Cannibalization effect

Cannibalization Effect

Business / By /

Cannibalization effect is a phenomenon that occurs when a new product or service within a company’s portfolio competes with and reduces the sales and market share of its existing products or services. While it may seem counterintuitive for a business to undermine its own offerings, cannibalization can be a strategic move when managed effectively.

Introduction to Cannibalization Effect

Cannibalization effect, also known simply as “cannibalization,” refers to the situation where a company’s new product or service directly competes with its existing offerings, leading to a reduction in the sales or market share of those existing products. This phenomenon occurs when a business decides to introduce something new that appeals to its existing customer base, even if it means some of its existing products will lose sales.

Causes of Cannibalization Effect

Several factors can lead to the cannibalization effect:

  1. Innovation: The introduction of innovative products or services can render existing offerings less attractive, prompting customers to switch to the new, superior option.
  2. Market Evolution: Changes in customer preferences, market dynamics, or technological advancements may require companies to adapt and offer new solutions to remain competitive.
  3. Competitive Pressure: The presence of strong competitors in the market can force a company to innovate and release new products or services to maintain or expand its market share.
  4. Diversification: Companies often seek to diversify their product or service portfolios to reduce risks and capture a broader range of customers.

Impact of Cannibalization Effect

The cannibalization effect can have various consequences for a business:

Advantages:

  1. Innovation: Cannibalization encourages companies to innovate and introduce new products or services, ensuring they stay relevant in a rapidly changing market.
  2. Market Leadership: Embracing cannibalization can reinforce a company’s market leadership position by demonstrating its commitment to innovation and progress.
  3. Sustained Growth: The introduction of new products or services allows a company to continue growing and adapting to changing market conditions.

Disadvantages:

  1. Short-Term Revenue Loss: Cannibalization can result in a temporary decline in sales and revenue as customers switch to the new offerings.
  2. Brand Confusion: Customers may become confused or frustrated when a company offers similar products with slight variations, potentially affecting brand loyalty.
  3. Resource Allocation: Companies need to allocate resources for the development, marketing, and distribution of new products, which can be costly.
  4. Channel Conflict: Cannibalization may create conflicts within distribution channels, as retailers or distributors may struggle to allocate resources and shelf space to competing products.

Strategies for Managing Cannibalization Effect

To effectively manage the cannibalization effect, businesses can implement several strategies:

  1. Customer Segmentation: Identify distinct customer segments for existing and new products. Ensure that the new offerings cater to different customer needs or preferences.
  2. Clear Communication: Transparently communicate the benefits of new products to existing customers. Explain how the innovations address their needs or offer superior value.
  3. Gradual Transition: Implement cannibalization gradually rather than abruptly discontinuing existing products. This allows customers to adjust to the changes.
  4. Pricing Strategies: Employ pricing strategies that encourage customers to switch to new products gradually. This can include offering discounts or bundling options.
  5. Cross-Promotion: Promote new products to existing customers through cross-selling and bundling, creating synergy between the old and new offerings.
  6. Innovation Pipeline: Establish a consistent innovation pipeline to continually introduce new products and stay ahead of market changes.
  7. Monitoring and Adjustment: Monitor the performance of new products and be prepared to adjust marketing, pricing, and distribution strategies based on customer feedback and market dynamics.

Real-World Examples of Cannibalization Effect

  1. Apple Inc.: Apple has strategically employed the cannibalization effect several times. When it introduced the iPhone, it cannibalized its own iPod sales, recognizing that the iPhone’s capabilities made standalone music players less relevant. Similarly, the introduction of the iPad disrupted its laptop sales, but it opened up a new market segment for Apple.
  2. Toyota: Toyota introduced its hybrid vehicles, like the Prius, which cannibalized its own sales of traditional gasoline-powered cars. The company recognized the shift in consumer preferences toward more fuel-efficient and environmentally friendly vehicles, and it embraced this change through innovation.
  3. Netflix: Netflix, originally a DVD rental service, transitioned to a streaming platform, cannibalizing its own DVD rental business. This move allowed Netflix to stay ahead in the evolving entertainment industry and cater to changing viewer habits.

Conclusion

The cannibalization effect is a complex phenomenon in business where a company’s new product or service competes with and reduces the sales and market share of its existing offerings. While it may initially lead to short-term revenue loss and brand confusion, when managed effectively, it can drive innovation, sustain growth, and maintain market leadership. By understanding its causes, impact, advantages, disadvantages, and effective management strategies, businesses can make informed decisions regarding the cannibalization effect. In a competitive business landscape, embracing well-managed cannibalization can contribute to long-term success and adaptability.

Related FrameworksDescriptionPurposeKey Components/Steps
Cannibalization EffectThe Cannibalization Effect refers to the negative impact on sales or revenue of an existing product or service caused by the introduction or promotion of a new product or service from the same company. It occurs when the new offering draws customers away from the existing ones.To understand the potential loss of sales or revenue resulting from the introduction of a new product or service that competes with existing offerings within the same company’s portfolio.1. Identify Existing Products: Identify the products or services within the company’s portfolio that may be affected by the introduction of a new offering. 2. Market Analysis: Analyze the market demand, customer preferences, and competitive landscape to assess the potential impact of the new product on existing offerings. 3. Sales Data Analysis: Analyze historical sales data to identify any correlations between the introduction of new products and declines in sales of existing ones. 4. Mitigation Strategies: Develop strategies to minimize the cannibalization effect, such as pricing strategies, product differentiation, or targeted marketing campaigns.
Market SegmentationMarket Segmentation involves dividing a heterogeneous market into smaller, homogeneous segments based on characteristics such as demographics, psychographics, behavior, or needs. It allows companies to tailor their marketing strategies and offerings to specific customer groups.To identify and target distinct groups of customers with unique needs, preferences, or behaviors, enabling companies to develop more effective marketing strategies, product designs, and communication approaches.1. Identify Segmentation Criteria: Determine the criteria or variables (e.g., demographics, behavior) for segmenting the market. 2. Segment Identification: Analyze customer data to identify homogeneous groups with similar characteristics or needs. 3. Targeting: Select target segments based on their attractiveness, accessibility, and compatibility with the company’s capabilities and objectives. 4. Positioning: Develop positioning strategies and marketing messages tailored to each target segment’s needs, preferences, or aspirations.
Product Portfolio ManagementProduct Portfolio Management involves the strategic management of a company’s portfolio of products or services to achieve business objectives and maximize value. It includes activities such as product development, optimization, retirement, and diversification to balance risk and return.To optimize the composition and performance of a company’s product portfolio, ensuring alignment with market demands, competitive dynamics, and strategic goals, while minimizing risks and maximizing returns.1. Portfolio Analysis: Assess the current composition and performance of the product portfolio, considering factors such as market share, growth potential, profitability, and competitive positioning. 2. Strategic Alignment: Align the product portfolio with the company’s overall strategy, goals, and market trends, identifying areas for expansion, optimization, or divestment. 3. Resource Allocation: Allocate resources (e.g., investments, talent) effectively across different products or projects based on their strategic importance and potential for growth or value creation. 4. Risk Management: Identify and mitigate risks associated with the product portfolio, such as market volatility, technological disruptions, or competitive threats, through diversification, innovation, or strategic partnerships.
Competitive AnalysisCompetitive Analysis involves evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of competitors, their strategies, market positioning, and performance to inform business decisions and strategies. It helps companies identify opportunities and threats in the market landscape and develop effective competitive strategies.To assess the competitive landscape, identify key competitors, and evaluate their strategies, strengths, and weaknesses to inform strategic decision-making, product positioning, pricing strategies, and marketing approaches.1. Competitor Identification: Identify direct and indirect competitors operating in the same market or industry. 2. Competitive Intelligence: Gather information on competitors’ products, pricing, distribution channels, marketing strategies, and customer feedback through research, surveys, or market analysis. 3. SWOT Analysis: Conduct a SWOT analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) for each competitor to understand their competitive position and potential impact on the company. 4. Strategy Formulation: Develop competitive strategies based on insights from the competitive analysis, focusing on areas of competitive advantage, differentiation, and market opportunities.

Read Next: Porter’s Five Forces, PESTEL Analysis, SWOT, Porter’s Diamond Model, Ansoff, Technology Adoption Curve, TOWS, SOAR, Balanced Scorecard, OKR, Agile Methodology, Value Proposition, VTDF Framework.

Connected Strategy Frameworks

ADKAR Model

adkar-model
The ADKAR model is a management tool designed to assist employees and businesses in transitioning through organizational change. To maximize the chances of employees embracing change, the ADKAR model was developed by author and engineer Jeff Hiatt in 2003. The model seeks to guide people through the change process and importantly, ensure that people do not revert to habitual ways of operating after some time has passed.

Ansoff Matrix

ansoff-matrix
You can use the Ansoff Matrix as a strategic framework to understand what growth strategy is more suited based on the market context. Developed by mathematician and business manager Igor Ansoff, it assumes a growth strategy can be derived from whether the market is new or existing, and whether the product is new or existing.

Business Model Canvas

business-model-canvas
The business model canvas is a framework proposed by Alexander Osterwalder and Yves Pigneur in Busines Model Generation enabling the design of business models through nine building blocks comprising: key partners, key activities, value propositions, customer relationships, customer segments, critical resources, channels, cost structure, and revenue streams.

Lean Startup Canvas

lean-startup-canvas
The lean startup canvas is an adaptation by Ash Maurya of the business model canvas by Alexander Osterwalder, which adds a layer that focuses on problems, solutions, key metrics, unfair advantage based, and a unique value proposition. Thus, starting from mastering the problem rather than the solution.

Blitzscaling Canvas

blitzscaling-business-model-innovation-canvas
The Blitzscaling business model canvas is a model based on the concept of Blitzscaling, which is a particular process of massive growth under uncertainty, and that prioritizes speed over efficiency and focuses on market domination to create a first-scaler advantage in a scenario of uncertainty.

Blue Ocean Strategy

blue-ocean-strategy
A blue ocean is a strategy where the boundaries of existing markets are redefined, and new uncontested markets are created. At its core, there is value innovation, for which uncontested markets are created, where competition is made irrelevant. And the cost-value trade-off is broken. Thus, companies following a blue ocean strategy offer much more value at a lower cost for the end customers.

Business Analysis Framework

business-analysis
Business analysis is a research discipline that helps driving change within an organization by identifying the key elements and processes that drive value. Business analysis can also be used in Identifying new business opportunities or how to take advantage of existing business opportunities to grow your business in the marketplace.

BCG Matrix

bcg-matrix
In the 1970s, Bruce D. Henderson, founder of the Boston Consulting Group, came up with The Product Portfolio (aka BCG Matrix, or Growth-share Matrix), which would look at a successful business product portfolio based on potential growth and market shares. It divided products into four main categories: cash cows, pets (dogs), question marks, and stars.

Balanced Scorecard

balanced-scorecard
First proposed by accounting academic Robert Kaplan, the balanced scorecard is a management system that allows an organization to focus on big-picture strategic goals. The four perspectives of the balanced scorecard include financial, customer, business process, and organizational capacity. From there, according to the balanced scorecard, it’s possible to have a holistic view of the business.

Blue Ocean Strategy 

blue-ocean-strategy
A blue ocean is a strategy where the boundaries of existing markets are redefined, and new uncontested markets are created. At its core, there is value innovation, for which uncontested markets are created, where competition is made irrelevant. And the cost-value trade-off is broken. Thus, companies following a blue ocean strategy offer much more value at a lower cost for the end customers.

GAP Analysis

gap-analysis
A gap analysis helps an organization assess its alignment with strategic objectives to determine whether the current execution is in line with the company’s mission and long-term vision. Gap analyses then help reach a target performance by assisting organizations to use their resources better. A good gap analysis is a powerful tool to improve execution.

GE McKinsey Model

ge-mckinsey-matrix
The GE McKinsey Matrix was developed in the 1970s after General Electric asked its consultant McKinsey to develop a portfolio management model. This matrix is a strategy tool that provides guidance on how a corporation should prioritize its investments among its business units, leading to three possible scenarios: invest, protect, harvest, and divest.

McKinsey 7-S Model

mckinsey-7-s-model
The McKinsey 7-S Model was developed in the late 1970s by Robert Waterman and Thomas Peters, who were consultants at McKinsey & Company. Waterman and Peters created seven key internal elements that inform a business of how well positioned it is to achieve its goals, based on three hard elements and four soft elements.

McKinsey’s Seven Degrees

mckinseys-seven-degrees
McKinsey’s Seven Degrees of Freedom for Growth is a strategy tool. Developed by partners at McKinsey and Company, the tool helps businesses understand which opportunities will contribute to expansion, and therefore it helps to prioritize those initiatives.

McKinsey Horizon Model

mckinsey-horizon-model
The McKinsey Horizon Model helps a business focus on innovation and growth. The model is a strategy framework divided into three broad categories, otherwise known as horizons. Thus, the framework is sometimes referred to as McKinsey’s Three Horizons of Growth.

Porter’s Five Forces

porter-five-forces
Porter’s Five Forces is a model that helps organizations to gain a better understanding of their industries and competition. Published for the first time by Professor Michael Porter in his book “Competitive Strategy” in the 1980s. The model breaks down industries and markets by analyzing them through five forces.

Porter’s Generic Strategies

competitive-advantage
According to Michael Porter, a competitive advantage, in a given industry could be pursued in two key ways: low cost (cost leadership), or differentiation. A third generic strategy is focus. According to Porter a failure to do so would end up stuck in the middle scenario, where the company will not retain a long-term competitive advantage.

Porter’s Value Chain Model

porters-value-chain-model
In his 1985 book Competitive Advantage, Porter explains that a value chain is a collection of processes that a company performs to create value for its consumers. As a result, he asserts that value chain analysis is directly linked to competitive advantage. Porter’s Value Chain Model is a strategic management tool developed by Harvard Business School professor Michael Porter. The tool analyses a company’s value chain – defined as the combination of processes that the company uses to make money.

Porter’s Diamond Model

porters-diamond-model
Porter’s Diamond Model is a diamond-shaped framework that explains why specific industries in a nation become internationally competitive while those in other nations do not. The model was first published in Michael Porter’s 1990 book The Competitive Advantage of Nations. This framework looks at the firm strategy, structure/rivalry, factor conditions, demand conditions, related and supporting industries.

SWOT Analysis

swot-analysis
A SWOT Analysis is a framework used for evaluating the business‘s Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. It can aid in identifying the problematic areas of your business so that you can maximize your opportunities. It will also alert you to the challenges your organization might face in the future.

PESTEL Analysis

pestel-analysis

Scenario Planning

scenario-planning
Businesses use scenario planning to make assumptions on future events and how their respective business environments may change in response to those future events. Therefore, scenario planning identifies specific uncertainties – or different realities and how they might affect future business operations. Scenario planning attempts at better strategic decision making by avoiding two pitfalls: underprediction, and overprediction.

STEEPLE Analysis

steeple-analysis
The STEEPLE analysis is a variation of the STEEP analysis. Where the step analysis comprises socio-cultural, technological, economic, environmental/ecological, and political factors as the base of the analysis. The STEEPLE analysis adds other two factors such as Legal and Ethical.

SWOT Analysis

swot-analysis
A SWOT Analysis is a framework used for evaluating the business’s Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. It can aid in identifying the problematic areas of your business so that you can maximize your opportunities. It will also alert you to the challenges your organization might face in the future.

Main Guides:

More Resources

Discover more from FourWeekMBA

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Scroll to Top
FourWeekMBA