing strategies to exploit, elevate, or eliminate constraints to improve overall system performance. Constraint management techniques include bottleneck analysis, capacity planning, and constraint relaxation, aimed at optimizing resource utilization, reducing cycle times, and increasing throughput in operations and production systems.	– When optimizing system performance or resolving production bottlenecks in organizations. – Particularly in situations where system performance is constrained by bottlenecks or where there is a need to improve throughput and productivity. Constraint Management provides a structured approach for organizations to diagnose constraints, develop focused improvement strategies, and optimize system performance to achieve organizational objectives in operations management, supply chain optimization, and production planning initiatives.
Buffer Management	Buffer Management is a technique used in the Theory of Constraints (TOC) to manage variability and protect system performance from disruptions caused by constraints or fluctuations in demand. Buffer management involves strategically placing buffers, or reserves of capacity, before and after the constraint to absorb variability and ensure continuous flow through the system. Buffers can take various forms, such as time buffers, inventory buffers, or resource buffers, depending on the nature of the constraint and the system dynamics. Buffer management helps organizations reduce the impact of disruptions, improve system reliability, and enhance throughput by strategically managing capacity and flow in operations and production systems.	– When managing variability or improving system reliability in operations or production systems. – Particularly in environments where system performance is affected by fluctuations in demand or disruptions caused by constraints. Buffer Management provides a structured approach for organizations to deploy buffers, monitor buffer status, and adjust buffer sizes to mitigate risks, enhance system responsiveness, and optimize throughput in operations management, supply chain optimization, and lean production initiatives.
Goldratt’s Rules of Production Scheduling	Goldratt’s Rules of Production Scheduling are a set of guidelines derived from the Theory of Constraints (TOC) that provide principles for optimizing production scheduling and managing workflow in manufacturing environments. Goldratt’s Rules include: 1. Balance flow, not capacity, 2. Utilize the constraint, 3. Subordinate all other operations to the constraint, 4. Elevate the constraint, and 5. Do not let inertia set in. These rules help organizations prioritize production activities, synchronize operations, and optimize throughput by focusing on maximizing the performance of the constraint and aligning workflow with system capacity and demand. Goldratt’s Rules provide a structured approach for organizations to improve production scheduling, reduce lead times, and enhance overall system performance in manufacturing operations and production planning initiatives.	– When scheduling production activities or optimizing manufacturing workflows in organizations. – Particularly in situations where production scheduling is complex or where there is a need to improve throughput and reduce lead times. Goldratt’s Rules provide practical guidelines for organizations to align production activities with system constraints, optimize resource utilization, and improve production efficiency in manufacturing operations, supply chain management, and lean production initiatives.
TOC Thinking Processes	TOC Thinking Processes are a set of analytical tools and methodologies used in the Theory of Constraints (TOC) to identify, analyze, and solve complex problems in organizations. TOC Thinking Processes include techniques such as the Current Reality Tree (CRT), the Evaporating Cloud (EC), and the Future Reality Tree (FRT), which help organizations clarify objectives, diagnose root causes, and develop effective solutions to overcome obstacles and achieve desired outcomes. TOC Thinking Processes facilitate systems thinking, creative problem-solving, and decision-making by providing structured approaches for addressing complex challenges and improving organizational performance.	– When analyzing complex problems or developing improvement strategies in organizations. – Particularly in situations where traditional problem-solving methods fail to address root causes or where there is a need to think systemically and develop holistic solutions. TOC Thinking Processes offer powerful tools for organizations to clarify goals, identify constraints, and generate innovative solutions to overcome obstacles and achieve breakthrough improvements in operations management, project management, and strategic planning initiatives.
TOC Supply Chain Management	TOC Supply Chain Management applies the principles and methodologies of the Theory of Constraints (TOC) to optimize supply chain operations and improve overall supply chain performance. TOC Supply Chain Management focuses on identifying and managing constraints in the supply chain, synchronizing activities across the value chain, and aligning inventory levels with demand variability to enhance throughput and responsiveness. TOC Supply Chain Management techniques include constraint identification, buffer management, and demand-driven replenishment, aimed at reducing lead times, increasing on-time delivery, and maximizing supply chain efficiency and profitability.	– When optimizing supply chain operations or improving supply chain performance in organizations. – Particularly in environments where supply chain performance is constrained by bottlenecks or where there is a need to synchronize activities and reduce lead times. TOC Supply Chain Management offers a systematic approach for organizations to diagnose constraints, streamline operations, and optimize inventory management to achieve supply chain agility, resilience, and competitiveness in supply chain optimization, logistics management, and demand fulfillment initiatives.

Related Business Matrices

Failure Mode And Effects Analysis

Agile Business Analysis

Business Valuation

Paired Comparison Analysis

Monte Carlo Analysis

Cost-Benefit Analysis

CATWOE Analysis

VTDF Framework

Pareto Analysis

Comparable Analysis

SWOT Analysis

PESTEL Analysis

Business Analysis

Financial Structure

Financial Modeling

Value Investing

Buffet Indicator

Financial Analysis

Post-Mortem Analysis

Retrospective Analysis

Root Cause Analysis

Blindspot Analysis

Break-even Analysis

Decision Analysis

DESTEP Analysis

STEEP Analysis

STEEPLE Analysis

Related Strategy Concepts: Go-To-Market Strategy, Marketing Strategy, Business Models, Tech Business Models, Jobs-To-Be Done, Design Thinking, Lean Startup Canvas, Value Chain, Value Proposition Canvas, Balanced Scorecard, Business Model Canvas, SWOT Analysis, Growth Hacking, Bundling, Unbundling, Bootstrapping, Venture Capital, Porter’s Five Forces, Porter’s Generic Strategies, Porter’s Five Forces, PESTEL Analysis, SWOT, Porter’s Diamond Model, Ansoff, Technology Adoption Curve, TOWS, SOAR, Balanced Scorecard, OKR, Agile Methodology, Value Proposition, VTDF Framework, BCG Matrix, GE McKinsey Matrix, Kotter’s 8-Step Change Mod

Read Also: RAPID Framework, RACI Matrix, 3×3 Sales Matrix, Value/effort Matrix, SFA matrix, Value/Risk Matrix, Reframing Matrix, Kepner-Tregoe Matrix.

Additional resources:

• Successful Types of Business Models You Need to Know
• The Complete Guide To Business Development
• Business Strategy: Definition, Examples, And Case Studies
• What Is a Value Proposition? Value Proposition Canvas Explained
• Marketing Strategy: Definition, Types, And Examples
• Market Segmentation