Private Equity Vs. Hedge Fund

Private equity funds invest capital into a public or private firm to acquire a controlling stake in that firm. This money can be put to use in numerous ways, such as the strengthening of a balance sheet or the acquisition of new technology to increase output. Otherwise, private equity may simply be used to expand working capital.

A hedge fund is another name for an investment partnership that is created to protect investors from financial losses. They are an alternative form of investment where funds are pooled and used in several different strategies to earn returns for each investor.

One of these is the so-called “long-short” strategy, where the hedge fund takes a long position in some stocks and a short position in others.

Scenario	Private Equity (PE)	Hedge Fund (HF)
Investment Focus	Invests in private companies through equity ownership, often with a focus on long-term growth and value creation.	Primarily focused on actively managing a diversified portfolio of publicly traded securities and financial instruments.
Investment Horizon	Typically involves longer-term investments, with holdings lasting several years, aiming to enhance company value.	Generally shorter investment horizons, with more frequent trading and portfolio adjustments.
Investment Strategy	Often involved in direct ownership and operational control of portfolio companies, actively participating in management decisions.	Typically uses various strategies, including long and short positions, leverage, and derivatives, in public markets.
Risk and Return Profile	Generally seeks higher returns through active involvement in portfolio companies but also involves higher risks.	Seeks risk-adjusted returns, with strategies designed to generate alpha (returns exceeding market benchmarks).
Liquidity	Investments are less liquid due to the longer holding periods in private companies, with limited exit options.	Generally offers more liquidity, as hedge funds trade in public markets, allowing investors to redeem shares periodically.
Regulation	Subject to securities regulations and oversight but with more flexibility due to private market focus.	Subject to various regulations, including disclosure and reporting requirements, depending on the jurisdiction.
Investor Base	Typically raises funds from institutional investors, high-net-worth individuals, and pension funds.	Attracts a wide range of investors, including institutional, accredited, and retail investors.
Fee Structure	Fees typically include management fees (e.g., 2%) and performance fees (e.g., 20%) based on profits.	Common fee structures include management fees (e.g., 1-2%) and performance fees (e.g., 20%) on gains above a hurdle rate.
Exit Strategies	Exit strategies include initial public offerings (IPOs), strategic sales, or secondary buyouts to realize gains.	Can exit positions quickly through trading, but also participate in longer-term strategies.
Investment Size	Often requires substantial capital, making it less accessible to smaller investors.	Allows investors to participate with a wide range of capital sizes, including smaller allocations.
Transparency	Typically provides limited transparency due to the private nature of investments, with reporting to investors.	Provides regular updates and transparency, including performance reporting and portfolio holdings.
Diversification	Focuses on concentrated investments in a smaller number of portfolio companies, increasing idiosyncratic risk.	Achieves diversification by holding a broad range of assets, reducing specific risk.
Tax Treatment	May offer tax advantages, such as carried interest, which can be subject to preferential tax rates.	Typically taxed at ordinary income rates, with some strategies offering tax efficiency.
Fund Lock-Up Periods	Longer lock-up periods, often spanning several years, restricting investors from withdrawing capital.	Generally shorter lock-up periods, allowing investors to redeem shares or withdraw capital periodically.
Alignment of Interests	Aligns interests with portfolio company success, as PE firms often have a substantial stake in the businesses they invest in.	Aligns interests with investors through performance fees, but HFs may not have direct control over underlying assets.
Exit Timing	Exit timing depends on the maturity and readiness of portfolio companies for strategic sales or public offerings.	Exit timing can be more frequent, with positions adjusted based on market conditions and strategy.
Asset Management	Actively participates in the management and operational decisions of portfolio companies.	Primarily focuses on asset management and trading, with limited involvement in the underlying businesses.
Investment Control	Exercises control over investment decisions, including operational strategies and governance of portfolio companies.	Exercises control over investment strategies and positions but has limited control over underlying companies.

Table of Contents

Key differences between private equity funds and hedge funds

With the above in mind, let’s explain some of the key differences between private equity and hedge funds.

Investment horizon

Hedge fund managers tend to be on the lookout for assets that can deliver a worthwhile ROI in a short time frame. In other words, they prefer liquid assets that enable them to quickly move from one investment to the next.

Conversely, private equity funds take more of a long-term view with respect to the profit potential of a company. They are not interested in running a business or acquiring one that needs to be turned around.

Instead, they usually take a controlling stake with a leveraged buyout (LBO) and then make improvements to the company’s management or operations. On average, this investment horizon is around 5 to 7 years.

Capital investment

Members of a private equity fund chose how much capital they are willing to invest and only have to do so when called upon. However, financial penalties can result if the investor does not honor the capital call of the fund manager.

Members of a hedge fund invest all their money at once and, unlike the private equity investor, are not required to commit their money for a predetermined period.

Compensation and fee structure

There are also differences in the ways both funds are compensated. Typical private equity fund managers will charge a 1-2% management fee on top of a 20% incentive or profit-sharing fee.

Hedge fund managers may also collect similar fees while others base them on the net asset value (NAV) for each investor and the high water mark.

This number depends on the timing of an individual investment compared to the year-over-year (YOY) rise and fall of the fund.

Instead of the high watermark, private equity funds use the hurdle rate and managers only earn an incentive fee once this mark has been reached.

For example, if the hurdle rate is set at 7% and the annualized returns reach 6%, no fee is charged.

Risk management

Hedge fund investments are inherently riskier because of their preference to maximize profits in a shorter period of time.

Having said that, both hedge funds and private equity funds combine riskier investments with those deemed safer as part of their risk management strategies.

Key Similarities between Private Equity Funds and Hedge Funds:

Investment Vehicles

Both private equity funds and hedge funds are types of investment vehicles that pool capital from multiple investors to make various investments.

Professional Management

Both funds are managed by professional fund managers who have expertise in identifying investment opportunities and maximizing returns for investors.

Diverse Investment Strategies

Both funds use a diverse range of investment strategies to achieve their financial objectives. They may invest in stocks, bonds, commodities, real estate, and other financial instruments.

Risk and Return

Both funds involve varying degrees of risk, and the potential for high returns is associated with higher risk investments.

Key takeaways:

Private equity funds invest capital into a public or private firm to acquire a controlling stake in that firm. A hedge fund is an investment partnership created to protect investors from financial losses where funds are invested into long and short positions.
Hedge fund managers are more interested in assets that can deliver a worthwhile ROI in a short time frame. Private equity managers take a longer-term view as they acquire a controlling stake in a company and then improve it to ideally sell for a profit after many years have elapsed.
Hedge funds and private funds also differ in the way investment capital is handled. Generally speaking, there are also key discrepancies in terms of risk management and compensation or fee structure.

Key Highlights:

Nature of Investment:
- Private Equity: Invests to acquire a controlling stake in companies.
- Hedge Fund: Pools funds to protect investors from losses and seeks to achieve returns through various strategies.
Investment Horizon:
- Private Equity: Long-term investment, typically 5-7 years.
- Hedge Fund: Prefers shorter-term, liquid assets.
Capital Investment:
- Private Equity: Members choose the amount and invest when called upon.
- Hedge Fund: Members invest all their money upfront.
Compensation and Fee Structure:
- Private Equity: Typically charges 1-2% management fee and a 20% incentive fee.
- Hedge Fund: Charges based on the net asset value and might include a high water mark.
Risk Management:
- Private Equity: Focuses on long-term improvements of companies, combining riskier and safer investments.
- Hedge Fund: Prefers maximizing profits in a shorter timeframe, often with a mix of high-risk and low-risk strategies.
Commonalities:
- Both are investment vehicles pooling capital from multiple investors.
- Managed by professional fund managers.
- Utilize diverse investment strategies.
- Both involve varying degrees of risk and potential for high returns.