Israeli Military Sent 3.5M Photos to Amazon AI, Files Show

The Israeli military uploaded 3.5 million photographs to Amazon Web Services in order to use Rekognition, Amazon’s facial recognition platform, on images of Palestinians, The Guardian reported on 16 November, citing leaked documents it obtained. AWS told The Guardian it had no “visibility” into workloads held by its customers; the Israel Defence Forces said it “does not intend to comment on engagements or services related to operational needs”.

Our read of AWS’s own service terms, last updated on 5 November 2026: the Rekognition rules set four conditions plus a police moratorium, our count, and all of them are written for law enforcement in criminal investigations. Sections 50.8 and 50.9 contain no wording on military users.

Business Pill · Embedded Dependency

An evergreen Business Engineer explainer on embedded dependency, what sits inside what you buy. It teaches the general idea only and does not discuss Amazon, Israel or the report described here.

The key insight: As we read it, the story turns on contract terms as much as on technology: AWS’s published Rekognition conditions are written for law enforcement in criminal investigations, by our count, while The Guardian reported that the Nimbus contract prohibits the providers from restricting Israeli government and military use of their cloud services.

What the Leaked Files Show

According to The Guardian, the images were moved into an Amazon datacentre near Tel Aviv by a department commonly known as Rolling Stone, which sits within a military software unit. The department informed Amazon of the decision in early 2024 so it could use Rekognition, which The Guardian describes as the company’s “AI-powered image analysis platform”.

The Guardian reported that the department holds millions of photographs taken for the identity cards issued to Palestinian residents. It wrote that it is “not clear whether the 3.5m images uploaded to Amazon’s Rekognition were captured at these checkpoints”, referring to temporary Israeli checkpoints in Gaza.

In early 2024, a small group of Israeli soldiers worked from AWS’s offices in Tel Aviv, several military sources told The Guardian. The paper wrote that it is not clear whether their work was made operational or related to the 3.5 million images.

The Israeli military’s move onto Amazon Web Services as reported: the 2021 Nimbus award (NIS 4 billion,
The Israeli military’s move onto Amazon Web Services as reported: the 2021 Nimbus award (NIS 4 billion, $1.2 billion, per Israel’s Finance Ministry via The Times of Israel), new AWS datacentres in Israel in early 2023, data migration into a segregated ‘walled garden’ in 2023, and the upload of 3.5 million photographs to use Rekognition in early 2024, per leaked documents cited by The Guardian on 16 November 2026.

The Cloud Contract Behind It

The Guardian calls Project Nimbus, a “multibillion dollar deal”, the foundation of Israel’s relationship with Amazon. In April 2021 Google and AWS won “a NIS 4 billion tender ($1.2 billion)” to provide cloud-based regional data services to Israel, the Finance Ministry said at the time, as The Times of Israel reported. The two companies won against Microsoft, Oracle and IBM.

As part of Nimbus, AWS opened new datacentres in Israel in early 2023, The Guardian reported, citing documents. The files show an obligation on AWS to give the military access to a segregated area within its Tel Aviv datacentres, which the company and its client described as a “walled garden”, the paper wrote.

The Guardian said it revealed last year that the Nimbus contract contains terms that prohibit the US companies from restricting or suspending Israeli government and military use of their cloud services, even if Israel breaches their terms of service. A military source told the paper the plan at Rolling Stone was to “migrate pictures, videos, all the confidential intelligence information”. For a map of Amazon’s businesses, see our list of Amazon subsidiaries.

What AWS’s Rekognition Terms Cover

Section 50.8 of the AWS Service Terms applies when “Law Enforcement Agencies” use Rekognition’s face comparison feature in connection with criminal investigations. It defines them as “a government entity whose primary purpose and responsibilities are criminal investigation, apprehension and prosecution”.

Its four numbered conditions require a trained person to make any decision that could affect a person’s civil liberties, training for staff, an independent review before “sustained surveillance of a specific person”, and a public disclosure of use. Section 50.9.1 adds a moratorium on face comparison by police departments in criminal investigations. The terms also say the feature “does not provide definitive identifications of any person”.

Our count: four conditions and one moratorium, all scoped to law enforcement or police. In the full terms page, the word “military” appears only in an export clause on hardware appliances used in the European Union and in a careers footer. Government data contracts for AI vendors are in play elsewhere too, as in the race for Palantir’s NHS data contract.

AWS Service Terms sections 50.8.1 to 50.9.1: four conditions on law enforcement use of Rekognition face comparison and one moratorium on police use; no wording on military users
The conditions on Rekognition’s face comparison feature in the AWS Service Terms, sections 50.8 to 50.9.1 (last updated 5 November 2026): four for law enforcement agencies in criminal investigations and a moratorium on police use. The count is ours.

What Amazon and the IDF Said

An AWS spokesperson told The Guardian: “We respect the privacy of our customers, and we do not discuss our relationship without their consent.” On the soldiers’ presence at its offices, AWS said customers “regularly visit our offices for briefings and meetings” and that “Any suggestion that these visits are anything other than routine customer engagement is wrong and unsubstantiated.”

A spokesperson for the Israel Defence Forces said it “does not intend to comment on engagements or services related to operational needs”, The Guardian reported.

The Structural Read

As we read it, the AWS statements answer a different question from the one the documents raise: AWS told The Guardian it has no visibility into workloads held by its customers, and The Guardian reported that the sensitive material sat in a segregated area of AWS’s Tel Aviv datacentres.

As we read The Guardian’s own caveats, the report establishes the upload and the plan to use Rekognition, not the results: the paper wrote that it is not clear where the 3.5 million images were captured or whether the soldiers’ work at AWS’s offices became operational.

An AWS spokesperson, to The Guardian

“We respect the privacy of our customers, and we do not discuss our relationship without their consent.”

Three Implications

FOR CLOUD PROVIDERS The Guardian wrote that the Nimbus terms would prevent the kind of unilateral action Microsoft took last year when it disabled the Israeli military’s access to technology used to operate a mass surveillance system.

FOR THE NIMBUS CONTRACT The Times of Israel reported in 2021 that Google and AWS won the NIS 4 billion ($1.2 billion) tender against Microsoft, Oracle and IBM.

RELATED The race for Palantir’s NHS data contract is another government data deal for an AI vendor.

The Business Engineer Lens

This story maps onto the Business Engineer framework Enterprise AI: From Software to Substrate.

The framework says enterprise vendors “sell irreversibility”: the product becomes infrastructure other systems depend on.

As we read it, the Nimbus terms The Guardian described, which bar the providers from restricting use, and the plan it reported to move all of Rolling Stone’s databases into AWS fit that pattern of a cloud vendor becoming infrastructure. The framework predates the report and does not discuss Israel, Nimbus or Rekognition.

What Is Not Established

The account rests on documents and military sources cited by The Guardian; we have not seen the leaked files. Ynetnews, Anadolu Agency and Arab News published reports based on The Guardian’s investigation; we found no outlet that obtained the documents independently.

The Guardian itself says it is not clear where the 3.5 million images were captured or whether the soldiers’ work at AWS’s offices became operational. Neither AWS nor the IDF addressed the 3.5 million figure in the statements reported. Whether the Nimbus terms override the Rekognition service terms is not stated in the sources we read. We did not contact Amazon or the IDF.

This Week In The AI Supercycle

AI Lost Its Central Banker, the Lab Oligopoly, and the Future of Open Source

This week’s issue: the Nvidia leadership change, read as the AI build-out losing its central banker: who now finances the GPU landlords, backstops the data centres and sponsors open models, and why two labs are becoming the bank.

Read the full issue →

Business Engineer Framework

Enterprise AI: From Software to Substrate

The Business Engineer analysis of how enterprise vendors become infrastructure their customers are woven into.

Read the premium analysis →Get 50% off →

The Bottom Line

The Guardian reported, citing leaked documents, that the Israeli military moved 3.5 million photographs into AWS in early 2024 to use Rekognition. Project Nimbus, which The Guardian calls the foundation of the relationship, was awarded in 2021 as a NIS 4 billion ($1.2 billion) tender, The Times of Israel reported. AWS’s published Rekognition terms set their conditions for law enforcement, by our count; AWS said it has no visibility into customer workloads, and the IDF declined to comment.

95,000+ executives read Business Engineer for the AI strategy frameworks cited by ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity.

A note on sourcing. The account of the 3.5 million photographs, the Rolling Stone department, the soldiers at AWS’s Tel Aviv offices, the walled garden and the Nimbus terms comes from The Guardian’s investigation of 16 November 2026 by Harry Davies and Yuval Abraham, based on leaked documents and military sources; we read it in full but have not seen the documents. The AWS and IDF statements are as given to The Guardian.

The Nimbus tender value comes from The Times of Israel’s report of 21 April 2021, citing Israel’s Finance Ministry. The Rekognition conditions come from the AWS Service Terms, sections 50.8 to 50.9.1 (last updated 5 November 2026), read on 17 November 2026; the count of conditions is ours. We did not contact Amazon or the IDF.

Sources: The Guardian, 16 Nov 2026 (leaked documents) · AWS Service Terms, sections 50.8-50.9.1 (updated 5 Nov 2026) · The Times of Israel, 21 Apr 2021 (Nimbus tender) · Ynetnews report on the Guardian investigation

Scroll to Top
FourWeekMBA