NYT Has Until 25 Nov to Press 2 ChatGPT Claims, Judge Rules

The New York Times and four other news publishers have until Wednesday, 25 November, to seek summary judgment against OpenAI on their “grounding and output” claims, a federal judge ordered.

Judge Sidney Stein set the date on 12 November, 13 days ahead, after the publishers left those claims out of their first motion. OpenAI’s opposition is due 11 December and any reply 18 December.

The order sits in the consolidated copyright case against OpenAI in Manhattan federal court. Each side gets 7,500 words, and 2,500 for a reply.

Business Pill · The Cost of Checking

An evergreen Business Engineer explainer on the cost of checking AI output. It teaches the general idea only and does not discuss this case.

The key insight: The New York Times and four other news publishers must file by 25 November if they want summary judgment against OpenAI on their grounding and output claims, after Judge Stein declined to foreclose them despite a missed deadline; briefing would close on 18 December.

Why the Claims Were Left Out

The publishers chose not to seek summary judgment on these two claims in their first motion. They said the issue was “not ripe for determination against OpenAI until the resolution” of a pending sanctions motion, the order says.

That sanctions motion alleges, among other things, that OpenAI misrepresented its ability to search its training datasets for the publishers’ articles and obstructed the sampling of ChatGPT output logs, per the order.

In it, the publishers ask the court to stop OpenAI relying on a log of 20 million conversations in its own summary judgment motion.

They also ask the court to find that ChatGPT output logs show “substantial and systematic grounding on and regurgitation of News Plaintiffs’ copyrighted material in outputs”, the order records.

The publishers’ motion is due 13 days after the order, and briefing would close 36 days after it, by our
The publishers’ motion is due 13 days after the order, and briefing would close 36 days after it, by our arithmetic from the order.

What the Judge Said

OpenAI raised the gap in its opposition brief, writing that the publishers “never sought court approval for this approach and it ignores the Court’s deadlines,” per the order.

Stein agreed the publishers had not asked permission to delay. “However, the Court will not go so far, as OpenAI implies, as to foreclose News Plaintiffs’ ability to seek summary judgment in their favor on their grounding and output claims, despite the missed deadline,” he wrote.

He added that the omission “undermines the Court-ordered word limit for summary judgment motions.”

Stacked bar of word limits in the order: 7,500 words for the publishers' motion, 7,500 for OpenAI's opposition and 2,500 for a reply, 17,500 in all.
The order caps the publishers’ motion and OpenAI’s opposition at 7,500 words each and a reply at 2,500, 17,500 words in all by our arithmetic.

Who the News Plaintiffs Are

The order names five groups: The New York Times, the Daily News plaintiffs, the Center for Investigative Reporting, the Intercept and the Ziff Davis plaintiffs. Its caption lists five news case numbers.

We have covered the Times’ case against OpenAI and Microsoft before, including what a sealed memo showed. We track the models at issue on our AI model benchmarks page.

What to Watch on Wednesday

First, whether the publishers file at all. The order says they must file by 25 November “if News Plaintiffs intend to pursue” these claims.

Second, what a filing says about the 20 million conversation logs. Third, any ruling on the sanctions motion, which the order says is pending and “will be decided on its own terms.”

The Structural Read

As we read it, these are the claims about what ChatGPT produces, not how it was trained, which is why the 20 million conversation logs sit at the centre.

As we read it, the judge gave a second chance but tied it to the sanctions fight, which the order leaves undecided.

Judge Sidney H. Stein, S.D.N.Y., 12 Nov 2026

“However, the Court will not go so far, as OpenAI implies, as to foreclose News Plaintiffs’ ability to seek summary judgment in their favor on their grounding and output claims, despite the missed deadline.”

Three Implications

FOR OPENAI Its opposition to any motion is due 11 December, with a 7,500-word limit, per the order.

FOR THE PUBLISHERS They must file by 25 November if they intend to pursue the grounding and output claims, per the order.

FOR AI COPYRIGHT CASES The sanctions motion over ChatGPT output logs is pending and will be decided on its own terms, the order says.

What Is Not Established

The order does not decide the claims. A footnote says “Nothing in this Order suggests an outcome on the merits” of the sanctions motion.

The sanctions motion’s claims about OpenAI are the publishers’ allegations as the order describes them, not findings. The day counts and the 17,500-word total are our arithmetic.

This Week In The AI Supercycle

A World Without an Order, and an AI Central Bank Without a Successor

This week’s issue: the week AI memory stayed largely sold out while the people holding the shares paid: why the AI Supercycle is not a dot-com replay, read through geopolitics, macro and technology, with the gap between building and financing the widest we’ve recorded.

Read the full issue →

Business Engineer Framework

The AI Supercycle

The Business Engineer map of who builds, finances and captures value in AI.

Read the Map of AI →

The Bottom Line

Five news publishers have until 25 November to press two claims about what ChatGPT says, after the judge declined to shut them out. Briefing would run to 18 December, 36 days after the order.

97,000+ executives read Business Engineer for the AI strategy frameworks cited by ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity.

A note on sourcing. Every fact and quote is from Judge Sidney H. Stein’s order of 12 November 2026 (Dkt. 2518) in In re OpenAI, Inc., Copyright Infringement Litigation, which also quotes the parties’ filings. The sanctions motion’s claims are allegations as the order describes them. The 13-, 29- and 36-day counts and the 17,500-word total are our arithmetic.

Sources: Order, In re: OpenAI, Inc., Copyright Infringement Litigation, No. 25-md-3143 (SHS) (OTW), S.D.N.Y., Dkt. 2518, filed 12 Nov 2026 (via CourtListener RECAP)

Scroll to Top
FourWeekMBA