greenwashing

What Is Greenwashing? Greenwashing In A Nutshell

Environmentalist Jay Westerveld first coined the term “greenwashing” in 1986 at a time when most consumers received their news from television, radio, and print media. Some companies took advantage of limited public access to information by portraying themselves as environmental stewards – even when their actions proved otherwise. Greenwashing is a deceptive marketing practice where a company makes unsubstantiated claims about an environmentally-friendly product or service.

AspectExplanation
DefinitionGreenwashing is a deceptive marketing practice in which a company, organization, or product presents itself as environmentally friendly, sustainable, or green to appeal to environmentally conscious consumers while exaggerating or misrepresenting the extent of its environmental efforts. The term is a portmanteau of “green” (associated with environmentalism) and “whitewashing” (to cover up or gloss over negative aspects).
MotivationCompanies engage in greenwashing for various reasons, including improving their public image, attracting environmentally conscious consumers, and gaining a competitive edge in the market. It can also be a response to regulatory pressures and consumer demand for eco-friendly products and practices.
Common ExamplesGreenwashing can manifest in different ways, such as: 1. Misleading Labels: Using deceptive labels or certifications that imply environmental benefits without proper verification. 2. Vague Terminology: Using vague terms like “natural” or “eco-friendly” without clear definitions. 3. Hidden Trade-Offs: Focusing on one environmental aspect while neglecting others. 4. Irrelevant Claims: Making environmental claims unrelated to the product (e.g., “CFC-free” on products that never contained CFCs).
ImpactGreenwashing can have several negative impacts, including: 1. Consumer Deception: Consumers may make choices based on false information, leading to disappointment. 2. Undermining Legitimate Efforts: Genuine eco-friendly products and practices may lose credibility. 3. Erosion of Trust: It can erode trust in businesses and make consumers skeptical of environmental claims. 4. Environmental Harm: In some cases, greenwashing can perpetuate harmful practices.
DetectionDetecting greenwashing often requires consumer awareness and critical evaluation. Consumers can look for third-party certifications, such as the USDA Organic label or ENERGY STAR certification, as well as transparent disclosure of environmental efforts and impacts. Organizations like Greenpeace and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) also monitor and take action against greenwashing.
RegulationsTo combat greenwashing, governments and regulatory bodies have implemented guidelines and regulations. For example, the FTC in the United States has issued the Green Guides, which provide recommendations for truthful and non-deceptive environmental marketing. Violators can face fines and legal action.
Corporate ResponsibilityTo avoid greenwashing accusations, responsible companies focus on genuine environmental efforts, such as reducing carbon emissions, minimizing waste, and sourcing sustainable materials. They also engage in transparent reporting and seek credible certifications.
Consumer RoleConsumers can play a role in addressing greenwashing by staying informed, supporting businesses with authentic sustainability practices, and reporting suspected cases to relevant authorities. Consumer activism can influence companies to adopt more responsible practices.
TransparencyTransparency is a key element in combating greenwashing. Companies should provide clear, accurate, and verifiable information about their environmental initiatives. This includes disclosing their sustainability goals, progress, and the methodologies used to measure and report their environmental impacts.
Sustainable PracticesTrue sustainability involves adopting practices that reduce environmental harm and have a positive impact. These practices may include energy efficiency, renewable energy adoption, waste reduction, ethical sourcing, and support for biodiversity.
Ethical MarketingEthical marketing entails honesty, integrity, and accountability in communicating a company’s environmental efforts. This approach involves avoiding exaggerations, deceptive claims, and misleading visuals in marketing materials.

 

Understanding greenwashing

One such company was Chevron, which produced a series of television and print advertisements in an attempt to convince the public of its green credentials.

Various ad campaigns depicted Chevron employees appearing to protect bears, sea turtles, and butterflies, among many other animals.

The commercials had their desired effect, with the company winning an Effie advertising award in 1990.

Later, Chevron’s dubious claims were made the subject of a Harvard Business School study.

The study became notorious among scholars and environmentalists alike, who proclaimed the company to be the gold standard of greenwashing.

Greenwashing is the corporate practice of making sustainability claims to cover a questionable environmental record.

Companies use greenwashing techniques when promoting their products to appeal to the environmentally-conscious consumer, with buzzwords such as “sustainable”, “ecofriendly”, and “natural” frequently cited. 

There may be some degree of truth in the environmental claims an organization makes.

However, these claims are deliberately exaggerated or misrepresented to mislead consumers for financial gain.

The six sins of greenwashing

In an earlier 2007 study, environmental firm TerraChoice examined thousands of products from six category-leading big box stores. 

The study, which aimed to describe, understand, and quantify the growth of greenwashing, found there were six common greenwashing patterns (or sins):

Hidden trade-offs

Where a company suggests a product is green based on a single environmental attribute while ignoring other, more important issues.

For example, paper towel and copy paper is promoted as being made from recycled or sustainable timber with no mention made of manufacturing impacts such as air or water pollution.

No proof

Where a claim is made that cannot be substantiated by easily accessible information.

Household lights and lamps are promoted as energy efficient without any real evidence backed by hard data.

Shampoos and other personal care products also claimed they were not tested on animals with little supporting evidence.

Vagueness

These are claims that are so poorly defined that their meaning is likely to be misconstrued by consumers.

Companies that claim their products are “chemical-free” are misleading because chemicals are found in everything from plants and animals to water.

Similarly, “non-toxic” claims are vague because every substance is toxic in the correct dosage.

Irrelevance

Irrelevant claims may be truthful but are unimportant and unhelpful to consumers seeking green products.

Products that promote themselves as chlorofluorocarbon (CFC) free are irrelevant since their use has been banned for decades.

Lesser of two evils

These are “green” or “organic” products that may hold true within their category but that risk distracting the consumer from the more significant impacts of the category as a whole.

Organic tobacco is touted as a green alternative to normal tobacco, but it still poses the same health risks for the smoker.

Fibbing

As the name suggests, these claims are simply false. Less than 1% of the products in the study displayed this pattern.

Nevertheless, a dishwasher detergent purporting to be packaged in 100% recycled paper was made from plastic.

Several shampoo products also claimed to be organic, but the researchers did not find evidence of any such certification.

Case Studies

  • Volkswagen (VW) Dieselgate Scandal (2015):
    • Claim: Volkswagen marketed its diesel vehicles as eco-friendly with low emissions.
    • Reality: VW installed software that manipulated emissions tests, causing the vehicles to emit harmful pollutants far above legal limits.
  • BP’s “Beyond Petroleum” Campaign (2000s):
    • Claim: BP (British Petroleum) rebranded itself as an environmentally responsible company, emphasizing its commitment to renewable energy.
    • Reality: BP continued to be primarily an oil and gas company, and its environmental efforts were a small fraction of its business.
  • ExxonMobil’s Green Ads (2000s):
    • Claim: ExxonMobil ran ads showcasing its efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and develop cleaner fuels.
    • Reality: The company faced criticism for downplaying climate change research and its significant contributions to carbon emissions.
  • Bottled Water Companies:
    • Claim: Many bottled water companies market their products as environmentally friendly or “pure.”
    • Reality: Bottled water production has significant environmental impacts, including plastic waste and energy consumption.
  • Fast Fashion Brands:
    • Claim: Some fast fashion brands promote “sustainable” clothing lines.
    • Reality: These brands often use unsustainable manufacturing processes, exploit workers, and contribute to textile waste.
  • Single-Use Plastics Bans by Some Companies:
    • Claim: Some companies announce bans on single-use plastics to appear eco-friendly.
    • Reality: These bans may focus on a small portion of their plastic use, while the majority remains unchanged.
  • Food Products with “Natural” Labeling:
    • Claim: Food products labeled as “natural” suggest they are healthier and more environmentally friendly.
    • Reality: “Natural” labeling is often unregulated and can be applied to products with synthetic additives.
  • Fast Food Chains and Recycling Initiatives:
    • Claim: Fast food chains highlight recycling programs and efforts to reduce waste.
    • Reality: Critics argue that fast food packaging and waste remain major environmental issues for these chains.
  • Fashion Brands and Sustainable Collections:
    • Claim: Some fashion brands introduce “sustainable” clothing lines.
    • Reality: These brands may continue unsustainable practices in their main collections, while the sustainable lines represent a small fraction of their offerings.
  • Electric Car “Green” Claims:
    • Claim: Some electric car manufacturers market their vehicles as completely green and emissions-free.
    • Reality: The environmental impact of electric cars depends on factors like electricity sources and battery production.

Key takeaways

  • Greenwashing is a deceptive marketing practice where a company makes unsubstantiated claims about an environmentally-friendly product or service. The phrase itself was coined in 1986 around the time oil company Chevron was making false claims about their environmental credentials.
  • There may be some degree of truth in a greenwashing campaign, though the intent of the company is always to mislead consumers for financial gain. 
  • Greenwashing was discovered to occur across six common patterns, or sins. These include hidden trade-offs, no proof, vagueness, irrelevance, the lesser of two evils, and fibbing.

Key highlights and takeaways about greenwashing:

  • Definition of Greenwashing: Greenwashing is a deceptive marketing practice where a company makes unsubstantiated claims about an environmentally-friendly product or service. It involves portraying the company as environmentally responsible, even when their actions don’t align with these claims.
  • Origin of the Term: The term “greenwashing” was first coined in 1986 by environmentalist Jay Westerveld. It emerged at a time when consumers primarily relied on television, radio, and print media for news and information.
  • Chevron’s Example: Chevron, an oil company, is cited as an example of greenwashing. They ran advertising campaigns that depicted their employees as environmental stewards protecting various animals. These campaigns won awards but were later exposed as misleading.
  • Harvard Business School Study: Chevron’s greenwashing claims became the subject of a Harvard Business School study, which gained notoriety among scholars and environmentalists. Chevron was considered a prime example of greenwashing.
  • Purpose of Greenwashing: Companies engage in greenwashing to appeal to environmentally-conscious consumers. They use terms like “sustainable,” “ecofriendly,” and “natural” to promote their products, even if the environmental claims are exaggerated or misleading.
  • The Six Sins of Greenwashing: In a 2007 study by environmental firm TerraChoice, six common patterns or “sins” of greenwashing were identified:
    • Hidden Trade-offs: Promoting a single environmental attribute while ignoring other important issues.
    • No Proof: Making claims that cannot be substantiated with accessible information.
    • Vagueness: Using poorly defined claims that are likely to be misunderstood.
    • Irrelevance: Making truthful but unimportant claims about a product’s environmental impact.
    • Lesser of Two Evils: Promoting a product as green within its category but diverting attention from broader environmental issues.
    • Fibbing: Making false claims, although this is relatively rare.
  • Key Takeaways: Greenwashing is a practice that aims to mislead consumers for financial gain. Companies may include some element of truth in their claims, but the overall intent is to deceive. It’s essential for consumers to be aware of the six common patterns of greenwashing to make informed choices.

Other Types Of Marketing

Email Marketing

email-marketing
Email marketing leverages a set of tactics to build a stronger brand, drive traffic to your products, and build a solid funnel for converting leads into loyal customers. While email marketing isn’t new, it’s still one of the most effective marketing strategies to build a valuable business.

Affiliate Marketing

affiliate-marketing
Affiliate marketing describes the process whereby an affiliate earns a commission for selling the products of another person or company. Here, the affiliate is simply an individual who is motivated to promote a particular product through incentivization. The business whose product is being promoted will gain in terms of sales and marketing from affiliates.

Influencer Marketing

influencer-marketing
Influencer marketing involves the marketing of products or services that leverages the popularity, expertise, or reputation of an individual. Influencer marketing is often associated with those who have large social media followings, but popularity should not be confused with influence. Influence has the power to change consumer perceptions or get their audience to do something different.

Sustainable Marketing

sustainable-marketing
Sustainable marketing describes how a business will invest in social and environmental initiatives as part of its marketing strategy. Also known as green marketing, it is often used to counteract public criticism around wastage, misleading advertising, and poor quality or unsafe products.

E-commerce Marketing

e-commerce-marketing
E-commerce marketing is part of the digital marketing landscape, and beyond, where e-commerce businesses can enhance their sales, distribution, and branding through targeted campaigns toward their desired audience, convert it into loyal customers which can potentially refer the brand to others. Usually, e-commerce businesses can kick off their digital marketing strategy by mastering a single channel then expand for a more integrated digital marketing strategy.

Buzz Marketing

buzz-marketing
Buzz marketing leverages the power of word-of-mouth advertising to create products or services with enough novelty that they go viral. In many cases, buzz marketing leverages on versatile content that can easily scale and be readapted to various contexts and fear of missing out (FOMO) to amplify the effect of word-of-mouth campaigns.

Shotgun Marketing

Shotgun Marketing
Shotgun marketing is a form of above-the-line (ATL) marketing, where popular mediums such as TV and radio are used to market to a mass audience. This technique of marketing targets as many consumers as possible. Also known as mass marketing, the technique attracts a large number of leads that, on average, might be of lower quality in nature.

Multichannel Marketing

multichannel-marketing
Multichannel marketing executes a marketing strategy across multiple platforms to reach as many consumers as possible. Here, a platform may refer to product packaging, word-of-mouth advertising, mobile apps, email, websites, or promotional events, and all the other channels that can help amplify the brand to reach as many consumers as possible.

Inbound Marketing

inbound-marketing
Inbound marketing is a marketing strategy designed to attract customers to a brand with content and experiences that they derive value from. Inbound marketing utilizes blogs, events, SEO, and social media to create brand awareness and attract targeted consumers. By attracting or “drawing in” a targeted audience, inbound marketing differs from outbound marketing which actively pushes a brand onto consumers who may have no interest in what is being offered.

Partnership Marketing

partnership-marketing
With partnership marketing, two or more companies team up to create marketing campaigns that help them grow organically with a mutual agreement, thus making it possible to reach shared business goals. Partnership marketing leverages time and resources of partners that help them expand their market.

Growth Marketing

growth-marketing
Growth marketing is a process of rapid experimentation, which in a way has to be “scientific” by keeping in mind that it is used by startups to grow, quickly. Thus, the “scientific” here is not meant in the academic sense. Growth marketing is expected to unlock growth, quickly and with an often limited budget.

Guerrilla Marketing

guerrilla-marketing
Guerrilla marketing is an advertising strategy that seeks to utilize low-cost and sometimes unconventional tactics that are high impact. First coined by Jay Conrad Levinson in his 1984 book of the same title, guerrilla marketing works best on existing customers who are familiar with a brand or product and its particular characteristics.

Ambush Marketing

ambush-marketing
As the name suggests, ambush marketing raises awareness for brands at events in a covert and unexpected fashion. Ambush marketing takes many forms, one common element, the brand advertising their products or services has not paid for the right to do so. Thus, the business doing the ambushing attempts to capitalize on the efforts made by the business sponsoring the event.

Relationship Marketing

relationship-marketing
Relationship marketing involves businesses and their brands forming long-term relationships with customers. The focus of relationship marketing is to increase customer loyalty and engagement through high-quality products and services. It differs from short-term processes focused solely on customer acquisition and individual sales.

Main Free Guides:

About The Author

Scroll to Top
FourWeekMBA