brand-agnostic

What Does It Mean To Be Brand Agnostic? Brand agnostic In A Nutshell

Brand agnostic refers to a consumer who does not show a preference for one brand over another. Brand agnostic consumers typically possess several characteristics. They are motivated by discounts and bargains, associate value and inspiration with their consumption, and tend to search for ethical products at the best available price. Brand agnostic consumers contradict themselves to some extent. While they tend to be price conscious, they also purchase based on emotion and spend more money on brands they resonate with. This can cause brand loyalty, the opposite of brand agnosticism.

Understanding brand agnosticism

Before the digital era when communication was more difficult, infrequent, and required numerous barriers to be crossed, businesses needed to establish brand loyalty as a matter of survival.

Today, however, consumers faced with unlimited choice and a limited attention span tend to be more brand agnostic than previous generations.

Brand loyalty has been replaced with a desire for new experiences, with a survey finding that 67% chose a product based on a whim or a preference for variety.

From the same study, it was also found that 58% of consumers did not care whether a product was for sale under a national, specialty, or store brand.

With that in mind, a brand agnostic consumer is simply one that holds no preference for one brand over another.

While the brand does remain an important factor in some purchase decisions, modern consumers now consider a range of other criteria, such as social responsibility, product quality, innovation, healthiness, and of course value.

Supply chain disruptions arising from the COVID-19 pandemic also caused a rapid shift to brand agnosticism as consumers rushed to purchase whatever products were still in stock.

Characteristics of a brand agnostic consumer

According to market research firm Euromonitor International, there are several characteristics of a brand agnostic consumer:

  1. They are motivated by discounts and bargains.
  2. They search for the most ethical products at the most attractive prices.
  3. They associate value and inspiration with their consumption.
  4. They tend to be focused on the quality of a product or service.
  5. They are less concerned with notable brands and labels and more concerned with brands that are personable and with whom they can form an emotional connection.
  6. They can seamlessly switch between a brand or product, and
  7. They choose products and services that deliver value via innovation.

Apparent contradictions of the brand-agnostic consumer

Euromonitor International also noted that brand-agnostic consumers tend to contradict themselves.

While many of them search for discounts and bargains, they will also tend to spend more money on products they consider inspirational.

This means there is a conflict between emotion and logic, with the former likely to cause a connection that results in brand loyalty and not brand agnosticism.

To at least partly address this contradiction, businesses should endeavor to develop simple, cost-effective products that inspire the consumer. The brand behind the product should also have a purpose the consumer can relate to and possess these four qualities:

A customer promise

brand-promise
A brand promise is usually one or two sentences that accurately communicates what a consumer should expect when interacting with a brand. When a business creates a brand promise, it is making a declaration of assurance. Brand promises are often seen as extensions of brand positioning statements that explain why a business exists. A brand promise then tells the consumer how a product is service is better than those of a competitor.

This must be consistent with brand values and be relevant at all times.

Continuous improvement

continuous-innovation
That is a process that requires a continuous feedback loop to develop a valuable product and build a viable business model. Continuous innovation is a mindset where products and services are designed and delivered to tune them around the customers’ problem and not the technical solution of its founders.

The business must also derive new insights to make progress. 

Trust

This can be facilitated with exemplary customer service and an ability to keep pace with dynamic consumer preferences.

Innovation

innovation-funnel
An innovation funnel is a tool or process ensuring only the best ideas are executed. In a metaphorical sense, the funnel screens innovative ideas for viability so that only the best products, processes, or business models are launched to the market. An innovation funnel provides a framework for the screening and testing of innovative ideas for viability.

Thinking outside the box is also key to combatting brand agnosticism. 

Case Studies

  • Electronics:
    • Scenario: Jenny used to be loyal to Apple, using an iPhone for years. However, after reading positive reviews about the camera quality and battery life of the Samsung Galaxy S21, she decided to switch. The next year, intrigued by the Google Pixel’s AI features, she gave it a try.
  • Sportswear:
    • Scenario: Michael runs marathons and has shoes from Nike, Adidas, and Brooks. Depending on the type of race and terrain, he chooses the brand that suits him best, rather than sticking to one.
  • Airlines:
    • Scenario: On her frequent trips, Laura sometimes flies Delta for its comfort, Southwest for its baggage policy, or JetBlue for its in-flight entertainment. Her choice is often based on the best deal and flight schedule.
  • Groceries:
    • Scenario: At Walmart, Alex sometimes buys Great Value (Walmart’s private label) products, but he’ll also pick up national brands like Kellogg’s or Kraft, especially if there’s a sale.
  • Automobiles:
    • Scenario: Over the years, Sophia has owned a Toyota Camry for its reliability, a Honda CR-V for its spaciousness, and a Tesla Model 3 for its sustainability features. Her purchases are driven by her current needs rather than brand loyalty.
  • Streaming Services:
    • Scenario: Kevin subscribes to Netflix for its vast library of shows, Disney+ for Marvel and Star Wars content, and occasionally turns to Amazon Prime Video for its unique originals. He doesn’t exclusively stick to one service.
  • Coffee Chains:
    • Scenario: On her way to work, Maria might grab a latte from Starbucks, a cold brew from Dunkin’, or a cappuccino from Peet’s Coffee, depending on her mood and location.
  • Gadgets:
    • Scenario: For noise-cancelling headphones, Liam first bought Bose QuietComfort because of its reputation. Later, intrigued by the design and reviews, he tried the Sony WH-1000XM4.
  • Furniture:
    • Scenario: When moving into her new apartment, Emily purchased a MALM bed from IKEA, a dining set from West Elm, and accent chairs from Target’s Project 62 line. Her decisions were based on style, budget, and convenience.
  • Cosmetics:
    • Scenario: In her makeup routine, Ava uses Fenty Beauty foundation for its inclusive shade range, MAC lipsticks for their vibrant colors, and Urban Decay eyeshadows for their longevity. She picks each product based on its specific merit rather than brand loyalty.

Key highlights on Brand Agnosticism:

  • Introduction:
    • Consumers are increasingly making purchasing decisions based on emotion and resonance with a brand, leading to brand loyalty. The opposite of this is brand agnosticism.
  • Understanding Brand Agnosticism:
    • In the digital era with unlimited choice, brand loyalty is diminishing.
    • Consumers often choose products on a whim or for variety.
    • 58% of consumers are indifferent to the brand type (national, specialty, or store brand).
    • Brand agnosticism is influenced by various factors like social responsibility, product quality, innovation, healthiness, and value.
    • COVID-19 supply chain disruptions further pushed consumers towards brand agnosticism.
  • Characteristics of Brand Agnostic Consumers:
    • Motivated by discounts.
    • Seek ethical products at good prices.
    • Associate value and inspiration with consumption.
    • Focus on product or service quality.
    • Prefer brands with which they can form an emotional connection.
    • Can easily switch between brands.
    • Prioritize products and services that offer innovative value.
  • Contradictions in Brand Agnostic Consumers:
    • While they seek discounts, they might spend more on products they find inspirational.
    • There’s a conflict between emotion (leading to brand loyalty) and logic (leading to brand agnosticism).
  • Combatting Brand Agnosticism:
    • Companies should offer simple, cost-effective, and inspiring products.
    • The brand should have a purpose relatable to consumers.
    • Essential qualities to combat brand agnosticism:
      • Customer Promise: A declaration of assurance, often an extension of a brand positioning statement.
      • Continuous Improvement: A mindset that focuses on constantly refining products based on customer feedback.
      • Trust: Building trust through excellent customer service and adapting to consumer preferences.
      • Innovation: Using tools like innovation funnels to ensure only viable and innovative ideas are executed.
  • Conclusion:
    • With the rise of brand agnosticism, businesses must think outside the box and prioritize trust, innovation, and relevance to stand out and build loyalty among consumers.

Visual Marketing Glossary

Account-Based Marketing

account-based-marketing
Account-based marketing (ABM) is a strategy where the marketing and sales departments come together to create personalized buying experiences for high-value accounts. Account-based marketing is a business-to-business (B2B) approach in which marketing and sales teams work together to target high-value accounts and turn them into customers.

Ad-Ops

ad-ops
Ad Ops – also known as Digital Ad Operations – refers to systems and processes that support digital advertisements’ delivery and management. The concept describes any process that helps a marketing team manage, run, or optimize ad campaigns, making them an integrating part of the business operations.

AARRR Funnel

pirate-metrics
Venture capitalist, Dave McClure, coined the acronym AARRR which is a simplified model that enables to understand what metrics and channels to look at, at each stage for the users’ path toward becoming customers and referrers of a brand.

Affinity Marketing

affinity-marketing
Affinity marketing involves a partnership between two or more businesses to sell more products. Note that this is a mutually beneficial arrangement where one brand can extend its reach and enhance its credibility in association with the other.

Ambush Marketing

ambush-marketing
As the name suggests, ambush marketing raises awareness for brands at events in a covert and unexpected fashion. Ambush marketing takes many forms, one common element, the brand advertising their products or services has not paid for the right to do so. Thus, the business doing the ambushing attempts to capitalize on the efforts made by the business sponsoring the event.

Affiliate Marketing

affiliate-marketing
Affiliate marketing describes the process whereby an affiliate earns a commission for selling the products of another person or company. Here, the affiliate is simply an individual who is motivated to promote a particular product through incentivization. The business whose product is being promoted will gain in terms of sales and marketing from affiliates.

Bullseye Framework

bullseye-framework
The bullseye framework is a simple method that enables you to prioritize the marketing channels that will make your company gain traction. The main logic of the bullseye framework is to find the marketing channels that work and prioritize them.

Brand Building

brand-building
Brand building is the set of activities that help companies to build an identity that can be recognized by its audience. Thus, it works as a mechanism of identification through core values that signal trust and that help build long-term relationships between the brand and its key stakeholders.

Brand Dilution

brand-dilution
According to inbound marketing platform HubSpot, brand dilution occurs “when a company’s brand equity diminishes due to an unsuccessful brand extension, which is a new product the company develops in an industry that they don’t have any market share in.” Brand dilution, therefore, occurs when a brand decreases in value after the company releases a product that does not align with its vision, mission, or skillset. 

Brand Essence Wheel

brand-essence-wheel
The brand essence wheel is a templated approach businesses can use to better understand their brand. The brand essence wheel has obvious implications for external brand strategy. However, it is equally important in simplifying brand strategy for employees without a strong marketing background. Although many variations of the brand essence wheel exist, a comprehensive wheel incorporates information from five categories: attributes, benefits, values, personality, brand essence.

Brand Equity

what-is-brand-equity
The brand equity is the premium that a customer is willing to pay for a product that has all the objective characteristics of existing alternatives, thus, making it different in terms of perception. The premium on seemingly equal products and quality is attributable to its brand equity.

Brand Positioning

brand-positioning
Brand positioning is about creating a mental real estate in the mind of the target market. If successful, brand positioning allows a business to gain a competitive advantage. And it also works as a switching cost in favor of the brand. Consumers recognizing a brand might be less prone to switch to another brand.

Business Storytelling

business-storytelling
Business storytelling is a critical part of developing a business model. Indeed, the way you frame the story of your organization will influence its brand in the long-term. That’s because your brand story is tied to your brand identity, and it enables people to identify with a company.

Content Marketing

content-marketing
Content marketing is one of the most powerful commercial activities which focuses on leveraging content production (text, audio, video, or other formats) to attract a targeted audience. Content marketing focuses on building a strong brand, but also to convert part of that targeted audience into potential customers.

Customer Lifetime Value

customer-lifetime-value
One of the first mentions of customer lifetime value was in the 1988 book Database Marketing: Strategy and Implementation written by Robert Shaw and Merlin Stone. Customer lifetime value (CLV) represents the value of a customer to a company over a period of time. It represents a critical business metric, especially for SaaS or recurring revenue-based businesses.

Customer Segmentation

customer-segmentation
Customer segmentation is a marketing method that divides the customers in sub-groups, that share similar characteristics. Thus, product, marketing and engineering teams can center the strategy from go-to-market to product development and communication around each sub-group. Customer segments can be broken down is several ways, such as demographics, geography, psychographics and more.

Developer Marketing

developer-marketing
Developer marketing encompasses tactics designed to grow awareness and adopt software tools, solutions, and SaaS platforms. Developer marketing has become the standard among software companies with a platform component, where developers can build applications on top of the core software or open software. Therefore, engaging developer communities has become a key element of marketing for many digital businesses.

Digital Marketing Channels

digital-marketing-channels
A digital channel is a marketing channel, part of a distribution strategy, helping an organization to reach its potential customers via electronic means. There are several digital marketing channels, usually divided into organic and paid channels. Some organic channels are SEO, SMO, email marketing. And some paid channels comprise SEM, SMM, and display advertising.

Field Marketing

field-marketing
Field marketing is a general term that encompasses face-to-face marketing activities carried out in the field. These activities may include street promotions, conferences, sales, and various forms of experiential marketing. Field marketing, therefore, refers to any marketing activity that is performed in the field.

Funnel Marketing

funnel-marketing
interaction with a brand until they become a paid customer and beyond. Funnel marketing is modeled after the marketing funnel, a concept that tells the company how it should market to consumers based on their position in the funnel itself. The notion of a customer embarking on a journey when interacting with a brand was first proposed by Elias St. Elmo Lewis in 1898. Funnel marketing typically considers three stages of a non-linear marketing funnel. These are top of the funnel (TOFU), middle of the funnel (MOFU), and bottom of the funnel (BOFU). Particular marketing strategies at each stage are adapted to the level of familiarity the consumer has with a brand.

Go-To-Market Strategy

go-to-market-strategy
A go-to-market strategy represents how companies market their new products to reach target customers in a scalable and repeatable way. It starts with how new products/services get developed to how these organizations target potential customers (via sales and marketing models) to enable their value proposition to be delivered to create a competitive advantage.

Greenwashing

greenwashing
The term “greenwashing” was first coined by environmentalist Jay Westerveld in 1986 at a time when most consumers received their news from television, radio, and print media. Some companies took advantage of limited public access to information by portraying themselves as environmental stewards – even when their actions proved otherwise. Greenwashing is a deceptive marketing practice where a company makes unsubstantiated claims about an environmentally-friendly product or service.

Grassroots Marketing

grassroots-marketing
Grassroots marketing involves a brand creating highly targeted content for a particular niche or audience. When an organization engages in grassroots marketing, it focuses on a small group of people with the hope that its marketing message is shared with a progressively larger audience.

Growth Marketing

growth-marketing
Growth marketing is a process of rapid experimentation, which in a way has to be “scientific” by keeping in mind that it is used by startups to grow, quickly. Thus, the “scientific” here is not meant in the academic sense. Growth marketing is expected to unlock growth, quickly and with an often limited budget.

Guerrilla Marketing

guerrilla-marketing
Guerrilla marketing is an advertising strategy that seeks to utilize low-cost and sometimes unconventional tactics that are high impact. First coined by Jay Conrad Levinson in his 1984 book of the same title, guerrilla marketing works best on existing customers who are familiar with a brand or product and its particular characteristics.

Hunger Marketing

hunger-marketing
Hunger marketing is a marketing strategy focused on manipulating consumer emotions. By bringing products to market with an attractive price point and restricted supply, consumers have a stronger desire to make a purchase.

Integrated Communication

integrated-marketing-communication
Integrated marketing communication (IMC) is an approach used by businesses to coordinate and brand their communication strategies. Integrated marketing communication takes separate marketing functions and combines them into one, interconnected approach with a core brand message that is consistent across various channels. These encompass owned, earned, and paid media. Integrated marketing communication has been used to great effect by companies such as Snapchat, Snickers, and Domino’s.

Inbound Marketing

inbound-marketing
Inbound marketing is a marketing strategy designed to attract customers to a brand with content and experiences that they derive value from. Inbound marketing utilizes blogs, events, SEO, and social media to create brand awareness and attract targeted consumers. By attracting or “drawing in” a targeted audience, inbound marketing differs from outbound marketing which actively pushes a brand onto consumers who may have no interest in what is being offered.

Integrated Marketing

integrated-marketing
Integrated marketing describes the process of delivering consistent and relevant content to a target audience across all marketing channels. It is a cohesive, unified, and immersive marketing strategy that is cost-effective and relies on brand identity and storytelling to amplify the brand to a wider and wider audience.

Marketing Mix

marketing-mix
The marketing mix is a term to describe the multi-faceted approach to a complete and effective marketing plan. Traditionally, this plan included the four Ps of marketing: price, product, promotion, and place. But the exact makeup of a marketing mix has undergone various changes in response to new technologies and ways of thinking. Additions to the four Ps include physical evidence, people, process, and even politics.

Marketing Myopia

marketing-myopia
Marketing myopia is the nearsighted focus on selling goods and services at the expense of consumer needs. Marketing myopia was coined by Harvard Business School professor Theodore Levitt in 1960. Originally, Levitt described the concept in the context of organizations in high-growth industries that become complacent in their belief that such industries never fail.

Marketing Personas

marketing-personas
Marketing personas give businesses a general overview of key segments of their target audience and how these segments interact with their brand. Marketing personas are based on the data of an ideal, fictional customer whose characteristics, needs, and motivations are representative of a broader market segment.

Meme Marketing

meme-marketing
Meme marketing is any marketing strategy that uses memes to promote a brand. The term “meme” itself was popularized by author Richard Dawkins over 50 years later in his 1976 book The Selfish Gene. In the book, Dawkins described how ideas evolved and were shared across different cultures. The internet has enabled this exchange to occur at an exponential rate, with the first modern memes emerging in the late 1990s and early 2000s.

Microtargeting

microtargeting
Microtargeting is a marketing strategy that utilizes consumer demographic data to identify the interests of a very specific group of individuals. Like most marketing strategies, the goal of microtargeting is to positively influence consumer behavior.

Multi-Channel Marketing

multichannel-marketing
Multichannel marketing executes a marketing strategy across multiple platforms to reach as many consumers as possible. Here, a platform may refer to product packaging, word-of-mouth advertising, mobile apps, email, websites, or promotional events, and all the other channels that can help amplify the brand to reach as many consumers as possible.

Multi-Level Marketing

multilevel-marketing
Multi-level marketing (MLM), otherwise known as network or referral marketing, is a strategy in which businesses sell their products through person-to-person sales. When consumers join MLM programs, they act as distributors. Distributors make money by selling the product directly to other consumers. They earn a small percentage of sales from those that they recruit to do the same – often referred to as their “downline”.

Net Promoter Score

net-promoter-score
The Net Promoter Score (NPS) is a measure of the ability of a product or service to attract word-of-mouth advertising. NPS is a crucial part of any marketing strategy since attracting and then retaining customers means they are more likely to recommend a business to others.

Neuromarketing

neuromarketing
Neuromarketing information is collected by measuring brain activity related to specific brain functions using sophisticated and expensive technology such as MRI machines. Some businesses also choose to make inferences of neurological responses by analyzing biometric and heart-rate data. Neuromarketing is the domain of large companies with similarly large budgets or subsidies. These include Frito-Lay, Google, and The Weather Channel.

Newsjacking

newsjacking
Newsjacking as a marketing strategy was popularised by David Meerman Scott in his book Newsjacking: How to Inject Your Ideas into a Breaking News Story and Generate Tons of Media Coverage. Newsjacking describes the practice of aligning a brand with a current event to generate media attention and increase brand exposure.

Niche Marketing

microniche
A microniche is a subset of potential customers within a niche. In the era of dominating digital super-platforms, identifying a microniche can kick off the strategy of digital businesses to prevent competition against large platforms. As the microniche becomes a niche, then a market, scale becomes an option.

Push vs. Pull Marketing

push-vs-pull-marketing
We can define pull and push marketing from the perspective of the target audience or customers. In push marketing, as the name suggests, you’re promoting a product so that consumers can see it. In a pull strategy, consumers might look for your product or service drawn by its brand.

Real-Time Marketing

real-time-marketing
Real-time marketing is as exactly as it sounds. It involves in-the-moment marketing to customers across any channel based on how that customer is interacting with the brand.

Relationship Marketing

relationship-marketing
Relationship marketing involves businesses and their brands forming long-term relationships with customers. The focus of relationship marketing is to increase customer loyalty and engagement through high-quality products and services. It differs from short-term processes focused solely on customer acquisition and individual sales.

Reverse Marketing

reverse-marketing
Reverse marketing describes any marketing strategy that encourages consumers to seek out a product or company on their own. This approach differs from a traditional marketing strategy where marketers seek out the consumer.

Remarketing

remarketing
Remarketing involves the creation of personalized and targeted ads for consumers who have already visited a company’s website. The process works in this way: as users visit a brand’s website, they are tagged with cookies that follow the users, and as they land on advertising platforms where retargeting is an option (like social media platforms) they get served ads based on their navigation.

Sensory Marketing

sensory-marketing
Sensory marketing describes any marketing campaign designed to appeal to the five human senses of touch, taste, smell, sight, and sound. Technologies such as artificial intelligence, virtual reality, and the Internet of Things (IoT) are enabling marketers to design fun, interactive, and immersive sensory marketing brand experiences. Long term, businesses must develop sensory marketing campaigns that are relevant and effective in eCommerce.

Services Marketing

services-marketing
Services marketing originated as a separate field of study during the 1980s. Researchers realized that the unique characteristics of services required different marketing strategies to those used in the promotion of physical goods. Services marketing is a specialized branch of marketing that promotes the intangible benefits delivered by a company to create customer value.

Sustainable Marketing

sustainable-marketing-green-marketing
Sustainable marketing describes how a business will invest in social and environmental initiatives as part of its marketing strategy. Also known as green marketing, it is often used to counteract public criticism around wastage, misleading advertising, and poor quality or unsafe products.

Word-of-Mouth Marketing

word-of-mouth-marketing
Word-of-mouth marketing is a marketing strategy skewed toward offering a great experience to existing customers and incentivizing them to share it with other potential customers. That is one of the most effective forms of marketing as it enables a company to gain traction based on existing customers’ referrals. When repeat customers become a key enabler for the brand this is one of the best organic and sustainable growth marketing strategies.

360 Marketing

360-marketing
360 marketing is a marketing campaign that utilizes all available mediums, channels, and consumer touchpoints. 360 marketing requires the business to maintain a consistent presence across multiple online and offline channels. This ensures it does not miss potentially lucrative customer segments. By its very nature, 360 marketing describes any number of different marketing strategies. However, a broad and holistic marketing strategy should incorporate a website, SEO, PPC, email marketing, social media, public relations, in-store relations, and traditional forms of advertising such as television.

Read more:

Read also:

About The Author

Scroll to Top
FourWeekMBA