Disciplined Agile was first developed at IBM in 2009 and then introduced to the mainstream in a 2012 book entitled Disciplined Agile Delivery. Disciplined Agile (DA) is a people-first process decision toolkit with a focus on learning and the streamlining of internal processes.
| Aspect | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Concept Overview | – Disciplined Agile (DA) is a process decision framework that provides a comprehensive approach to agile and lean practices for organizations. It offers guidance on how to select and tailor agile and lean approaches to fit specific context and needs. Developed by Scott W. Ambler and Mark Lines, DA goes beyond a one-size-fits-all approach, recognizing that different situations require different strategies. It integrates several popular agile and lean methods, such as Scrum, Kanban, and SAFe, into a coherent framework. |
| Key Principles | – Disciplined Agile is guided by several key principles: 1. Choice: DA offers a range of choices and options for teams and organizations to tailor their approach. 2. Flexibility: It recognizes that different situations require different strategies and adapts accordingly. 3. Pragmatism: DA promotes practical solutions that align with organizational goals and constraints. 4. Context Matters: The framework emphasizes that context, including team size, geographic distribution, and regulatory environment, influences process choices. 5. Enterprise Awareness: DA considers the needs of the entire organization and provides strategies for scaling agile practices. 6. Full Delivery Lifecycle: It addresses the entire delivery lifecycle, from ideation to delivery to operations. |
| DA Disciplines | – Disciplined Agile encompasses various disciplines, including: 1. Agile Delivery: Focuses on the delivery of value through iterative and incremental development. 2. Disciplined DevOps: Emphasizes a holistic approach to development and operations, including continuous delivery and automation. 3. Lean Portfolio Management: Addresses the lean and agile approach to portfolio management. 4. Agile Product Management: Covers product ownership, requirements, and prioritization. 5. Agile Architecture: Discusses architecture and design within an agile context. 6. Team and Technical Agility: Focuses on team practices and technical excellence. 7. Organizational Agility: Addresses the overall organizational context and culture. |
| Implementation | – Implementing Disciplined Agile involves assessing your organization’s context, selecting the appropriate DA lifecycles, and tailoring the practices and processes to fit your specific needs. DA provides guidance for different lifecycles, including Agile, Lean, Continuous Delivery, and Exploratory. Organizations can also choose a combination of these lifecycles based on their requirements. |
| Benefits and Impact | – Disciplined Agile offers several benefits and impacts: 1. Flexibility: Organizations can choose the practices that suit their context, making it adaptable to various industries and situations. 2. Comprehensive Guidance: DA provides a wide range of practices and strategies, covering the entire delivery lifecycle. 3. Scalability: It offers strategies for scaling agile practices to large and complex organizations. 4. Efficiency: DA promotes efficient delivery by incorporating lean and agile principles. 5. Pragmatic Solutions: It focuses on practical solutions that align with organizational goals. 6. Alignment: DA helps align teams and stakeholders with common objectives. |
| Challenges and Risks | – Challenges in implementing Disciplined Agile may include the need for organizational change and alignment, the complexity of tailoring practices, and the risk of misinterpreting or misapplying the framework’s principles. Risks can involve resistance to change and a lack of understanding of the DA approach. |
Understanding Disciplined Agile
Early incarnations of Disciplined Agile had a broad focus on process decisions across an organization.
Then, more specific adaptations began to appear including “Disciplined DevOps” and “Disciplined Agile IT.”
Disciplined Agile has now been designed to cover the full end-to-end product lifecycle, from project initiation to final delivery.
Fundamentally, DA helps businesses understand how seemingly compartmentalized activities such as security, finance, and product management can work together contextually.
With a focus on everything from consumable solutions to working software and documentation, Disciplined Agile is unique among scaling methodologies.
DA also advocates that the scaling of agile practices be based on decisions that result in the greatest customer value.
The four layers of the Disciplined Agile toolkit
To assist decision-makers in navigating the DA toolkit, information is commonly grouped into four separate layers.
Let’s look at each layer:
Foundation
This layer forms the conceptual underpinning of the entire toolkit. As a result, it contains the principles and guidelines of the DA mindset.
It also includes concepts fundamental to agile and lean methodologies and information on roles and responsibilities within a team.
Lastly, the foundation layer guides the choice of a way of working (WoW).
Disciplined DevOps
This involves the streaming of software development (dev) and IT operations (ops).
Disciplined Agile favors a collaborative approach to release management, data management, support, and operations.
The DevOps framework can be adapted to suit depending on the structure and maturity level of the organization concerned.
Examples of DA release management strategies may include SAFe release trains and slow or quick cadence release windows.
Value streams
This layer encompasses every set of actions that take place to bring value to the customer, from the initial concept to final delivery and customer support.
Here, businesses must concentrate on adding value that can be realized in the marketplace.
The DA FLEX mindset ties organizational strategy to effective value streams, ensuring that innovative decisions add value to both the customer and business.
Disciplined Agile Enterprise (DAE)
This layer can respond with agility to changing market conditions.
It does this via the promotion of a flexible and adaptable organizational culture and structure.
This agility is reinforced by the business adopting a learning mindset, which helps to drive innovation.
Strengths of Disciplined Agile
Flexibility
Far from being a tool that is used by software development teams exclusively,
DA is an approach that is relevant to any customer-facing role or department.
Marketing and sales teams, for example, benefit greatly from enhanced collaboration with customers by taking advantage of DA principles and adapting them to suit.
Robust decision-making framework
DA does not assume that the project team needs to tailor up or tailor down according to their experience level.
Instead, it takes a middle-of-the-road approach and describes all options and the potential trade-offs of each.
Options are sourced from a variety of sources including Scrum, XP, Agile Modeling, Kanban, and Outside-In Development.
Ultimately, DA utilizes a risk value lifecycle, with a focus giving the teams the freedom to make their own decisions.
Weaknesses of Disciplined Agile
Does require experience
DA is unsuited to teams that are unfamiliar with agile practices because it does not detail an actionable methodology or set process.
In some cases, the business may need to hire external consultants to provide training.
Can be cumbersome
Since DA seeks to break down compartmental barriers, the organization-wide rollout of its principles may take longer when compared with similar agile systems.
It also requires discipline, direction, and coordination – particularly when teams are largely autonomous.
When to Use Disciplined Agile:
Disciplined Agile is suitable in various business scenarios:
- Enterprise Agility: For organizations aiming to achieve agile transformation at an enterprise level.
- Project and Product Management: In project and product management contexts where flexibility and adaptability are crucial.
- Delivery Teams: For agile delivery teams looking to enhance their practices.
- Regulated Industries: In industries with regulatory requirements where flexibility and compliance are essential.
- Complex Projects: For complex projects where a tailored approach is necessary.
How to Implement Disciplined Agile Effectively:
To implement Disciplined Agile effectively, consider the following steps:
- Training and Education: Provide training and education to teams and leaders in Disciplined Agile practices and principles.
- Process Tailoring: Tailor the DA toolkit to suit the specific needs and context of your organization.
- Team Collaboration: Foster collaboration among cross-functional teams and stakeholders.
- Continuous Improvement: Implement feedback loops to continuously improve processes and practices.
- Measurement and Metrics: Define and track key metrics to evaluate the effectiveness of your chosen approaches.
Expected Benefits of Disciplined Agile:
When implementing Disciplined Agile effectively, expect the following benefits:
- Flexibility: DA provides the flexibility to choose and adapt agile and lean practices that best fit your organization’s needs.
- Improved Delivery: It helps organizations deliver value more efficiently and effectively.
- Enhanced Collaboration: DA encourages collaboration among teams and stakeholders.
- Compliance: Organizations in regulated industries can maintain compliance while adopting agile and lean practices.
- Continuous Improvement: DA promotes a culture of continuous improvement and learning.
Potential Drawbacks of Disciplined Agile:
While Disciplined Agile offers numerous advantages, it also has potential drawbacks:
- Complexity: DA can be complex to implement, especially in large organizations.
- Resource Intensive: Implementing and maintaining DA practices may require additional resources.
- Resistance to Change: Traditional organizations may face resistance when transitioning to DA.
Related Frameworks and Methodologies:
- Scrum: Scrum is an agile framework that focuses on iterative and incremental product development.
- Kanban: Kanban is a lean method that emphasizes visualizing work, limiting work in progress, and optimizing workflow.
- SAFe (Scaled Agile Framework): SAFe is a framework for scaling agile and lean practices to large organizations.
- Lean: Lean principles focus on eliminating waste and delivering value efficiently.
- Agile Manifesto: The Agile Manifesto is a set of guiding values and principles for agile development.
Key takeaways
- Disciplined Agile is process decision structure in software development that prioritizes individuals and the connection between individuals.
- Disciplined Agile comprises four layers: foundation, Disciplined DevOps, value streams, and Disciplined Agile Enterprise (DAE). Each layer helps project teams make sense of a large amount of information within the DA toolkit.
- Disciplined Agile is a flexible and robust decision-making framework. But it does assume some experience in agile and can be cumbersome to implement in larger or compartmentalized organizations.
Key Highlights
- Origin and Purpose of Disciplined Agile (DA):
- Developed at IBM in 2009 and introduced in 2012.
- DA is a people-first process decision toolkit with a focus on learning and streamlining processes.
- Scope and Evolution of DA:
- Originally covered broad process decisions across organizations.
- Adaptations like “Disciplined DevOps” and “Disciplined Agile IT” emerged.
- Now covers end-to-end product lifecycle from initiation to delivery.
- Emphasizes contextual collaboration across seemingly separate activities.
- Focus and Uniqueness of Disciplined Agile:
- Focuses on consumable solutions, working software, and documentation.
- Scales agile practices based on decisions yielding the most customer value.
- Four Layers of the Disciplined Agile Toolkit:
- Foundation: Principles, guidelines, agile/lean concepts, roles, and choice of way of working.
- Disciplined DevOps: Collaboration between development and operations, adaptable release management.
- Value Streams: Bringing customer value from concept to delivery, aligning strategy with value.
- Disciplined Agile Enterprise (DAE): Agile organizational culture, adaptability, learning mindset.
- Strengths of Disciplined Agile:
- Flexibility: Relevant to various customer-facing roles, not just software development.
- Robust Decision-Making: Presents options and trade-offs, incorporates various sources.
- Weaknesses of Disciplined Agile:
- Experience Requirement: Unsuitable for teams unfamiliar with agile practices.
- Potential Cumbersomeness: Implementation may take longer due to breaking down compartmental barriers.
- Key Takeaways:
- DA prioritizes individuals and their connections in software development.
- DA includes layers like foundation, Disciplined DevOps, value streams, and DAE.
- DA is flexible and robust, assuming some agile experience, but can be complex in larger organizations.
| Related Frameworks | Description | When to Apply |
|---|---|---|
| Scrum Framework | – Scrum is an iterative and incremental Agile framework for managing complex projects. – It emphasizes empirical process control, self-organization, and collaboration to deliver high-value products. – Scrum roles include the Product Owner, Scrum Master, and Development Team. – It consists of sprints, daily stand-ups, sprint reviews, and retrospectives for continuous improvement. | – When managing software development projects or other complex initiatives where requirements may change frequently, and iterative delivery is preferred. |
| Kanban Method | – Kanban is a visual management tool that helps teams optimize workflow and limit work in progress. – It visualizes the flow of work on a Kanban board, with columns representing different stages of the workflow. – It focuses on continuous delivery, pull-based scheduling, and workflow transparency to improve efficiency and effectiveness. – Kanban allows teams to identify bottlenecks and optimize processes iteratively. | – When managing workflows or projects that require flexibility, visualizing work, and minimizing waste by limiting work in progress. |
| Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) | – SAFe is a scalable and collaborative framework for large-scale Agile projects. – It provides guidance on organizational alignment, team collaboration, and continuous delivery. – SAFe includes roles, events, and artifacts tailored for enterprise-level agility. – It supports program increment planning, value stream mapping, and devops practices for end-to-end delivery. | – When implementing Agile at scale across large organizations or managing complex projects with multiple teams and dependencies. |
| Lean Startup | – The Lean Startup methodology emphasizes rapid experimentation, validated learning, and iteration in product development cycles. – It advocates for building minimum viable products (MVPs) to test assumptions and gather feedback from customers early. – Lean Startup principles include validated learning, innovation accounting, and build-measure-learn cycles. | – When launching new products or ventures, especially in uncertain environments, to quickly validate assumptions, learn from customer feedback, and iterate on product development based on validated learnings. |
| Design Thinking | – Design Thinking is a human-centered approach to innovation that focuses on empathizing with users, defining problems, ideating solutions, prototyping ideas, and testing with users. – It encourages collaboration, creativity, and iteration to develop innovative solutions. – Design Thinking stages include empathize, define, ideate, prototype, and test. | – When seeking to understand user needs, generate innovative ideas, and prototype solutions iteratively to solve complex problems or develop user-centric products and services. |
| Lean UX | – Lean UX applies Lean principles to user experience (UX) design, focusing on rapid iteration, collaboration, and validated learning. – It emphasizes cross-functional teams, early and frequent testing, and minimal viable products (MVPs). – Lean UX methods include user research, collaborative design, and iterative prototyping. – It aims to reduce waste, increase efficiency, and deliver value to users quickly and continuously. | – When integrating UX design processes with Agile development, particularly in environments where rapid iteration and user feedback are essential to product success. |
| DevOps | – DevOps is a culture, philosophy, and set of practices that aims to bridge the gap between software development and IT operations. – It promotes collaboration, automation, and measurement to improve deployment frequency, reliability, and scalability. – DevOps practices include continuous integration, continuous deployment, and infrastructure as code. | – When seeking to improve collaboration between development and operations teams, accelerate software delivery, and enhance the reliability and quality of software releases through automation and cultural alignment. |
| Agile Modeling | – Agile Modeling is a practice-based methodology for modeling and documentation in Agile projects. – It advocates for sufficient and just-in-time modeling, focusing on value and communication. – Agile Modeling principles include model with a purpose, multiple models, and travel light. – It aims to minimize waste, improve communication, and maximize the value of modeling efforts in Agile development. | – When modeling and documenting software systems in Agile projects, emphasizing agility, simplicity, and value-driven approaches to modeling and communication. |
| Continuous Delivery | – Continuous Delivery is a software development practice where code changes are automatically built, tested, and deployed to production environments. – It emphasizes automated and reliable release processes to enable frequent and predictable software releases. – Continuous Delivery relies on continuous integration, automated testing, and infrastructure as code to streamline the delivery pipeline. | – When aiming to achieve shorter development cycles, faster time to market, and more reliable software releases by automating the build, test, and deployment processes in software development. |
Connected Agile & Lean Frameworks


















































Read Also: Continuous Innovation, Agile Methodology, Lean Startup, Business Model Innovation, Project Management.
Read Next: Agile Methodology, Lean Methodology, Agile Project Management, Scrum, Kanban, Six Sigma.
Main Guides:
- Business Models
- Business Strategy
- Business Development
- Distribution Channels
- Marketing Strategy
- Platform Business Models
- Network Effects
Main Case Studies:









