The Pygmalion effect is the finding that higher expectations from others, such as teachers or managers, can lead to better performance, a form of self-fulfilling prophecy. Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson reported it in 1968 under the title Pygmalion in the Classroom; later reviews find the effect real but usually small.
How it works
Where you see it today
A review of 35 years of research (Jussim & Harber, 2005) concluded that self-fulfilling prophecies in classrooms do occur but are typically small, and that teacher expectations often predict results because they are accurate. The effect is real but easy to overstate.
Expectations work on people using AI too. Participants who believed an adaptive AI was helping them solve word puzzles, when no AI was involved, expected to do better, and those expectations were correlated with how many puzzles they solved (Kosch et al., 2022).
People told that a conversational AI had caring motives rated the same system as more trustworthy, empathetic and effective than people told it was manipulative (Pataranutaporn et al., 2023). How a tool is introduced shapes how it is experienced.
When HR software flags some employees as “high potential”, the label can work like a teacher’s expectation: it may steer attention and opportunities toward those people. That makes the accuracy of the label, and how managers use it, a performance question as well as a data question.
Pygmalion effect vs related effects
How to use it
- Tell people specifically what you expect them to achieve, and why you think they can.
- Pair high expectations with support: harder assignments plus coaching and feedback.
- Check whether you give “high potentials” more attention than others, and whether that is earned.
- When rolling out AI tools, frame them as extending what people can do, then measure real output, not just satisfaction.
- Do not rely on belief alone; small effects need real training and good tools behind them.
How leaders introduce AI can shape how teams use it: framed as a way to do more, tools tend to be explored; framed as replacement or surveillance, they tend to be used minimally. The Business Engineer’s work on enterprise adoption looks at the mechanics that turn that framing into measurable use.
Read: FDEs & The Enterprise AI Adoption Wedge →Explore the platform →Related: Self-fulfilling prophecy · Hawthorne effect · Placebo effect · Expectancy theory · Confirmation bias
Frequently asked questions
What is the Pygmalion effect?
The finding that higher expectations from others, such as teachers or managers, can lead to better performance through a self-fulfilling prophecy.
What is the opposite of the Pygmalion effect?
The Golem effect, in which low expectations from others lead to worse performance.
Is the Pygmalion effect real?
Yes, but usually small: a 2005 review found classroom self-fulfilling prophecies do occur, are typically modest, and that expectations often predict results because they are accurate.
Does the Pygmalion effect apply to AI?
Studies show that what people are told about an AI system changes their expectations and their experience of it, even when the system itself is the same.
Sources
- Rosenthal & Jacobson (1968), Pygmalion in the classroom, The Urban Review
- Jussim & Harber (2005), Teacher Expectations and Self-Fulfilling Prophecies: Knowns and Unknowns, Resolved and Unresolved Controversies, Personality and Social Psychology Review
- Kosch et al. (2022), The Placebo Effect of Artificial Intelligence in Human-Computer Interaction, ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction
- Pataranutaporn et al. (2023), Influencing human-AI interaction by priming beliefs about AI can increase perceived trustworthiness, empathy and effectiveness, Nature Machine Intelligence
The full guide
The complete explainer, cleaned up and reformatted for mobile.
The Pygmalion effect is a psychological phenomenon where higher expectations lead to an increase in performance. The Pygmalion effect was defined by psychologist Robert Rosenthal, who described it as “the phenomenon whereby one person’s expectation for another person’s behavior comes to serve as a self-fulfilling prophecy.”
Understanding the Pygmalion effect
To study the effect, Rosenthal joined forces with a Californian elementary school principal named Lenore Jacobsen.
During the study, each student completed an IQ-test but the results were not disclosed to teachers.
However, they were told the names of students who were identified as ‘intellectual bloomers’.
One year later, the students took the test again.
While all managed to achieve a higher score, the students identified as more intellectual made the most progress.
In other words, students who had higher expectations placed on them by teachers performed better.
Teachers were more likely to pay closer attention to these students by providing in-depth feedback and continuing to challenge them.
The mood and attitude of each teacher toward intellectual students were also hypothesized to be a contributing factor in high performance.
How does the Pygmalion effect work?
As noted by Rosenthal, the Pygmalion effect is a self-fulling prophecy. As a result, it is helpful to consider the effect as a cyclical process:
- First, the beliefs and expectations of Person A affect their interaction with Person B.
- Then, this interaction influences the beliefs or expectations that Person B considers true about themselves.
- In turn, these beliefs or expectations impact Person B’s performance.
- Once the performance of Person B has been impacted, the initial beliefs and expectations of Person A have been verified.
- At this point, the cycle begins again. During the interactions between Person A and Person B, certain beliefs and expectations are reinforced by Person A to get the desired result.
Best practices for using the Pygmalion effect in business
In business, it’s helpful to consider that employees are no different from the students in Rosenthal‘s original study. The same mechanisms can be used to encourage high performance to further personal and professional goals alike.
Here are some best practices for use in a business setting:
Manage expectations
It’s important to note that the Pygmalion effect works both ways.
While positive expectations contribute to high performance, negative expectations contribute to poor performance.
Leaders should therefore seek to identify strengths in their team members and not dwell on weaknesses.
Using the effect, this style of leadership primarily focuses on employee potential.
Set challenges that are ambitious
With the bar set high, overcoming these challenges increases a feeling of empowerment in employees.
Leaders who set high standards are also likely to do everything they can to help someone else reach their goal.
Ultimately, this enhances the culture of an organization.
Use positive language
Perhaps an obvious point, but one that bears repeating. Words are inherently powerful, so leaders should use them to their advantage.
Complimenting the positive attributes of an employee is vital, particularly if they typically have a low opinion of themselves.
This increases trust and commitment to the process in both parties.
Pygmalion Effect Vs Hawthorne Effect

The Pygmalion effect is a psychological phenomenon that describes how expectations modify behavior or performance.
Similarly, the Hawthorne Effect tends to change a person’s behavior due to an awareness of being observed.
Just like the Pygmalion effect can be used in business to encourage strong leadership and higher employee performance, the Hawthorne Effect might help enhance ideation, leadership, and collaboration in young companies.
Pygmalion effect examples
To understand how the Pygmalion effect works in business, let’s start with one of the most comprehensive illustrations of how managerial expectations impact employee productivity.
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company (MetLife)
In 1961, district manager Alfred Oberlander decided to conduct an experiment after he made two observations:
- Exemplary insurance companies grew faster than average or poor companies, and
- New insurance employees performed better in these exemplary companies than they did in average or poor companies – irrespective of their sales aptitude.
Based on these observations, Oberlander placed his best insurance agents under one unit to encourage high performance and also to provide an environment where new recruits would be challenged. He then assigned staff such that:
- The six best employees worked with his best assistant manager.
- Six average employees worked with an average assistant manager, and
- The remainder, or those with the least output, worked with the least able manager.
Once all team members were assigned, Oberlander asked the group containing the six best employees to produce 66% of the volume achieved by the entire company the previous year.
What happened next?
Individuals in the team tasked with producing 66% of the insurance company’s output were called “super staff” by their counterparts.
They also exhibited what is known as esprit de corps, or a collective feeling of pride and mutual loyalty.
After the first 12 weeks, output from this group far surpassed even the most optimistic expectations. This proved that groups with superior ability could be motivated to perform at levels far beyond normal output when average and poor performers were removed from the scenario.
With organizational performance up by 40%, Oberlander repeated the process in 1962 and 1963.
More assistant managers were appointed and matched with subordinates of a similar productive capacity.
The average group anomaly
The six average employees who were assigned to an average assistant manager proved to be somewhat of an anomaly.
Oberlander found that the performance of this group increased significantly because of a healthy dose of competition.
In other words, the manager in charge of the average unit refused to believe that she was less capable than her colleague in charge of the super staff. She also countered that the super staff themselves were not any more talented than her own.
During communication with the group, she challenged her subordinates to outperform the super staff.
She insisted they had the potential to do so provided they did not see their relative lack of experience selling insurance as an obstacle.
Over the years Oberlander’s experiment ran, the average cohort increased its performance by a higher percentage than the employees containing the six best salespeople.
However, it should be noted that it could not match the sales generated by the more experienced group in dollar terms.
The poor-performing employees
Despite the beneficial outcomes seen in the first two groups, it was observed that managers nevertheless found it easier to communicate low expectations than they did high expectations.
At the MetLife district office where Oberlander worked, one manager from a low-output group believed subordinates had zero chance of performing well.
He tried to hide this expectation, but it became evident in his actions and demeanor and some employees resigned as a result.
Over time, employees who were assigned to that manager’s unit believed they were poor performers and expected to be terminated.
Case Studies
- Leadership and Employee Performance:
- Expectations: A manager believes that a new employee has significant potential to excel in their role.
- Behavior: The manager provides guidance, mentorship, and challenging opportunities to the employee.
- Performance: The employee consistently exceeds performance targets and takes on leadership roles.
- Confirmation: The employee’s outstanding performance validates the manager’s initial expectations, reinforcing a cycle of high performance.
- Workplace Promotion:
- Expectations: An employee is promoted based on the belief in their leadership abilities.
- Behavior: The promoted employee takes on new responsibilities with confidence and decisiveness.
- Performance: The employee excels in the leadership role, leading the team to achieve significant goals.
- Confirmation: The employee’s success in the leadership position validates the initial expectations, demonstrating the power of positive beliefs in leadership potential.
- Managerial Leadership:
- Expectations: A manager has high expectations for the capabilities of their team members.
- Behavior: The manager encourages the team to take on challenging projects, fosters a culture of innovation, and provides resources for skill development.
- Performance: The team consistently delivers high-quality work, meets deadlines, and exceeds client expectations.
- Confirmation: The team’s outstanding performance affirms the manager’s expectations, contributing to a positive work environment and reinforcing the cycle of excellence.
- Team Collaboration and Innovation:
- Expectations: A team leader believes in the creative potential of their team members.
- Behavior: The leader encourages brainstorming sessions, values diverse ideas, and provides a safe space for risk-taking.
- Performance: The team consistently generates innovative solutions, leading to the development of new products or services.
- Confirmation: The team’s successful innovations validate the leader’s initial belief in their creativity, fostering a culture of continuous innovation.
- Sales Team Performance:
- Expectations: A sales manager holds high expectations for the sales team’s abilities to meet ambitious sales targets.
- Behavior: The manager provides comprehensive training, sales tools, and motivational support.
- Performance: The sales team consistently achieves and surpasses sales quotas, resulting in increased revenue.
- Confirmation: The team’s exceptional sales performance validates the manager’s belief in their capabilities, motivating the team to maintain high standards.
- Customer Service Excellence:
- Expectations: A customer service manager believes that the support team can provide exceptional service.
- Behavior: The manager emphasizes the importance of customer satisfaction, encourages empathy, and provides training.
- Performance: The customer support team consistently receives positive feedback and resolves issues effectively.
- Confirmation: High customer satisfaction scores affirm the manager’s confidence in the team’s abilities, reinforcing a culture of excellent customer service.
- Innovation and Product Development:
- Expectations: A company’s leadership team believes in the innovative capabilities of their product development team.
- Behavior: The company allocates resources for research and development, encourages experimentation, and supports cross-functional collaboration.
- Performance: The product development team introduces groundbreaking products that capture market share.
- Confirmation: The team’s successful innovations confirm the leadership’s expectations, encouraging ongoing investment in innovation.
- Project Team Performance:
- Expectations: A project manager believes in the expertise of the project team.
- Behavior: The manager trusts team members to make decisions, assigns responsibilities based on strengths, and fosters open communication.
- Performance: The project is executed efficiently, meets all milestones, and exceeds client expectations.
- Confirmation: The project’s success affirms the manager’s belief in the team’s capabilities, promoting trust and collaboration in future projects.
Key takeaways
- The Pygmalion effect is a psychological phenomenon that describes how expectations modify behavior or performance.
- The Pygmalion effect can be thought of as a cyclical, self-fulfilling process between two parties.
- The Pygmalion effect can be used in business to encourage strong leadership and higher employee performance. Managing expectations and the setting of ambitious goals are crucial. Positive affirmation is also important as a means of increasing trust and buy-in.
Pygmalion Effect Highlights
- Definition: The Pygmalion effect is a psychological phenomenon in which higher expectations placed on an individual lead to an increase in their performance. It’s a self-fulfilling prophecy where one person’s beliefs about another person’s behavior influence the outcome.
- Rosenthal-Jacobsen Study: In an elementary school study, students were identified as “intellectual bloomers” based on random IQ test results. Teachers’ expectations about these students led to their improved performance over time, highlighting the Pygmalion effect.
- Cyclical Process: The Pygmalion effect operates in a cycle:
- Person A has expectations for Person B.
- Person A’s behavior towards Person B is influenced by those expectations.
- Person B internalizes these expectations, affecting their performance.
- Person B’s performance confirms Person A’s initial expectations.
- Application in Business:
- Managing Expectations: Leaders should focus on employees’ potential, emphasizing strengths rather than weaknesses.
- Setting Ambitious Challenges: High standards and challenges empower employees and foster a culture of excellence.
- Using Positive Language: Compliments and positive reinforcement build trust and commitment.
- Pygmalion Effect vs. Hawthorne Effect:
- Pygmalion Effect: Expectations shape performance by influencing individuals’ behavior.
- Hawthorne Effect: People change their behavior when they know they are being observed.
- Metropolitan Life Insurance Company Example:
- Experiment Setup: Alfred Oberlander’s experiment at MetLife placed employees into different performance groups.
- Results:
- Positive expectations led to increased productivity in the “super staff” group.
- A healthy competition environment boosted performance in the average group.
- Poor expectations resulted in lower performance and employee resignations in the low-output group.
- Key Takeaway: The Pygmalion effect highlights the impact of expectations on performance. It’s a powerful tool in business leadership that can be harnessed to encourage high performance by managing expectations, setting challenges, and using positive reinforcement.
Connected · Pygmalion Effect
Where to go next from Pygmalion Effect
Picked for this page by topic. Every link checked live.
The Business Engineer readFDEs & The Enterprise AI Adoption Wedge Enterprise AI has a problem that the model layer cannot solve.Read on businessengineer.ai →














