A Ponzi scheme is an investment scam where existing investors generate returns via money collected from new investors. The scam was named after Charles Ponzi, an Italian con artist who promised a 50% return within 45 days or a 100% return within 90 days on postal coupons in the 1920s. When something changes hands without a core underlying product or service, it might fall under a Ponzi scheme, thus requiring caution from potential investors.
Aspect
Explanation
Ponzi Scheme
A Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investment scheme where returns to earlier investors are paid using the capital of newer investors, rather than from legitimate profits. It is named after Charles Ponzi, who became infamous for running such a scheme in the early 20th century.
Modus Operandi
In a Ponzi scheme, the operator or promoter promises high, consistent, and often unrealistic returns to investors. These returns are typically much higher than what can be earned through legitimate investments.
Early investors may receive the promised returns, which creates a false sense of legitimacy and attracts more investors. However, the operator uses the capital from new investors to pay returns to earlier participants, creating a cycle of dependency on new investments.
Characteristics
Ponzi schemes often lack a legitimate underlying business or investment activity. Instead, they rely on the constant influx of new investor funds to sustain the illusion of profitability.
Promoters may use various tactics to attract investors, including offering referral bonuses, using charismatic sales pitches, and creating the appearance of a successful enterprise.
Ponzi schemes typically collapse when the operator cannot attract enough new investments to pay returns to earlier investors, or when authorities intervene and uncover the fraud. Investors at the bottom of the pyramid often lose their entire investment.
Legal Consequences
Operating a Ponzi scheme is illegal in most countries. Individuals found guilty of running Ponzi schemes can face criminal charges, including fraud, and may be subject to imprisonment and financial penalties.
Infamous Cases
Charles Ponzi’s scheme in the early 20th century is one of the most famous Ponzi schemes in history. More recent examples include the Bernie Madoff scandal, which was one of the largest and most notorious Ponzi schemes, defrauding investors of billions of dollars.
Warning Signs
Investors should be cautious of investment opportunities that promise guaranteed high returns with little or no risk. Lack of transparency, pressure to recruit new investors, and vague explanations of how profits are generated are all red flags.
Prevention
To protect themselves, investors should conduct due diligence, research the legitimacy of investment opportunities, and seek advice from financial professionals. Regulatory authorities also play a role in detecting and preventing Ponzi schemes.
Impact
Ponzi schemes can cause significant financial losses for investors, destroy trust in financial systems, and have far-reaching economic and social consequences. They often leave victims with little hope of recovering their investments.
Table of Contents
Understanding a Ponzi scheme
A Ponzi scheme is an investment scam where existing investors are paid with funds collected from new investors.
Though author Charles Dickens had written about similar scams as early as 1844, Ponzi received considerable press coverage on his arrest and he would be forever associated with the scheme.
The most nefarious element of a Ponzi scheme is the belief held by victims that profits are coming from proper business activities such as product sales or investment returns. In the process, they remain unaware that other victims are the source of the funds.
Ponzi schemes operators focus most of their efforts on attracting new investors.
The scheme may run for as long as people continue to invest and are satisfied to the extent that they do not ask to cash out their investments.
Characteristics of a Ponzi scheme
In truth, many Ponzi schemes share a few common characteristics. These include:
Consistent (out of the market) returns
Legitimate investments tend to fluctuate in value as market values increase and decrease.
In a Ponzi scheme, the investment appears to generate positive returns irrespective of market conditions.
Unlicensed sellers (usually not officially recognized)
Investment professionals are required under various state and federal laws to be registered.
Many Ponzi schemes involve unlicensed investors who may claim to be representatives of a real or imagined company.
Difficulty receiving payments (illiquidity)
Despite the apparent success of the scheme, it can be difficult for participants to cash out their investment or realize gains.
Some promoters may tempt them to remain in the scheme with the lure of higher returns in the future.
Secretive or sophisticated strategies (opacity)
The way con artists profit from the Ponzi Scheme is quite simple, but they describe the investment strategy to victims in terms or processes that are difficult to understand.
Others will be vague or tell the individual to keep the investment a secret from family and friends.
Ponzi scheme examples
In the years since Charles Ponzi, investors continue to fall victim to Ponzi schemes despite increased awareness and information around the technique.
Here are just a few examples from the 21st century:
Gerald Payne
Greater Ministries International was an Evangelical Christian ministry headed by Gerald Payne.
Stockbroker and investment adviser Bernie Madoff operated a Ponzi scheme in the asset management unit of his firm Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities.
FTX seemed to be the most successful crypto trading platform in the world until it turned out to be a big fraud.
FTX is a cryptocurrency exchange platform headquartered in the Bahamas but incorporated in Antigua and Barbuda. The platform was founded by Sam Bankman-Fried who became inspired to make money for the greater social good while studying at MIT.
On a mobile-based trading app, retail and institutional traders can buy and sell futures, options, leveraged tokens, fiat currency, cryptocurrency, and non-fungible tokens (NFTs). Users can receive discounts on trading fees by using the native token FTT.
FTX makes money through various trading fees, including maker fees, taker fees, NFT fees, and margin borrower interest. The company also charges interest on its institutional loan service and collects a fee from merchants that want to accept cryptocurrency as a form of payment.
Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF), defrauded billion of dollars, diverting funds that users had deposited to its platform to another research firm he owned which used those to place wild bets.
The Ponzi Scheme here came in the form of a token called FTT, which was used to create fake liquidity, and enabled SBF to take on a huge amount of loaned money to keep obliterating its Ponzi scheme.
The fact that SBF was running a Ponzi Scheme operation became clear to some already a few months before the FTX collapse.
Zeek Rewards: Zeek Rewards, founded by Paul Burks, was an investment opportunity linked to a penny auction site. The company promised daily returns on investments, which were actually funded by newer investors. The scheme collected over $600 million from investors before the SEC shut it down in 2012.
Stanford Financial Group: Founded by Allen Stanford, this company offered certificates of deposit (CDs) from its bank in Antigua, promising consistent, above-market returns. It turned out that the bank was investing in illiquid assets, including real estate and private equity, rather than the liquid assets it claimed. The scheme collapsed in 2009, with investors losing billions.
Bitconnect: In the cryptocurrency space, Bitconnect promised its investors up to 40% monthly returns through a lending program. They asked users to buy their Bitconnect tokens with Bitcoin and then earn interest on lending them out. The company relied on new capital to pay out the promised returns until it collapsed in 2018, leading to losses of up to $1 billion.
MMM: Founded by Sergei Mavrodi, MMM operated in Russia during the 1990s. It promised returns of 100% per month and used aggressive advertising campaigns to attract investors. At its peak, it was estimated to have millions of investors. When it collapsed, it led to widespread protests and financial ruin for many.
AdSurfDaily: Run by Thomas A. Bowdoin Jr., AdSurfDaily promised its members daily returns for viewing ads online. It operated by taking money from new members to pay returns to earlier members. The scheme attracted over $100 million before it was shut down by U.S. authorities.
Lou Pearlman: Known for managing famous boy bands like NSYNC and Backstreet Boys, Lou Pearlman also ran one of the largest and longest-running Ponzi schemes in U.S. history. He defrauded investors, including friends and family, out of over $300 million by selling them shares in fictitious companies.
TelexFree: Originally founded in Brazil, TelexFree entered the U.S. market in 2012. It claimed to sell VoIP telephone service and promised massive returns for those who invested and recruited others. The company amassed over a billion dollars before being shut down as a Ponzi scheme.
Charles Dickens’ “Martin Chuzzlewit”: While this is fictional, it provides an early insight into Ponzi schemes. In this novel, the character Montague Tigg starts the Anglo-Bengalee Disinterested Loan and Life Assurance Company, which promises high returns but relies on new investments to pay off the old ones.
Caritas: A Romanian Ponzi scheme from the 1990s which promised eightfold returns on investments in six months. It attracted almost 400,000 investors and collected over $1 billion before its collapse.
Emgoldex/Global Intergold: This company promised high returns for buying gold from them and recruiting others to do the same. It operated in multiple countries and defrauded thousands of investors before being shut down.
Key takeaways
A Ponzi scheme is an investment scam where existing investors are paid with funds collected from new investors.
Some of the common characteristics of Ponzi schemes include consistent returns, unlicensed sellers, difficulty receiving payments, and secretive or sophisticated investment strategies.
Ponzi schemes continue to occur in the modern age despite increased awareness around the practice. Investment adviser Bernie Madoff is the most notable example having collected almost $65 billion over many decades.
Key Insights
What is a Ponzi Scheme: A fraudulent investment scam where returns to existing investors are paid using money collected from new investors.
Ponzi Scheme Origin: Named after Charles Ponzi, an Italian con artist who conducted a high-profile scam in the 1920s, promising extraordinary returns on postal coupons.
Nefarious Element of Ponzi Scheme: Victims believe profits come from legitimate business activities, unaware that new investors fund the payouts.
Characteristics of Ponzi Schemes: Consistent returns regardless of market conditions, involvement of unlicensed sellers, difficulty in receiving payments, and use of secretive or sophisticated strategies.
Ponzi Scheme Examples:
Gerald Payne: Ran a Ponzi scheme through Greater Ministries International, defrauding investors of nearly $500 million.
Bernie Madoff: Operated the largest Ponzi scheme in history, collecting around $65 billion from thousands of investors.
Scott Rothstein: Used his law firm to scam investors of $1.2 billion in fake legal settlements.
FTX and SBF: FTX, a crypto trading platform founded by Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF), turned out to be a Ponzi scheme, creating an $8-9 billion hole.
Continued Occurrence: Despite increased awareness, Ponzi schemes continue to victimize investors in the modern age. Bernie Madoff’s case is a notable example, lasting for decades.
Ponzi Scheme
Operator
Case Study Description
Charles Ponzi
Charles Ponzi
The “Ponzi Scheme” is named after Charles Ponzi, who ran a fraudulent investment scheme in the early 20th century, promising returns from international reply coupons but using new investments to pay earlier investors.
Bernie Madoff
Bernard Madoff
Bernie Madoff orchestrated one of the largest Ponzi schemes in history, defrauding investors of billions of dollars over several decades by promising consistent, high returns through a fictitious investment strategy.
Enron
Enron Corporation
While not a traditional Ponzi scheme, the Enron scandal involved corporate fraud, with Enron executives inflating profits and hiding debt to maintain stock prices, leading to significant investor losses.
Stanford Financial Group
R. Allen Stanford
R. Allen Stanford operated a Ponzi scheme through his financial group, offering fraudulent certificates of deposit (CDs) with promised high returns. It resulted in billions of dollars in losses for investors.
Zeek Rewards
Paul Burks
Paul Burks ran Zeek Rewards, an online Ponzi scheme, promising investors returns through a penny auction website. The SEC shut it down after discovering the fraud.
TelexFree
TelexFree
TelexFree was a multi-billion dollar Ponzi scheme in which the company promised high returns for promoting its VoIP service. It collapsed, impacting thousands of investors.
OneCoin
Ruja Ignatova
OneCoin operated as a cryptocurrency Ponzi scheme, with Ruja Ignatova at the helm. Investors were promised profits through a non-existent blockchain and cryptocurrency.
Woodbridge Group
Robert Shapiro
The Woodbridge Group, led by Robert Shapiro, defrauded investors by selling unregistered securities disguised as real estate investments, resulting in a $1.2 billion Ponzi scheme.
MMM Global
Sergey Mavrodi
MMM Global was a global Ponzi scheme founded by Sergey Mavrodi, promising high returns through a fraudulent financial pyramid. It caused financial devastation in multiple countries.
BitClub Network
Matthew Brent Goettsche
BitClub Network operated as a Ponzi scheme within the cryptocurrency space, defrauding investors of millions by promising mining pool returns.
PlusToken
Unknown Operators
PlusToken was a cryptocurrency Ponzi scheme that swindled billions of dollars from unsuspecting investors before the operators were arrested.
A business incubator is an organization that helps start-up companies or entrepreneurs develop their businesses. Assistance usually takes the form of dedicated office space, management training, and venture capital funding. According to the National Business Incubation Association, there are more than 1,400 incubators in the United States.
An angel investor is usually a high net-worth individual who invests in early-stage start-ups in exchange for equity in the company. Angel investors are wealthy private investors focused on financing small business ventures in exchange for an equity stake. Unlike a venture capital firm, an angel investor invests their own capital during the early stages of a start-up when the risk of failure is relatively high, yet it might in the long-term unlock higher rates of return.
A venture capitalist generally invests in companies and startups which are still in a stage where their business model needs to be proved viable, or they need resources to scale up. Thus, those companies present high risks, but the potential for exponential growth. Therefore, venture capitalists look for startups that can bring a high ROI and high valuation multiples.
Economic or market moats represent the long-term business defensibility. Or how long a business can retain its competitive advantage in the marketplace over the years. Warren Buffet who popularized the term “moat” referred to it as a share of mind, opposite to market share, as such it is the characteristic that all valuable brands have.
Meme stocks are securities that go viral online and attract the attention of the younger generation of retail investors. Meme investing, therefore, is a bottom-up, community-driven approach to investing that positions itself as the antonym to Wall Street investing. Also, meme investing often looks at attractive opportunities with lower liquidity that might be easier to overtake, thus enabling wide speculation, as “meme investors” often look for disproportionate short-term returns.
Payment for order flow consists of a “kickback” or commission that the broker routing customers to a market maker (in charge of enabling the bid and ask price) will pay a commission to the broker as a sort of market-making fee.
A special purpose acquisition company (SPAC) is a company with no commercial operations that are created to raise capital through an IPO to acquire another company. The SPAC is also called for that reason a “blank check company” as it will use the money provided by investors to enable private companies to go public via the SPAC.
The Pac-Man defense is a tactic used by a company that is the subject of a hostile takeover. The Pac-Man defense is a response to a hostile takeover attempt with another hostile takeover attempt. In essence, the company that was the subject of the original takeover turns the tables on the acquiring company by trying to take it over in turn.
Gennaro is the creator of FourWeekMBA, which reached about four million business people, comprising C-level executives, investors, analysts, product managers, and aspiring digital entrepreneurs in 2022 alone | He is also Director of Sales for a high-tech scaleup in the AI Industry | In 2012, Gennaro earned an International MBA with emphasis on Corporate Finance and Business Strategy.
