A business model canvas is a framework to evaluate the key building blocks that make up a company from a competitive advantage standpoint. A value chain model instead focuses on how value is delivered to potential customers through a set of activities and via the company’s organizational structure. Both tools can be used to assess the competitive edge of a company and how to deliver value.
|Aspect||Business Model Canvas (BMC)||Value Chain|
|Purpose and Background||The Business Model Canvas (BMC) is a visual tool for developing, describing, and analyzing a business model. It provides a high-level overview of how a company creates, delivers, and captures value. It was introduced by Alexander Osterwalder and Yves Pigneur in their book “Business Model Generation.”||The Value Chain is a concept developed by Michael Porter in his book “Competitive Advantage.” It is a framework for analyzing a firm’s activities and how they create value. It helps in understanding the competitive advantage of a company.|
|Components and Structure||The BMC consists of nine building blocks: Customer Segments, Value Proposition, Channels, Customer Relationships, Revenue Streams, Key Resources, Key Activities, Key Partnerships, and Cost Structure. Each block represents a specific aspect of the business model.||The Value Chain is divided into primary activities and support activities. Primary activities include Inbound Logistics, Operations, Outbound Logistics, Marketing and Sales, and Service. Support activities encompass Firm Infrastructure, Human Resource Management, Technology Development, and Procurement. These activities are linked to create value.|
|Focus on Value Creation||The BMC emphasizes how a business creates, delivers, and captures value. It places a strong emphasis on understanding Customer Segments and Value Propositions, ensuring alignment between what customers need and what the business offers.||The Value Chain focuses on how a company’s activities create and enhance value. It analyzes each activity’s cost and potential for differentiation, helping companies identify areas for improvement or cost reduction. It is more operationally oriented.|
|Customer-Centric Approach||The BMC encourages a customer-centric approach by highlighting the importance of understanding customer needs and designing value propositions that address those needs. Customer segments and relationships are central elements.||While the Value Chain considers customer needs indirectly by aiming to create value for customers, it does not have a specific customer-centric focus. Instead, it looks at value creation from a process and cost perspective.|
|Business Model Visualization||The BMC uses a visual canvas format, which makes it suitable for workshops, brainstorming, and collaborative discussions. It allows teams to quickly iterate and communicate their business model.||The Value Chain is typically represented as a series of linked activities or processes, and it is often presented in a linear format. It serves as a tool for internal analysis and optimization rather than a visualization for external communication.|
|Strategic Planning Tool||The BMC is widely used for strategic planning, business model analysis, and presenting an overall view of a business’s value creation strategy. It is particularly valuable for startups and established companies looking to optimize their models.||The Value Chain is primarily a strategic tool for understanding how a company’s activities contribute to its competitive advantage. It helps companies identify opportunities for cost reduction or differentiation within their processes.|
|Innovation and Adaptation||The BMC is well-suited for startups and businesses that need to quickly iterate and adapt their business models based on customer feedback and market changes. It aligns with the lean startup approach.||The Value Chain is more focused on optimizing existing processes and activities. While it can inform strategic decisions, it may not be as agile in responding to rapid market changes as the BMC.|
|Dynamic Environment||The BMC is ideal for businesses operating in dynamic and uncertain environments. It allows companies to experiment with different components of their business model and pivot when necessary.||The Value Chain is traditionally used for industries with stable processes and slower changes. It may be less suitable for businesses in rapidly evolving markets where agility is essential.|
|Startups vs. Established||The BMC is particularly popular among startups because it provides a clear, concise way to outline their business model assumptions and test them quickly.||The Value Chain is more commonly used by established companies looking to analyze and optimize their existing operations. It may not be as well-suited for startups.|
Key Similarities between Business Model Canvas and Value Chain Model:
- Strategic Analysis: Both the Business Model Canvas and the Value Chain Model are strategic analysis frameworks that help organizations evaluate and understand their internal operations and competitive advantage.
- Value Delivery: Both tools focus on delivering value to customers. The Business Model Canvas assesses how value is created and delivered through the business model, while the Value Chain Model analyzes the processes that create value for consumers.
- Competitive Edge: Both tools can be used to assess the competitive edge of a company. The Business Model Canvas helps identify unique value propositions and competitive advantages, while the Value Chain Model examines how activities in the value chain contribute to a company’s competitive advantage.
- Organizational Structure: Both frameworks consider the company’s organizational structure and how different activities and resources are utilized to achieve the overall objectives.
Key Differences between Business Model Canvas and Value Chain Model:
- Focus: The primary focus of the Business Model Canvas is on designing, understanding, and communicating the business model of an organization. It analyzes the key building blocks that make up the company and how they create and deliver value to customers.
- Components: The Business Model Canvas consists of nine building blocks, including key partners, key activities, value propositions, customer relationships, customer segments, critical resources, channels, cost structure, and revenue streams.
- Value Creation: The Value Chain Model, on the other hand, is specifically focused on value creation within the company’s internal operations. It breaks down the company’s activities into primary and support activities to identify points of competitive advantage.
- Michael Porter’s Model: The Value Chain Model was developed by Michael Porter and is described in his book “Competitive Advantage.” It is a comprehensive analysis tool that examines the sequence of activities within a company.
Integration and Complementarity:
The Business Model Canvas and the Value Chain Model can be used together to gain a comprehensive understanding of a company’s competitive advantage and value delivery:
- Alignment: The Business Model Canvas helps identify the key building blocks and value propositions of the business, which can be aligned with the value chain activities to ensure efficient and effective value delivery.
- Value Chain Analysis: Value Chain analysis can help identify areas of improvement and optimization within the company’s operations, which can then be integrated into the Business Model Canvas to enhance the overall value proposition.
- Competitive Edge: Both tools contribute to assessing and enhancing the competitive edge of the company by understanding how value is created and delivered to customers.
- Strategic Decision-Making: Together, these tools provide valuable insights for strategic decision-making, enabling organizations to develop a clear and effective business model while optimizing their internal processes.
- The Business Model Canvas and the Value Chain Model are strategic analysis frameworks that can be used to assess a company’s competitive advantage and value delivery.
- While the Business Model Canvas focuses on the overall business model and value proposition, the Value Chain Model delves into the internal operations and activities that create value for customers.
- Used together, these tools can help organizations align their business model with value chain activities, optimize their operations, and strengthen their competitive edge.
Business Model Canvas:
- Key Partners: Coffee bean suppliers, local farmers, machine manufacturers.
- Key Activities: Brewing coffee, customer service, product development.
- Value Propositions: High-quality coffee, friendly ambiance, loyalty program.
- Customer Relationships: Barista-customer interaction, mobile app engagement.
- Customer Segments: Coffee lovers, remote workers, meeting attendees.
- Critical Resources: Coffee beans, store locations, trained staff.
- Channels: Physical stores, mobile app, online store.
- Cost Structure: Bean procurement, store operations, marketing.
- Revenue Streams: Drink sales, merchandise, online sales.
Value Chain Model:
- Primary Activities: Inbound logistics (bean sourcing, inventory), operations (brewing coffee, baking pastries), outbound logistics (deliveries for online sales), marketing and sales (ad campaigns, loyalty programs), service (customer service, loyalty program management).
- Support Activities: Infrastructure (store setup, IT systems), HR management (staff training, recruitment), technology development (app improvements, new brewing methods), procurement (bean sourcing, equipment purchase).
Business Model Canvas:
- Key Partners: Content producers, licensing agencies, streaming technology providers.
- Key Activities: Content streaming, original content production, algorithm development.
- Value Propositions: Vast content library, original shows, personalized recommendations.
- Customer Relationships: Personalized user profiles, customer support.
- Customer Segments: TV and movie watchers, households, binge-watchers.
- Critical Resources: Streaming technology, content licenses, user data.
- Channels: Mobile app, website, smart TVs.
- Cost Structure: Content production, licensing fees, technology maintenance.
- Revenue Streams: Monthly subscriptions, content partnerships.
Value Chain Model:
- Primary Activities: Inbound logistics (content acquisition, server maintenance), operations (streaming service, user data analysis), outbound logistics (content delivery to users), marketing and sales (ad campaigns, partnerships), service (user support, bug fixes).
- Support Activities: Infrastructure (data centers, streaming technology), HR management (content teams, tech teams), technology development (streaming improvements, personalization algorithms), procurement (content licenses, server equipment).
3. Apple (focusing on iPhone):
Business Model Canvas:
- Key Partners: Component suppliers, app developers, retail partners.
- Key Activities: Product design, software development, retail operations.
- Value Propositions: High-quality design, integrated software ecosystem, brand appeal.
- Customer Relationships: In-store service, online support, software updates.
- Customer Segments: Tech enthusiasts, brand loyalists, professionals.
- Critical Resources: Proprietary software, patents, brand reputation.
- Channels: Apple stores, online store, third-party retailers.
- Cost Structure: R&D, manufacturing, marketing.
- Revenue Streams: Device sales, app store commissions, accessory sales.
Value Chain Model:
- Primary Activities: Inbound logistics (component sourcing, inventory management), operations (assembly, software integration), outbound logistics (shipping to stores, online deliveries), marketing and sales (product launches, ad campaigns), service (Apple Care, software updates).
- Support Activities: Infrastructure (retail stores, online platforms), HR management (employee training, recruitment), technology development (iOS improvements, new feature development), procurement (component agreements, manufacturing equipment).
More Strategy Tools: Porter’s Five Forces, PESTEL Analysis, SWOT, Porter’s Diamond Model, Ansoff, Technology Adoption Curve, TOWS, SOAR, Balanced Scorecard, OKR, Agile Methodology, Value Proposition, VTDF Framework.
Connected Strategy Frameworks