The total cost of ownership (TCO) estimates the total cost associated with purchasing and operating an asset. TCO is a more comprehensive way to understand the real cost of ownership. Thus, how much it really costs in the long-term to own something, with all its related direct and indirect purchase costs.
|Concept Overview||Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) is a financial concept and analysis framework that calculates the complete cost associated with owning, operating, and maintaining an asset, product, or system throughout its entire lifecycle. TCO is a comprehensive approach that goes beyond the initial purchase price to include all direct and indirect costs incurred over the asset’s useful life. It is a valuable tool for decision-making in various contexts, such as procurement, investment, and business operations.|
|Components||TCO consists of various cost components, including:|
1. Acquisition Costs: This includes the initial purchase price of the asset or product, along with any associated costs like taxes and shipping fees.
2. Operating Costs: These are the ongoing expenses required to operate and use the asset, including energy, maintenance, repairs, and consumables.
3. Maintenance Costs: Expenses related to scheduled and unscheduled maintenance to keep the asset functioning correctly.
4. Financing Costs: Interest payments, if the asset was financed through a loan or lease.
5. Depreciation: The decrease in the asset’s value over time, which affects its resale or salvage value.
6. Training and Support Costs: Expenses for training personnel and providing customer support.
7. Disposal Costs: Costs associated with disposing of or replacing the asset at the end of its useful life.
|TCO Analysis||TCO analysis typically involves the following steps: |
1. Identify Costs: Identify all relevant costs associated with the asset or product.
2. Estimate Lifespan: Determine the expected useful lifespan of the asset.
3. Calculate Costs: Calculate the present value of all costs over the asset’s entire lifespan.
4. Compare Options: If applicable, compare TCO for different assets, products, or solutions to make informed decisions.
5. Consider External Factors: Factor in external variables like inflation rates and discount rates when assessing future costs.
|Benefits||TCO analysis offers several benefits: |
1. Informed Decision-Making: It helps organizations make well-informed decisions about investments, procurement, and resource allocation.
2. Cost Control: TCO analysis highlights all cost elements, allowing for better cost control and budgeting.
3. Long-Term Planning: Provides insights into the long-term financial implications of owning and operating assets.
4. Vendor and Supplier Evaluation: Helps in evaluating and comparing vendors and suppliers based on their total cost impact.
5. Risk Mitigation: Identifies potential cost drivers and risks associated with asset ownership.
|Applications||TCO is widely used in various industries and sectors, including manufacturing, IT, fleet management, and real estate. It is applicable to decisions involving equipment purchase, software selection, vehicle fleets, infrastructure investments, and more.|
|Challenges||TCO analysis can be complex and time-consuming, requiring accurate data, assumptions, and future cost estimations. It may also involve uncertainty, especially when predicting long-term costs and asset performance.|
Understanding the total cost of ownership
This value is derived from every aspect of owning an asset, including costs relating to acquisitions, operations, training, documentation, and so forth. The calculation considers the direct and indirect (hidden) costs of purchase.
TCO is an important consideration in any scenario necessitating a large capital purchase.
Calculating the total cost of ownership
The particular parameters of a TCO calculation will vary from industry to industry.
Nevertheless, a standardized calculation allows decision-makers to compare the viability of otherwise unrelated assets.
Incurred costs are usually calculated from eight key areas:
How much did the investment cost to acquire before taxes?
Such as customs, duties, packaging, transport, or other payment terms.
Or the cost of actions undertaken by the purchasing department.
For example, acquiring new software may incur licensing, installation, or subscription fees.
Cost of ownership
Including stock management and depreciation.
Such as cleaning, training, inspecting, reporting, troubleshooting, or servicing.
Otherwise known as operating costs, these usually relate to employee wages or other overheads such as rent, electricity, and water.
What are the costs associated with meeting deadlines or initiating a non-compliance process?
Or costs associated with the asset once it reaches the end of its usable life. This includes disposal, resale, or recycling cost.
Important TCO considerations
Determining the total cost of ownership is a nuanced process. Here are some important considerations for all businesses regardless of industry.
What are the hidden costs?
Spend some time considering the hidden costs of an asset purchase.
The better a business becomes at identifying hidden costs, the more accurately it will be able to calculate TCO.
What’s the cost of financing?
The method of financing used to fund the purchase will have an impact on TCO.
Decision-makers must liaise with finance and accounting to understand how factors such as deductions, expenses, and depreciation impact the final calculation.
How do the maintenance costs change over time?
Total cost of ownership is fluid. For example, the costs associated with maintaining a piece of equipment increase over time as the equipment ages.
Inflation also increases the cost of long-term maintenance.
What are the labor costs associated with owning?
Do not forget labor costs, which may decrease or increase as the result of new investment.
Winemaker Case Study
Consider a winemaker that needs to purchase a new forklift for its cellar operations.
The company has narrowed the purchase down to two potential models: Forklift A and Forklift B.
For the sake of this example, we’ll use the following formula to calculate the total cost of ownership:
TCO = initial cost (I) + cost of operation (O) + cost of maintenance (M) + cost of downtime (D) + cost of production (P) – remaining value (R).
Now, let’s run through each component step by step.
The initial cost of Forklift A is $25,000, while Forklift B retails for $28,000.
Cost of operation
Both forklifts will necessitate employee training on how to use them safely.
Since both models are electric forklifts, the company will also need to pay for electricity to charge the batteries.
Cost of maintenance
Periodic maintenance of the tires, tines, electric motor, and various other components will also be required over the forklift’s usable life.
Costs may also be incurred due to unexpected failures or inspections from a safe work authority that result in compulsory repairs.
Based on historical data, the winemaker costs the maintenance of Forklift A at $3,300 and Forklift B at $2,700.
Cost of downtime
Downtime costs for forklifts are especially relevant in the wine industry during the busy vintage period when grapes are harvested and the cellar is operating 24/7.
When a forklift is out of service, several processes such as crushing and pressing may be delayed.
There may also be a substantial loss of productivity in the bottling department since the process of bottling wine on a production line requires precision and coordination.
If the company is unable to unload glass bottles from a courier, for example, the line may have to be stopped until a forklift can be sourced.
For argument’s sake, the cost of downtime for Forklift A is $4,000 ($2,000 for 2 hours) and $2,000 ($2,000 for 1 hour) for Forklift B.
Cost of production
Forklift A has a total capacity of 3 tons, while Forklift B has a capacity of 2.5 tons.
This means that Forklift A has a lower cost of production because it can lift heavier loads and is more versatile as a consequence.
However, this advantage means the battery in Forklift A needs to be charged more frequently.
The winemaker has the policy to replace all forklifts after 15 years of service. After that time, it is estimated that Forklift A will be worth $5,000, while Forklift B will be worth $3,500.
Forklift Case Study
To calculate which forklift is most cost-effective, we can use the data and formula from above.
TCO = 25,000 + 3,300 + 4,000 – 5,000 = $27,300.
TCO = 28,000 + 2,700 + 2,000 – 3,500 = $29,200.
Despite the higher maintenance and potential downtime expenses, it is determined that Forklift A will cost the least to own over the 15-year period.
Is it worth owning a car?
The best example to grasp the concept of Total Cost of Ownership is whether to own or not a car.
Since we give this for granted, that is a great exercise to challenge some of our assumptions about it.
Of course, if you live in a a state like California, you know it is impossible to get by without a car.
However, do you know your total cost of ownership for owning it?
This goes way beyond your leasing fee.
It comprises things like:
- License registration.
- Fuel costs.
- Maintenance, both ordinary and extraordinary.
In other words, if you consider something you take for granted, like owning a car, and factor in all the above, you go from a cost of $300-500 of your leasing fee to potentially 3-4x that!
That is what it entails to understand what ownership implies.
This will help you better understand possible alternatives, as now you have a clearer vision of the burden that ownership might have on your lifestyle.
This same approach can be brought to the business world.
You might want to consider when it makes sense to own or rent.
While rent might seem more expensive at first, you realize that it carries some hidden benefits.
On the opposite spectrum, you might think owning is always more convenient until you start calculating the hidden costs.
- The total cost of ownership is the purchase price of an asset plus the costs of operation.
- Depending on the industry, the total cost of ownership can be calculated by considering costs grouped into eight categories: purchase price, associated costs, acquisition cost, cost of ownership, maintenance costs, usage costs, non-quality costs, and disposal cost.
- When calculating the total cost of ownership, decision-makers must identify hidden costs. They must also understand that the TOC of an asset fluctuates because of age, financing method, inflation, and labor demand.
- Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) Introduction: The total cost of ownership concept evaluates the complete expenses associated with owning and operating an asset over its lifecycle. TCO encompasses both direct and indirect costs, providing a comprehensive view of the true cost of ownership.
- TCO Overview: TCO assigns a single value to an asset’s entire lifespan, factoring in acquisition, operational, training, documentation, and other relevant costs. It is particularly vital for evaluating large capital purchases and conducting cost-benefit analyses.
- Calculating TCO: The components and parameters of TCO calculations vary by industry, enabling comparisons between diverse assets. TCO typically includes eight cost categories:
- Purchase price
- Associated costs (customs, duties, packaging, etc.)
- Acquisition costs (licensing, installation, etc.)
- Cost of ownership (stock management, depreciation)
- Maintenance costs (cleaning, servicing, etc.)
- Usage costs (employee wages, overheads)
- Non-quality costs (compliance costs, deadlines)
- Disposal costs (resale, recycling, etc.)
- Considerations in TCO Calculation:
- Hidden Costs: Identifying and accounting for hidden costs is essential for accurate TCO calculations.
- Financing Impact: The financing method affects TCO, involving factors like deductions, expenses, and depreciation.
- Maintenance Costs Over Time: As assets age, maintenance costs increase, and inflation plays a role.
- Labor Costs: Labor costs should not be overlooked, as they fluctuate with new investments.
- Winemaker Case Study: An example of comparing the TCO of two forklift models demonstrates the formula for TCO calculation. The case study considers various components like initial cost, operation, maintenance, downtime, production, and remaining value.
- Car Ownership Example: Applying TCO to car ownership reveals that beyond the lease fee, numerous costs such as insurance, registration, depreciation, fuel, and maintenance contribute to the true cost of ownership.
- Applying TCO in Business: Similar to personal car ownership, businesses should consider TCO when deciding between owning and renting assets. Hidden costs and the fluctuating nature of TCO influence such decisions.
Connected Business Concepts
Main Free Guides: