Porter’s five forces is a strategic framework to assess the competitiveness in a specific industry. Where Porter’s diamond model is a framework to assess why specific industries become internationally competitive, both frameworks can be used in conjunction to have a wider perspective on the competitive landscape surrounding an industry.
Aspect
Porter’s Five Forces
Diamond Model
Definition
Porter’s Five Forces is a framework for analyzing the competitive forces within an industry that shape an organization’s strategy and profitability. It helps identify the attractiveness of an industry.
The Diamond Model, developed by Michael Porter, is a comprehensive framework that focuses on the competitive advantage of nations or regions. It explores the interconnectedness of factors that contribute to a nation’s competitiveness in specific industries.
Focus
Porter’s Five Forces is primarily focused on understanding the competitive dynamics within an industry, such as the intensity of rivalry, the threat of new entrants, the power of buyers and suppliers, and the threat of substitutes.
The Diamond Model zooms out to consider the broader context of a nation or region. It examines how factors like government policies, factor conditions, demand conditions, related and supporting industries, and firm strategy, structure, and rivalry collectively influence a nation’s competitive advantage.
Components
Porter’s Five Forces comprises five main components: – Rivalry among Existing Competitors: Assessing the intensity of competition within the industry. – Threat of New Entrants: Evaluating the ease with which new competitors can enter the market. – Bargaining Power of Suppliers: Analyzing the influence suppliers have over firms. – Bargaining Power of Buyers: Assessing the influence buyers have over firms. – Threat of Substitutes: Examining the availability of substitute products or services.
The Diamond Model consists of four interconnected factors, often represented as a diamond: – Factor Conditions: Refers to the nation’s factors of production, such as labor, capital, infrastructure, and technology. – Demand Conditions: Focuses on the characteristics and sophistication of local demand, including the size and composition of the domestic market. – Related and Supporting Industries: Looks at the presence and competitiveness of industries that are related to and support the target industry. – Firm Strategy, Structure, and Rivalry: Examines the conditions that affect how companies compete in the target industry, including management practices and competitive intensity.
Timing Considerations
Porter’s Five Forces can be applied at any time to assess the industry’s competitive dynamics. It is often used to inform strategic decisions and evaluate the attractiveness of an industry.
The Diamond Model is typically used to assess the long-term competitiveness of a nation or region in specific industries. It considers factors that evolve more slowly and are less subject to short-term fluctuations.
Strategic Focus
Porter’s Five Forces guides firms in developing strategies to gain a competitive advantage within their industry. It helps firms understand their position relative to competitors.
The Diamond Model is often used by governments and policymakers to shape policies and initiatives that enhance a nation’s or region’s competitive advantage in specific industries. It focuses on improving the broader environment for industries to thrive.
Use in Different Contexts
Porter’s Five Forces is widely used in business strategy and market analysis across various industries and sectors.
The Diamond Model is often employed in economic development, international trade, and regional planning to assess a nation’s or region’s competitive advantage and inform policy decisions.
Limitations
– Porter’s Five Forces may oversimplify industry dynamics. – It may not consider the interplay of factors outside the industry. – It might not account for rapid changes in technology or other external factors.
– The Diamond Model may require extensive data and research to assess all four factors comprehensively. – It may not provide immediate tactical guidance for businesses. – The model’s effectiveness depends on the quality of data and analysis used to assess each factor.
Application Levels
Porter’s Five Forces can be applied at various levels, including the corporate, business unit, and industry levels.
The Diamond Model is typically used at the national or regional level to evaluate competitiveness across multiple industries and sectors.
Decision-Making Framework
Porter’s Five Forces provides a framework for analyzing an industry’s competitive forces and informing decisions related to market entry, pricing, and competitive strategy.
The Diamond Model informs policymakers and governments about the factors influencing a nation’s or region’s competitiveness. It guides the development of policies and initiatives aimed at enhancing long-term competitiveness.
Competitive Advantage
Porter’s Five Forces helps businesses identify sources of competitive advantage within their industry and develop strategies to leverage or mitigate the identified forces.
The Diamond Model addresses a nation’s or region’s competitive advantage by examining how multiple factors interact to create a favorable environment for industries to excel. It guides efforts to enhance national or regional competitiveness.
Examples of Benefits
– A smartphone manufacturer may use Porter’s Five Forces to assess the competitive landscape and identify strategies to differentiate its products. – An e-commerce company might apply the framework to evaluate the bargaining power of its suppliers and devise supply chain strategies.
– A national government may use the Diamond Model to assess the competitiveness of its automotive industry and implement policies to improve factor conditions, demand conditions, or related industries to attract foreign investment. – A regional economic development agency may leverage the model to identify sectors where the region has a competitive advantage and prioritize investments accordingly.
Porter’s Five Forces is a model that helps organizations better understand their industries and competition. Professor Michael Porter published for the first time in his book “Competitive Strategy” in the 1980s. The model breaks down industries and markets by analyzing them through five forces.
Porter’s Diamond Model is a diamond-shaped framework that explains why specific industries in a nation become internationally competitive while those in other nations do not. The model was first published in Michael Porter’s 1990 book The Competitive Advantage of Nations. This framework looks at the firm strategy, structure/rivalry, factor conditions, demand conditions, related and supporting industries.
Similarities:
Developed by Michael Porter: Both frameworks are creations of Professor Michael Porter, a prominent strategist and economist.
Strategic Analysis: Both tools provide strategic insights to businesses and nations.
Porter’s Five Forces guide businesses in formulating competitive strategies.
Porter’s Diamond Model helps governments and policymakers foster competitive industries.
Competitive Landscape: Both frameworks focus on understanding competitive dynamics.
Porter’s Five Forces assess the industry’s competitive forces.
Porter’s Diamond Model explains why certain industries succeed in specific nations.
Differences:
Scope of Analysis: Porter’s Five Forces analyze a specific industry’s competitive environment.
Porter’s Diamond Model examines why industries in a nation become internationally competitive.
Level of Analysis: Porter’s Five Forces operate at the industry level.
Porter’s Diamond Model operates at the country or nation level.
Forces vs. Determinants: Porter’s Five Forces examine five competitive forces within an industry.
Porter’s Diamond Model considers four determinants contributing to international competitiveness.
Publication Years: Porter’s Five Forces was introduced in the 1980s.
Porter’s Diamond Model was published in 1990.
Purpose: Porter’s Five Forces help businesses understand their market position and make strategic decisions.
Porter’s Diamond Model helps nations identify competitive advantages and develop policies to support industries.
Application:
Porter’s Diamond Model is relevant for policymakers shaping economic policies and fostering competitive industries.
Porter’s Five Forces are useful for businesses conducting industry analysis and formulating strategies.
Porter’s Five Forces Examples:
Automobile Industry:
Rivalry among existing competitors: Intense competition among major global players like Toyota, Ford, General Motors, Volkswagen, and Honda.
Threat of new entrants: Moderate, given the high capital requirements and regulatory barriers.
Threat of substitute products: Increasing, with the rise of electric vehicles, ride-sharing, and public transportation.
Bargaining power of buyers: Moderate, as buyers can choose from multiple brands but face costs switching between them.
Bargaining power of suppliers: Moderate, with suppliers providing parts, but major companies often have multiple suppliers to choose from.
Smartphone Industry:
Rivalry among existing competitors: Intense, with major brands like Apple, Samsung, Huawei, and Google competing for market share.
Threat of new entrants: Low, due to high development costs and brand loyalty.
Threat of substitute products: Low, as other devices like tablets and PCs serve different primary purposes.
Bargaining power of buyers: High, with many options and frequent product launches.
Bargaining power of suppliers: Moderate, as companies like Apple are vertically integrated and produce many components in-house.
Airline Industry:
Rivalry among existing competitors: High, with many airlines offering similar routes and services.
Threat of new entrants: Low, due to high capital and operational costs.
Threat of substitute products: Moderate, with alternatives like trains or buses for shorter routes.
Bargaining power of buyers: High, especially with online platforms comparing prices.
Bargaining power of suppliers: High, especially for airplane manufacturers like Boeing and Airbus.
Porter’s Diamond Model Examples:
Wine Production in France:
Factor Conditions: Favorable climate, terrain, and soil for grape cultivation.
Demand Conditions: Local appreciation and knowledge of wine, driving quality and innovation.
Related and Supporting Industries: Presence of cork manufacturers, bottle producers, and wine research institutions.
Firm Strategy, Structure, and Rivalry: Strong competition among local wine producers driving quality.
Tech Industry in Silicon Valley, USA:
Factor Conditions: High concentration of tech talent, universities, and research institutions.
Demand Conditions: Local market is tech-savvy and quick to adopt innovations.
Related and Supporting Industries: Abundance of venture capital firms, suppliers, and specialized services for tech companies.
Firm Strategy, Structure, and Rivalry: Intense competition among startups and tech giants alike, fostering innovation.
Automobile Manufacturing in Germany:
Factor Conditions: Skilled workforce, advanced infrastructure, and engineering heritage.
Demand Conditions: High domestic demand for quality and performance-driven cars.
Related and Supporting Industries: Network of suppliers providing high-quality automobile parts.
Firm Strategy, Structure, and Rivalry: Strong competition among brands like BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and Volkswagen, driving excellence.
Key Highlights:
Foundational Concepts:
Porter’s Five Forces: Framework to analyze the competitiveness of an industry.
Porter’s Diamond Model: Framework to understand why certain industries in specific nations are internationally competitive.
Origins:
Both frameworks were developed by Michael E. Porter.
Similarities:
Strategic Analysis: Both provide strategic perspectives – Five Forces for businesses, Diamond Model for nations.
Understanding Competition: Both aim to delve into competitive dynamics, be it at the industry or national level.
Differences:
Scope:
Five Forces: Industry-specific.
Diamond Model: Nation-specific, considering why particular industries in a nation excel.
Level:
Five Forces: Industry level.
Diamond Model: Country or national level.
Framework Components:
Five Forces: Examines competition through five forces.
Diamond Model: Considers four determinants of national advantage.
Publication:
Five Forces: Introduced in the 1980s.
Diamond Model: Presented in 1990.
Primary Use:
Five Forces: For businesses to understand market positioning and strategize.
Diamond Model: For nations to identify and cultivate competitive advantages.
Applications:
Porter’s Diamond Model: Relevant for national policymakers and those looking to shape economic strategies.
Porter’s Five Forces: Crucial for businesses aiming to understand their industry landscape and craft effective competitive strategies.
The ADKAR model is a management tool designed to assist employees and businesses in transitioning through organizational change. To maximize the chances of employees embracing change, the ADKAR model was developed by author and engineer Jeff Hiatt in 2003. The model seeks to guide people through the change process and importantly, ensure that people do not revert to habitual ways of operating after some time has passed.
You can use the Ansoff Matrix as a strategic framework to understand what growthstrategy is more suited based on the market context. Developed by mathematician and business manager Igor Ansoff, it assumes a growthstrategy can be derived from whether the market is new or existing, and whether the product is new or existing.
The business model canvas is a framework proposed by Alexander Osterwalder and Yves Pigneur in Busines Model Generation enabling the design of business models through nine building blocks comprising: key partners, key activities, value propositions, customer relationships, customer segments, critical resources, channels, cost structure, and revenue streams.
The lean startup canvas is an adaptation by Ash Maurya of the business model canvas by Alexander Osterwalder, which adds a layer that focuses on problems, solutions, key metrics, unfair advantage based, and a unique value proposition. Thus, starting from mastering the problem rather than the solution.
The Blitzscaling business model canvas is a model based on the concept of Blitzscaling, which is a particular process of massive growth under uncertainty, and that prioritizes speed over efficiency and focuses on market domination to create a first-scaler advantage in a scenario of uncertainty.
A blue ocean is a strategy where the boundaries of existing markets are redefined, and new uncontested markets are created. At its core, there is valueinnovation, for which uncontested markets are created, where competition is made irrelevant. And the cost-value trade-off is broken. Thus, companies following a blue ocean strategy offer much more value at a lower cost for the end customers.
Business analysis is a research discipline that helps driving change within an organization by identifying the key elements and processes that drive value. Business analysis can also be used in Identifying new business opportunities or how to take advantage of existing business opportunities to grow your business in the marketplace.
In the 1970s, Bruce D. Henderson, founder of the Boston Consulting Group, came up with The Product Portfolio (aka BCG Matrix, or Growth-share Matrix), which would look at a successful business product portfolio based on potential growth and market shares. It divided products into four main categories: cash cows, pets (dogs), question marks, and stars.
First proposed by accounting academic Robert Kaplan, the balanced scorecard is a management system that allows an organization to focus on big-picture strategic goals. The four perspectives of the balanced scorecard include financial, customer, business process, and organizational capacity. From there, according to the balanced scorecard, it’s possible to have a holistic view of the business.
A blue ocean is a strategy where the boundaries of existing markets are redefined, and new uncontested markets are created. At its core, there is valueinnovation, for which uncontested markets are created, where competition is made irrelevant. And the cost-value trade-off is broken. Thus, companies following a blue ocean strategy offer much more value at a lower cost for the end customers.
A gap analysis helps an organization assess its alignment with strategic objectives to determine whether the current execution is in line with the company’s mission and long-term vision. Gap analyses then help reach a target performance by assisting organizations to use their resources better. A good gap analysis is a powerful tool to improve execution.
The GE McKinsey Matrix was developed in the 1970s after General Electric asked its consultant McKinsey to develop a portfolio managementmodel. This matrix is a strategy tool that provides guidance on how a corporation should prioritize its investments among its business units, leading to three possible scenarios: invest, protect, harvest, and divest.
The McKinsey 7-S Model was developed in the late 1970s by Robert Waterman and Thomas Peters, who were consultants at McKinsey & Company. Waterman and Peters created seven key internal elements that inform a business of how well positioned it is to achieve its goals, based on three hard elements and four soft elements.
McKinsey’s Seven Degrees of Freedom for Growth is a strategy tool. Developed by partners at McKinsey and Company, the tool helps businesses understand which opportunities will contribute to expansion, and therefore it helps to prioritize those initiatives.
The McKinsey Horizon Model helps a business focus on innovation and growth. The model is a strategy framework divided into three broad categories, otherwise known as horizons. Thus, the framework is sometimes referred to as McKinsey’s Three Horizons of Growth.
Porter’s Five Forces is a model that helps organizations to gain a better understanding of their industries and competition. Published for the first time by Professor Michael Porter in his book “Competitive Strategy” in the 1980s. The model breaks down industries and markets by analyzing them through five forces.
According to Michael Porter, a competitive advantage, in a given industry could be pursued in two key ways: low cost (cost leadership), or differentiation. A third generic strategy is focus. According to Porter a failure to do so would end up stuck in the middle scenario, where the company will not retain a long-term competitive advantage.
In his 1985 book Competitive Advantage, Porter explains that a value chain is a collection of processes that a company performs to create value for its consumers. As a result, he asserts that value chain analysis is directly linked to competitive advantage. Porter’s Value Chain Model is a strategic management tool developed by Harvard Business School professor Michael Porter. The tool analyses a company’s value chain – defined as the combination of processes that the company uses to make money.
Porter’s Diamond Model is a diamond-shaped framework that explains why specific industries in a nation become internationally competitive while those in other nations do not. The model was first published in Michael Porter’s 1990 book The Competitive Advantage of Nations. This framework looks at the firm strategy, structure/rivalry, factor conditions, demand conditions, related and supporting industries.
A SWOT Analysis is a framework used for evaluating the business‘s Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. It can aid in identifying the problematic areas of your business so that you can maximize your opportunities. It will also alert you to the challenges your organization might face in the future.
Businesses use scenario planning to make assumptions on future events and how their respective business environments may change in response to those future events. Therefore, scenario planning identifies specific uncertainties – or different realities and how they might affect future business operations. Scenario planning attempts at better strategic decision making by avoiding two pitfalls: underprediction, and overprediction.
The STEEPLE analysis is a variation of the STEEP analysis. Where the step analysis comprises socio-cultural, technological, economic, environmental/ecological, and political factors as the base of the analysis. The STEEPLE analysis adds other two factors such as Legal and Ethical.
A SWOT Analysis is a framework used for evaluating the business’s Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. It can aid in identifying the problematic areas of your business so that you can maximize your opportunities. It will also alert you to the challenges your organization might face in the future.
Gennaro is the creator of FourWeekMBA, which reached about four million business people, comprising C-level executives, investors, analysts, product managers, and aspiring digital entrepreneurs in 2022 alone | He is also Director of Sales for a high-tech scaleup in the AI Industry | In 2012, Gennaro earned an International MBA with emphasis on Corporate Finance and Business Strategy.
Discover more from FourWeekMBA
Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.
