Both are strategic frameworks to build companies with a long-term competitive advantage. The business model canvas is comprised of nine building blocks explaining what makes up a company’s success. The value proposition canvas is an extension of the business model canvas. It is primarily focused on developing a strong value proposition, which is among the central element of a sustainable business model.
|Aspect||Business Model Canvas (BMC)||Value Proposition Canvas (VPC)|
|Purpose and Background||The Business Model Canvas (BMC) is a strategic tool that provides a visual framework for developing, describing, and analyzing a business model. It was introduced by Alexander Osterwalder and Yves Pigneur in their book “Business Model Generation” in 2010. The BMC helps organizations understand how they create, deliver, and capture value.||The Value Proposition Canvas (VPC) is a subset of the BMC, focusing specifically on the customer segment and value proposition elements. It was developed as an extension to the BMC to delve deeper into the customer’s perspective. The VPC was also introduced by Osterwalder and Pigneur in their book. It helps organizations create compelling value propositions for their customers.|
|Components and Structure||The BMC comprises nine building blocks: Customer Segments, Value Proposition, Channels, Customer Relationships, Revenue Streams, Key Resources, Key Activities, Key Partnerships, and Cost Structure. Each block represents a specific aspect of the business model.||The VPC narrows its focus to two key components: the Customer Segment and the Value Proposition. It provides a more detailed analysis of these elements, exploring the fit between what customers need (jobs, pains, gains) and what the business offers (products or services).|
|Customer-Centric Approach||While the BMC considers customers within various building blocks, it does not explicitly emphasize customer problems and solutions as the VPC does. It addresses customer-related concerns in the Customer Segments and Value Proposition blocks.||The VPC is specifically designed to be customer-centric. It helps businesses understand their customers’ jobs to be done, pains, and gains, ensuring that the value proposition aligns perfectly with customer needs.|
|Value Proposition Design||The BMC outlines the value proposition in a concise manner but does not delve deeply into customer pains and gains. It provides an overall view of how the value proposition fits within the business model.||The VPC is dedicated to value proposition design. It dissects the customer segment into jobs, pains, and gains, facilitating a more granular understanding of customer needs and how the value proposition can address them effectively.|
|Usage Stage||The BMC is typically used during the early stages of business model development, helping organizations explore and refine their overall business concept. It serves as a foundational tool for brainstorming and strategic planning.||The VPC is often used in conjunction with the BMC and comes into play when businesses need to fine-tune their value propositions to meet specific customer needs and preferences. It is more focused on the later stages of product or service development.|
|Visual Representation||The BMC uses a visual canvas format, making it suitable for workshops and collaborative discussions within teams or across different stakeholders. This visual approach aids in brainstorming and fostering a shared understanding of the business model.||The VPC also employs a visual canvas format, but it zooms in on the customer segment and value proposition elements. It allows teams to visualize and assess how well the value proposition aligns with customer needs, pains, and gains.|
|Strategic Planning Tool||The BMC is often used for strategic planning, business model analysis, and presenting an overall view of how a business creates, delivers, and captures value. It is particularly valuable for established companies looking to optimize their existing models.||The VPC is primarily a tool for fine-tuning and designing value propositions to ensure they resonate with customers. It plays a critical role in product development and marketing strategy, especially for startups aiming to meet specific customer needs.|
|Dynamic Environment||The BMC is versatile and can be adapted to various business environments. However, its primary strength lies in providing an overview of the business model, making it useful for businesses in both stable and dynamic markets.||The VPC is particularly valuable in dynamic environments where rapid adaptation to changing customer needs is crucial. Startups and businesses looking to pivot or innovate their offerings benefit from its customer-centric approach.|
|Startups vs. Established||The BMC is suitable for both startups and established companies. Startups can use it to develop their initial business model, while established companies can employ it for strategic analysis and optimization.||The VPC complements the BMC and is often used by startups looking to refine their value propositions based on customer feedback and validation. It is especially beneficial for startups aiming to disrupt or differentiate in crowded markets.|
Key Similarities between Business Model Canvas and Value Proposition Canvas:
- Strategic Frameworks: Both the Business Model Canvas and Value Proposition Canvas are strategic frameworks used in business planning and development.
- Building Blocks: Both canvases are structured using building blocks that help identify and articulate essential elements of a business.
- Customer-Centric: Both frameworks focus on understanding and meeting customer needs and preferences to create a successful and sustainable business.
- Value Creation: Both canvases address the concept of value creation. The Business Model Canvas considers value propositions as one of its building blocks, while the Value Proposition Canvas delves deeper into creating a strong value proposition.
Key Differences between Business Model Canvas and Value Proposition Canvas:
- Scope: The Business Model Canvas provides a holistic view of the entire business model, encompassing key partners, activities, customer segments, revenue streams, and more. The Value Proposition Canvas, on the other hand, zooms in on the specific value proposition offered to customers.
- Focus: The primary focus of the Business Model Canvas is to understand the entire business model and how all the building blocks interact to create value for the company. In contrast, the Value Proposition Canvas is centered on analyzing and refining the value proposition to meet customer needs effectively.
- Level of Detail: The Business Model Canvas provides a broader overview of the business, whereas the Value Proposition Canvas goes into more detail about the customer segment and the value proposition that caters to their specific needs.
- Value Proposition: While both canvases address value propositions, the Value Proposition Canvas dedicates more attention to understanding the customer’s pains, gains, and jobs to design a compelling value proposition that directly addresses their needs and preferences.
- Integration: The Value Proposition Canvas is an extension of the Business Model Canvas, meaning it can be used alongside the Business Model Canvas to enhance the understanding and refinement of the value proposition within the larger business model.
- Customer Insights: The Value Proposition Canvas places a greater emphasis on gaining deep customer insights and empathy to create a more customer-centric value proposition.
- The Business Model Canvas and Value Proposition Canvas are both strategic frameworks used in business planning and development.
- The Business Model Canvas provides a holistic view of the entire business model, while the Value Proposition Canvas zooms in on understanding and refining the value proposition offered to customers.
- Both canvases focus on understanding customer needs and preferences to create value for the business. However, the Value Proposition Canvas dedicates more attention to designing a compelling value proposition based on deep customer insights.
More Strategy Tools: Porter’s Five Forces, PESTEL Analysis, SWOT, Porter’s Diamond Model, Ansoff, Technology Adoption Curve, TOWS, SOAR, Balanced Scorecard, OKR, Agile Methodology, Value Proposition, VTDF Framework.
Connected Strategy Frameworks