Four export-control resolutions with chip-sector companies since 2023 cost between under 0.01% and 3.0% of a year’s revenue, by our arithmetic from official US releases and the companies’ annual reports. The largest share was Cadence Design Systems’ more than $140 million in 2025, about 3.0% of its 2024 revenue.
The four penalties total about $693 million, by our arithmetic. We set them out as context for Nvidia’s new board committee on export controls, created on 17 November; nothing in the releases below concerns Nvidia, and no US agency has announced a penalty against Nvidia.
Business Pill · Sovereign AI Explained
An evergreen Business Engineer explainer on sovereign AI: who controls the model and the data. It teaches the general idea only and does not discuss these penalties, Nvidia or export controls.
The key insight: As we read the four releases, the cash is only part of each resolution: BIS paired the Seagate and Applied Materials penalties with compliance audits, and Seagate’s with a five-year suspended Denial Order. By our arithmetic none of the four cash penalties exceeded about 3.0% of the company’s last full year of revenue.
The Four Cases
Seagate, $300 million (April 2023). The Commerce Department’s Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) said it imposed the penalty to resolve alleged violations tied to selling hard disk drives to Huawei, calling it “the largest standalone administrative penalty in BIS history”. BIS said Seagate admitted to the conduct set out in the charging letter. That is 2.6% of Seagate’s revenue for the fiscal year to July 2022, by our arithmetic.
BIS valued the drives at about $1.1 billion and said the penalty was “more than twice what BIS estimates to be the company’s net profits for the alleged illegal exports”. Against the shipments’ value the penalty is 27%, by our arithmetic.
Cadence Design Systems, more than $140 million (July 2025). The Justice Department said Cadence agreed to plead guilty to conspiracy to commit export control violations over sales of chip-design tools to a Chinese military university on the Entity List. After credits between the two agencies, it said, Cadence would pay “aggregate net criminal and civil penalties and forfeiture totaling more than $140 million”. That is about 3.0% of Cadence’s 2024 revenue, by our arithmetic.
Applied Materials, about $252 million (February 2026). BIS said the penalty, “the second-highest penalty ever imposed by BIS”, covered ion implanters shipped through Korea to China in 2021 and 2022 without a licence, worth about $126 million. Applied said it agreed to pay $252.5 million, that the shipments reflected “the company’s misunderstanding of the applicability of those regulations”, and that the Justice Department and the SEC closed related investigations without action. That is 0.9% of Applied’s fiscal 2025 revenue, by our arithmetic.
GlobalFoundries, $500,000 (November 2024). BIS said the penalty covered 74 shipments of wafers worth about $17.1 million to an Entity List company, and that GlobalFoundries voluntarily disclosed the conduct, which “resulted in a significant reduction in the penalty”. That is under 0.01% of its 2023 revenue, by our arithmetic.

What the Numbers Show
Measured against the last full fiscal year each company had reported, the penalties ran from under 0.01% of revenue (GlobalFoundries) to about 3.0% (Cadence), by our arithmetic. Seagate’s was 2.6% and Applied Materials’ 0.9%.
The releases also attach terms beyond the cash. BIS said Seagate faces a multi-year audit requirement and a five-year suspended Denial Order, and that Applied Materials agreed to multiple audits of its export compliance program with annual certifications to BIS.
BIS gave reasons for two of the amounts: it said Applied’s penalty was twice the transaction value, “the maximum allowed by statute”, and that GlobalFoundries’ voluntary disclosure and cooperation cut its penalty.
Where Nvidia Stands
Nvidia’s own 10-K puts customers headquartered in China, including Hong Kong, at $19,677 million of $215,938 million in fiscal 2026 revenue, or 9.1% by our arithmetic, as set out in our earnings preview. Nvidia says that split follows customers’ headquarters, not where chips end up.
The Commerce and Justice departments said on 16 November that the Justice Department leads the criminal investigation of Megaspeed, a buyer of Nvidia chips, and that Nvidia placed Megaspeed on its no-sell list in June 2025. That statement does not describe any investigation of Nvidia. BIS also announced a rule on remote access to advanced chips the same day.
The Structural Read
As we read the agencies’ own explanations, cooperation and disclosure moved the outcome: BIS said GlobalFoundries’ voluntary disclosure cut its penalty, while it set Applied Materials’ at the statutory maximum of twice the transaction value.
As we read the timing, Nvidia’s board created its export-control committee a day after the Commerce and Justice departments’ Megaspeed statement and the BIS remote-access rule; the release names none of them, and the statement does not describe any investigation of Nvidia.
Matthew S. Axelrod, Assistant Secretary for Export Enforcement, in BIS’s November 2024 release
“We want U.S. companies to be hypervigilant when sending semiconductor materials to Chinese parties”
Three Implications
FOR COMPLIANCE TEAMS BIS said Applied Materials agreed to multiple audits of its export compliance program and annual certifications to BIS, on top of the cash penalty.
FOR INVESTORS The four penalties total about $693 million, by our arithmetic; no penalty against Nvidia has been announced.
RELATED Our report on Nvidia’s new committee sets out its mandate and reporting lines.
The Business Engineer Lens
This story maps onto the Business Engineer framework The AI Supercycle.
The framework argues that chip and model assets “have to be priced with an embedded discount for the political volatility of the control plane.”
As we read it, the four penalties are one measurable part of that discount: by our arithmetic each cost at most about 3.0% of a year’s revenue, before audits and suspended orders. The framework predates these cases and does not discuss any of these companies or Nvidia.
What Is Not Established
No US agency has announced an export-control penalty against Nvidia, and the figures above say nothing about whether one could arise. The four cases differ in conduct, products and cooperation, so the shares of revenue are not a benchmark for any other company.
We chose the four cases from official BIS and Justice Department releases on chip-sector companies since 2023; the list is not exhaustive. We did not contact the companies or Nvidia for this piece.
The Bottom Line
The four chip-sector export-control resolutions since 2023 total about $693 million and ran up to about 3.0% of a year’s revenue, by our arithmetic. Nvidia, whose board created an export-control committee on 17 November, reports China-headquartered customers at 9.1% of fiscal 2026 revenue; no penalty against Nvidia has been announced.
95,000+ executives read Business Engineer for the AI strategy frameworks cited by ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity.
A note on sourcing. The four penalties, their terms and the conduct described come from the Bureau of Industry and Security’s releases of 19 April 2023, 1 November 2024 and 12 February 2026 and the Justice Department’s release of 28 July 2025, each attributed; Applied Materials’ account comes from its 8-K exhibit of 11 February 2026. Revenue figures come from each company’s 10-K or 20-F as filed with the SEC.
Nvidia’s China figure comes from its 10-K, as set out in our earlier piece. Shares of revenue and totals are our arithmetic. FourWeekMBA did not contact the companies or Nvidia for this piece. Not investment advice; for information only.
Sources: BIS: $300 Million Penalty Against Seagate Technology (19 Apr 2023) · US Justice Department: Cadence Design Systems Agrees to Plead Guilty and Pay Over $140 Million (28 Jul 2025) · BIS: Applied Materials to Pay $252 Million Penalty (12 Feb 2026) · Applied Materials 8-K exhibit 99.1 (11 Feb 2026) · BIS: $500,000 Mitigated Penalty Against GlobalFoundries (1 Nov 2024) · SEC XBRL company financial data (10-K and 20-F revenue)









