Data Centres Meet a 7-0 Vote, a Refusal and a Suit Threat

The Wisconsin Rapids Common Council voted 7-0 on Tuesday night, 20 October 2026, to reject a conditional use permit for a new hyper-scale data center proposed by the PNK Group at the city’s old paper mill site, WSAU-WAOW reported in a story carried by WDEZ on 21 October.

Five days earlier, on 15 October, Waterford City and County Council in Ireland refused planning permission for a data centre and energy development in Kilmeaden, RTÉ reported. In Pennsylvania, residents gave notice of intent to sue over a 1.5 million square foot data center project, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported on 20 October.

Business Pill · GRID COST ALLOCATION

A short explainer on grid cost allocation: who pays when a data centre needs a new power line. It teaches the general idea only and says nothing about these projects.

The key insight: As we read it, the reports show objections being decided at the local level: a 7-0 council vote in Wisconsin Rapids, a planning refusal in Kilmeaden that cited grid capacity, and a notice of intent to sue in East Whiteland, all reported between 15 and 23 October 2026.

Update (26 Oct): a Michigan township pauses data centres for 180 days. The board of trustees of Clinton Township in Macomb County approved a 180-day moratorium on the siting and building of data centers, the Macomb Daily reported. No data center proposal is pending there. “I think it’s important we get ahead of this issue rather than being victims of it,” township supervisor Paul Gieleghem said at the 19 October board meeting.

Gieleghem wants zoning, infrastructure, noise, utility and environmental impacts studied before any proposal is considered. Township attorney Linda McGrail said courts have upheld six-month moratoriums but not two-year ones, and that an outright ban would be exclusionary zoning. In nearby Lenox Township, a four-month moratorium expired without renewal after a data-center developer’s attorney threatened a lawsuit in May, the paper reported.

Update (26 Oct): in Melbourne, the fight is over power poles. NextDC, Australia’s largest datacentre operator, needs more electricity to expand its M3 datacentre in west Melbourne, and the distributor Jemena’s first plan was to replace shorter timber poles on some suburban streets with taller concrete poles carrying higher-voltage lines, the Guardian reported on 26 October. The upgrade has been delayed by safety concerns, by a lack of access to sites arising from community and stakeholder opposition, and because the local council had not approved 22-metre poles.

NextDC’s share price fell from more than $9 to $5.69 last week, the Guardian reported. The company and Jemena are looking at other options, including pole routes through industrial zones or underground connections. West Footscray residents have opposed the site over the scale of the expansion, construction noise and the possible use of diesel generators during outages.

Update (26 Oct): the fight goes to the ballot box. The Wall Street Journal on 26 October ran the headline “The Four Places Where the Midterms Will Decide the Fate of Data Centers”; we have read only the headline. Earlier, on 8 October, Fox News reported that voters will decide 34 data center-related ballot measures across seven states: California, Florida, Illinois, Kansas, Nevada, Ohio and Wisconsin.

Update (26 Oct): in Nevada, the fight is over who powers the build-out. Switch is seeking approval for a 510-megawatt gas-fired power plant at the Tahoe-Reno Industrial Center, the third private gas plant for data centres to come before the Public Utilities Commission of Nevada, Nevada Current reported. Unlike the two temporary plants regulators approved last month, it would run for 30 years or more, fed by a planned pipeline expansion that could bring up to five times as much gas into the region.

NV Energy told regulators that growth at and near the industrial centre has outpaced available regional generation capacity, noting “the existing system has limits”. A clean-energy group, Nevadans for Clean Affordable Reliable Energy, said in written testimony that at the upper end the plant’s emissions “would effectively eliminate the progress made to reduce electric sector emissions in Nevada since 2015”. Private on-site plants do not have to meet the state’s 50%-by-2030 renewable standard.

Separately, Denver-based Fleet Data Centers is moving ahead with its $5.2 billion data centre east of Reno without a final agreement locking in construction costs, CoStar reported; we could read only the opening of that report.

Where the Projects Met Resistance

The cases below are the local decisions, legal threats and permit disputes over data centres that we verified in reports published between 12 and 23 October 2026. They come from five places on two continents.

PlaceProjectWhat happenedSource
Kilmeaden, Co Waterford, IrelandCrag Rathnew DC Limited (an Echelon Data Centres subsidiary) and Kent Homes: three ICT facility buildings, 16 gas-powered turbines and a solar farm with more than 43,000 panelsCouncil refused planning permission on 15 OctoberRTÉ; Irish Times
Wisconsin Rapids, WisconsinPNK Group hyper-scale data center at the old paper mill siteCommon Council voted 7-0 on 20 October to reject a conditional use permitWSAU-WAOW via WDEZ
East Whiteland, Pennsylvania1.5 million square foot data center projectResidents sent an eight-page letter giving notice of intent to sue the township and developer, the Inquirer reported on 20 OctoberThe Philadelphia Inquirer
TexasData center permits at the state environmental regulator (TCEQ)Public Citizen says TCEQ issued water quality authorizations after the governor’s pause; TCEQ says they were automated notices, now suspended (reported 23 October)Spectrum News
South CarolinaUS Senate raceData centers a point of contention in the 11 October Senate debate; at least six Midlands communities have voted to pause data center developmentWIS via WTOC
Clinton Township, MichiganNo proposal pendingBoard approved a 180-day moratorium on siting and building data centers (meeting of 19 October)Macomb Daily
West Footscray, Melbourne, AustraliaNextDC M3 datacentre expansion; Jemena power-line upgradeUpgrade to taller concrete poles delayed; the council had not approved 22-metre poles; alternatives include industrial-zone routes or underground connections (reported 26 October)The Guardian

Scale figures are given only where the report states them; none of the reports gives a megawatt capacity.

The Wisconsin Rapids Common Council voted 7-0 on 20 October 2026 to reject a conditional use permit for a PNK
The Wisconsin Rapids Common Council voted 7-0 on 20 October 2026 to reject a conditional use permit for a PNK Group hyper-scale data center; Waterford City and County Council refused the Kilmeaden data centre campus on 15 October. Sources: WSAU-WAOW via WDEZ, 21 October; RTE, 15 October; The Irish Times, 20 October 2026.

Ireland: Grid Capacity and Village Character

Crag Rathnew DC Limited, a subsidiary of Irish company Echelon Data Centres, and local property developer Kent Homes submitted the Kilmeaden proposal in September 2025, the Irish Times reported. RTÉ said the application described a mixed-use village centre, technology park and renewable energy development on a total site area of 108.79 hectares, with three ICT facility buildings of around 24,000 square metres each.

Refusing permission, the council said the applicant failed to demonstrate there was “existing capacity in the electricity grid” to support the development, and pointed to a lack of “significant onsite renewable energy”, the Irish Times reported. The council also cited “excessive visual intrusion”, an inadequate wastewater network and flood risk.

The plans attracted hundreds of submissions, and over 300 people took part in a slow drive protest the weekend before the decision, RTÉ reported. Local TD David Cullinane said: “Residents in Kilmeaden have raised serious and legitimate concerns about this development and what it would mean for their village, their homes and their quality of life.”

Wisconsin: A Permit Vote After a Moratorium

The South Wood County Neighbors for Responsible Development formed in April to fight the Wisconsin Rapids proposal, WSAU-WAOW reported. Residents worried about noise and the project’s potential impact on energy costs, while the PNK Group held its own meetings touting its potential benefits.

Mayor Matt Zacher said he is not opposed to all data centers. “If we let them build it and it is a really horrible data center, we are living with it for the next 20, 50, 70 years,” Zacher said. On 9 October the city entered a one-year moratorium on data centers, with the option to extend it to 18 months, the report said.

Pennsylvania and Texas: Lawyers and Permits

In East Whiteland, the residents’ eight-page letter argues that there were violations of township ordinances in approving the plan for the 1.5 million square foot project, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported on 20 October.

In Texas, Gov. Greg Abbott directed the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality last month to stop issuing permits to data centers, Spectrum News reported on 23 October. Public Citizen says TCEQ approved water quality permits for data centers after that directive; TCEQ said the documents are stormwater general construction Notices of Intent, an automated process, and that it has now suspended them.

Abbott’s press secretary, Andrew Mahaleris, said in a statement: “In line with the Governor’s directive, TCEQ has not taken and will not take any proactive actions related to the approval of data center permits.”

South Carolina: Data Centres in a Senate Race

In the 11 October debate for South Carolina’s US Senate seat, data centers became a big point of contention for all three candidates, WIS reported. Democratic challenger Annie Andrews said: “data center companies and AI companies have spent millions to prop up her campaign,” referring to Republican Sen. Darline Graham. Graham responded that “there needs to be community involvement when it comes to data centers.”

Andrews said her data center plan includes a two-year moratorium, which Graham criticized, WIS reported. The New York Times published a story on 26 October headlined “Darline Graham Gets Help From the Data Center Industry in South Carolina Senate Race”; we did not read the article.

Connecting the Coverage

These local fights sit alongside larger public decisions we have covered. San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie posted on 16 October that he had signed the city’s data center moratorium legislation, as an Update to our New York moratorium piece reported. And on 14 October USDA announced a $3.3 billion loan for a Georgia power plant in the county where Reuters says Google bought land for a data center, as our piece on the USDA power loan reported.

The Structural Read

As we read it, the stated reasons are physical and local: the Kilmeaden refusal cited “existing capacity in the electricity grid” and wastewater, and Wisconsin Rapids residents raised noise and energy costs, the reports said.

As we read it, the pauses come first and the votes follow: Wisconsin Rapids entered a one-year moratorium on 9 October, eleven days before the council rejected the PNK Group permit, WSAU-WAOW reported.

As we read it, the issue has reached a federal race: in the South Carolina Senate debate, Annie Andrews proposed a two-year moratorium and Darline Graham called for community involvement, WIS reported.

Wisconsin Rapids Mayor Matt Zacher, via WSAU-WAOW, 20 October 2026

“If we let them build it and it is a really horrible data center, we are living with it for the next 20, 50, 70 years,”

Three Implications

FOR DEVELOPERS The Kilmeaden refusal cited grid capacity, onsite renewable energy, wastewater and flood risk, the Irish Times reported; the PNK Group permit failed 7-0 in Wisconsin Rapids.

FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENTS Wisconsin Rapids will use its moratorium to reevaluate its ordinance, WSAU-WAOW reported, and at least six South Carolina Midlands communities have voted to pause data center development, WIS reported.

FOR STATE REGULATORS In Texas, Public Citizen and TCEQ dispute whether water quality authorizations were issued after the governor’s pause, Spectrum News reported.

The Business Engineer Lens

This story maps onto the Business Engineer framework The State of AI Data Centers.

The analysis puts it this way: “The structural bottleneck isn’t computing, it’s electrons.”

As we read it, that point appears in Kilmeaden: the council’s reasons included that grid capacity was not shown. The analysis was published in December 2025 and does not discuss these projects or local votes.

What Is Not Established

We read the Inquirer’s summary of the East Whiteland letter, not the letter itself; the report describes a notice of intent to sue, not a filed lawsuit. The Texas dispute rests on Public Citizen’s documents and TCEQ’s response, as reported by Spectrum News. The New York Times article on the South Carolina race was not read; only its headline is cited. None of the reports gives the megawatt capacity of these projects, and we did not contact the developers, councils or regulators.

This Week In The AI Supercycle

Execution Fault Lines, Concentrated Demand, and Geopolitical Firewalls

This week’s issue: the AI build is not short of demand for its parts. It is short of cheap money, and its end revenue rests on a narrow base of large, often venture-funded buyers.

Read the full issue →

Business Engineer Framework

The State of AI Data Centers

A Business Engineer analysis of the gigawatt data centre build-out and the grid capacity gap behind it.

Read the Map of AI →

The Bottom Line

Waterford City and County Council refused the Kilmeaden data centre campus on 15 October, RTÉ reported, and the Wisconsin Rapids council voted 7-0 against a hyper-scale data center permit on 20 October, WSAU-WAOW reported. In Pennsylvania, residents gave notice of intent to sue over a 1.5 million square foot project, the Inquirer reported.

95,000+ executives read Business Engineer for the AI strategy frameworks cited by ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity.

A note on sourcing. This piece is based on reports by WSAU-WAOW (via WDEZ, 21 October 2026), RTE (15 October), The Irish Times (20 October), The Philadelphia Inquirer (20 October; headline and standfirst only), Spectrum News (23 October) and WIS (via WTOC, 12 October), read on 26 October 2026. The New York Times article is cited by headline only. We did not contact the developers, councils, Public Citizen, TCEQ or the campaigns.

Sources: WSAU-WAOW via WDEZ, 21 Oct 2026 · RTE, 15 Oct 2026 · The Irish Times, 20 Oct 2026 · The Philadelphia Inquirer, 20 Oct 2026 · Spectrum News, 23 Oct 2026 · WIS via WTOC, 12 Oct 2026

Scroll to Top
FourWeekMBA