Gemini 4 Carbon Leads AI Index at 59, Priced at Half of Opus

Google said on 28 October 2026 that Gemini 4 Carbon, “our next frontier model”, “ranks #1 on the recently updated v5.0 of Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index at 59”. In the benchmark table Google published with the launch, Claude Opus 5.5 scores 58 and GPT-6 Astra 57.

Google says Carbon “will launch at the same introductory price as Argon at $2 per million input tokens and $10 per million output tokens”. Anthropic’s pricing page lists Opus 5.5 at $4 and $20, so by our arithmetic Carbon is priced at half. For now, Google says it will make Carbon “available to a subset of cyber defenders” this week.

Short explainer · Gemini 4 Carbon brief

A vertical news Short narrated from the published headlines and opening lines of this piece and four related FourWeekMBA pieces on AI models, prices and chips.

Business Pill · Model routing

An evergreen Business Engineer explainer on model routing: sending each request to the cheapest model that can handle it. It explains the general idea only and does not discuss Gemini 4 Carbon.

The key insight: As we read it, Google’s launch puts two claims side by side: the top Index score it cites, 59, and an introductory price of $2 and $10 per million tokens, half of Opus 5.5’s list price, while access starts with a subset of cyber defenders.

Update (30 Oct): coding benchmark. Cognition said on 30 October that Gemini 4 Carbon scored 40% on FrontierCode 2.0, its coding benchmark, at a cost of $4.04 per task, behind Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6 Astra and Claude Sonnet 5.5. On Cognition’s leaderboard, that puts Carbon fourth: Opus 5.5 scored 45.5%, GPT-6 Astra 42.8% and Sonnet 5.5 41.0%. By our arithmetic, Carbon ranks first on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index but fourth on this coding test, and its $4.04 per task is about 32% of the $12.82 listed for Opus 5.5; the leaderboard ran Carbon at medium effort in Devin CLI and Opus 5.5 at max effort in Claude Code. Cognition said Gemini 4 Argon scored 26.3% at $6.41 per task, ahead of Muse Wonder 1.0 but behind Claude Haiku 5.5 and Grok 4.7; its leaderboard listed Argon’s cost as $6.51 when we read it.

Cognition’s post on X, above, gives the FrontierCode 2.0 results; it had about 82,000 views when we read it on 30 October.

Update (30 Oct): Perplexity’s early evals. Perplexity chief executive Aravind Srinivas posted on X on 30 October that Gemini 4 Carbon is the “strongest model that we’ve seen so far for long-form research and answer quality” in Perplexity’s early evaluations, with what he called a new state-of-the-art result on the Wide-And-Deep-Research (WANDR) benchmark; the post gives no scores. He said the model is “coming soon to all Perplexity Pro and Max users inside Computer, once we have sufficient token capacity”. That makes the rollout conditional on capacity rather than on a date, and he did not say when that capacity will be in place.

Aravind Srinivas’s post on X, above, shares Perplexity’s early evals of Gemini 4 Carbon; it had about 2,700 views when we read it on 30 October.

Update, 8 Nov: where Carbon can be used, 11 days on. Yuchen Jin posted on X on 8 November asking “Where can I actually use Gemini 4 Carbon?” and listing it as not available to Free, Pro or Ultra users or on the API. When we checked Google’s own pages at about 18:50 UTC on 8 November, Carbon did not appear on the Gemini API models page (which lists Gemini 4 Argon), the Gemini API changelog, the Gemini app release notes or the Vertex AI models page.

Google’s 28 October launch post described a phased rollout: it said Google would make Carbon “available to a subset of cyber defenders” and “gradually phase access to additional trusted partners through our Fairwind Program”, under the heading “Coming soon to developers, businesses, and consumers”. Neither that post nor the four pages above say how many defenders or partners have access. By our arithmetic, 8 November is 11 days after the announcement; alphaXiv’s 28 October post, above, said Carbon would not be generally available for another two weeks. Google’s 28 October post did not give a date for wider availability.

What Google’s Table Shows

Google’s table compares Carbon with Gemini 4 Argon, GPT-6 Astra, Claude Opus 5.5 and Claude Fable 5.1 on 17 benchmarks. Carbon has the top score on 15 of them.

The two it does not lead are FrontierSWE 2, where GPT-6 Astra scores 65.5% against Carbon’s 61.2%, and the offline subset of OSWorld-2.1, where Opus 5.5 scores 87.2% against 81.5%.

On GraphWalks, a long-context test between 256,000 and 1 million tokens, Carbon scores 96.2% against 84.2% for Argon, 71.8% for GPT-6 Astra and 66.8% for Opus 5.5. On Vending-Bench 2, its simulated bank balance is $16,484, against $15,515 for GPT-6 Astra and $9,235 for Opus 5.5.

Google adds that Carbon “jumps +89 elo points to land at #4 (1769) on WebDev Arena”, so on that public leaderboard it is not first.

Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5 scores as published in Google's Gemini 4 Carbon launch table, agains
Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5 scores as published in Google’s Gemini 4 Carbon launch table, against list output price per 1M tokens from the Anthropic and OpenAI API price pages read on 28 October 2026. Carbon and Argon are shown at Google’s stated introductory price of $2 input and $10 output. Half of Opus 5.5’s $20 is our arithmetic. Sources: Google, Anthropic, OpenAI.

What Was Posted on X

An X user posted that Google’s Chrome team says Gemini 4 Carbon performed over 10 times better than another lab’s large frontier model at generating high-quality security patches, and that Google reports over 2 times higher secure-code success than Argon, nearly 80% fewer high-severity misalignment alerts and zero successful attacks on its evaluated prompt-injection benchmark.

TestingCatalog posted that Gemini 4 Carbon (High) took first place on Text Arena with 1528 points, ranked second in Agent Arena behind Opus 5.5 and fourth in Web Dev Arena behind Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6 Astra and Sonnet 5.5.

Wall St Engine posted that Elon Musk called Google’s new Gemini 4 Carbon AI model “impressive.”

Elon Musk’s post reads, in full: “Impressive”.

Demis Hassabis posted that Gemini 4 Carbon is state of the art across key benchmarks and combines frontier capabilities with deep safety and security research.

alphaXiv posted that Gemini 4 Carbon is now state of the art on Terminal-Bench-Science at 64.8% versus GPT-6 Astra’s 63.3%, and that Carbon won’t be generally available for another two weeks.

alphaXiv’s post says Gemini 4 Carbon scores 64.8% on Terminal-Bench-Science versus 63.3% for GPT-6 Astra, and that Carbon won’t be generally available for another two weeks while Gemini 4 Argon can be used today.

Rohan Paul writes that Gemini 4 Carbon took first place on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index with 59, one point above Claude Opus 5.5 (58) and two above GPT-6 Astra (57). He says Artificial Analysis found Carbon wins 4 of the 9 evaluations but does not lead in coding or knowledge work.

The Cyber Numbers

Google describes Carbon as having “state-of-the-art cybersecurity and long horizon capabilities”. Its table puts Carbon at 88.2% on SEC-bench Pro, which tests finding real vulnerabilities, against 85.4% for GPT-6 Astra and 83.4% for Argon.

On ExploitGym, an exploitation benchmark, Carbon scores 54.8% against 42.4% for GPT-6 Astra and 34.5% for Opus 5.5. On CWE-bench, for patching, it scores 71.0% against 68.0% for Astra and 67.0% for Opus 5.5. Google says these were “evaluated without guardrails”.

Google also writes that “the Chrome team has reported that Carbon performed more than 10X better than another lab’s large frontier model when generating high quality patches”. It does not name that model.

Why the Rollout Is Gated

Google says it is “actively engaged in the U.S. government’s voluntary process for pre-release model testing”. Beyond the first cyber defenders, it says it “will gradually phase access to additional trusted partners through our Fairwind Program”.

Developers, businesses and consumers come later. Google says it is “continuing to gather feedback and iterate on guardrails before making Carbon available to developers, businesses, and consumers via our product surfaces as soon as possible”. Sundar Pichai wrote on X that this comes “ahead of wider availability soon, so hang tight!”

On safety, Google says Carbon “reduced successful cheating on Terminal-Bench 4.0 to 0.0%”, and that on Gray Swan’s prompt-injection benchmark it “achieves 0.0%”, against 0.7% for Argon. It also says that in live coding with its own teams, “high-severity misalignment alerts dropped by almost 80%”.

The Price Gap

Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5 scores as published in Google's Gemini 4 Carbon launch table: Gemini
Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5 scores as published in Google’s Gemini 4 Carbon launch table: Gemini 4 Carbon 59, Claude Opus 5.5 58, GPT-6 Astra 57, Gemini 4 Argon 50, Claude Fable 5.1 49. Carbon’s introductory price of $2 input and $10 output per 1M tokens is half Opus 5.5’s $4 and $20 list price (our arithmetic). Sources: Google, Anthropic, 28 October 2026.

Per million tokens, the official price pages list Opus 5.5 at $4 for input and $20 for output, and GPT-6 Astra at $10 and $50. OpenAI’s GPT-6.1 Sol is listed at $2 and $10, the same as Carbon’s introductory price.

By our arithmetic, Carbon’s introductory price is half of Opus 5.5’s and one-fifth of GPT-6 Astra’s, with Carbon one point and two points ahead of them on the Index score Google cites.

Connecting the Coverage

This morning Artificial Analysis’s new Index had Opus 5.5 on top: we reported Opus 5.5 tops AI Index at 58; GPT-6.1 Sol costs 8x less. Google now cites Carbon one point higher.

The price side follows our angle that AI prices fell 35%, yet Anthropic’s existing sales grew 9x. The chips under Gemini are in demand too: we reported that OpenAI plans to buy Google’s AI chips. On 27 October, Google DeepMind shipped Genie 4, its first real-time world model with sound.

Alphabet reports third-quarter results after the US market close today.

The Structural Read

As we read it, the gated rollout is part of the story: Google says it is engaged in the U.S. government’s voluntary process for pre-release model testing and will phase access through its Fairwind Program.

By our arithmetic, Carbon’s introductory price is half of Opus 5.5’s list price and one-fifth of GPT-6 Astra’s, for an Index score one and two points higher in Google’s table.

Google’s own table shows two benchmarks where Carbon is not first: FrontierSWE 2, where GPT-6 Astra scores 65.5%, and OSWorld-2.1, where Opus 5.5 scores 87.2%.

Sundar Pichai on X, 28 October 2026

“Following Argon’s release just two weeks ago, Carbon shows the pace at which we’re pushing the frontier”

Three Implications

FOR ANTHROPIC Google’s table puts Claude Opus 5.5 one point behind Carbon on the Index and ahead of it on OSWorld-2.1, and Anthropic’s pricing page lists Opus 5.5 at $4 and $20 per million tokens.

FOR OPENAI OpenAI’s price page lists GPT-6.1 Sol at the same $2 and $10 as Carbon’s introductory price, and in Google’s table GPT-6 Astra leads FrontierSWE 2 at 65.5%.

FOR SECURITY TEAMS Google says Carbon goes first to a subset of cyber defenders this week, and its table puts Carbon at 88.2% on SEC-bench Pro, evaluated without guardrails.

The Business Engineer Lens

This story maps onto the Business Engineer framework The Open vs Closed Meta-Framework.

The framework starts from the line “Every technology stack has layers.” It sorts those layers into scarce and abundant ones and argues for keeping the scarce layer proprietary while opening the abundant one.

Gemini 4 Carbon is a closed model that Google is releasing first to a subset of cyber defenders, at an introductory price it says matches Argon’s. The framework was published in March 2026 and does not discuss Gemini 4 Carbon.

What Is Not Established

The benchmark scores are Google’s, from the table in its launch post, and the Index score of 59 is as Google cites it. Google links a methodology page for the evaluations; this piece relies on Google’s table for every comparison.

The price is described as introductory, and Carbon is not yet available to developers, so no public price page lists it. We did not contact Google, Anthropic or OpenAI.

This Week In The AI Supercycle

Execution Fault Lines, Concentrated Demand, and Geopolitical Firewalls

This week’s issue: the AI build is not short of demand for its parts. It is short of cheap money, and its end revenue rests on a narrow base of large, often venture-funded buyers.

Read the full issue →

Business Engineer Framework

The State of The Inference Economy

A Business Engineer map of the shift from training to inference and who earns from every query.

Read the Map of AI →

The Bottom Line

Google says Gemini 4 Carbon scores 59 on Artificial Analysis’s Intelligence Index v5, one point above Claude Opus 5.5 in Google’s table, at an introductory price of $2 and $10 per million tokens, half of Opus 5.5’s list price. It goes first to a subset of cyber defenders, with wider availability promised soon.

95,000+ executives read Business Engineer for the AI strategy frameworks cited by ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity.

A note on sourcing. Benchmark scores are Google’s, from the table in its Gemini 4 Carbon launch post of 28 October 2026; the Index score of 59 is as Google cites it. Prices are from Google’s launch post and the Anthropic and OpenAI API price pages, read on 28 October 2026. Ratios are our arithmetic. We did not contact Google, Anthropic or OpenAI.

Sources: Google, Gemini 4 Carbon launch post, 28 Oct 2026 · Google DeepMind, launch post and benchmark table, 28 Oct 2026 · Sundar Pichai on X, 28 Oct 2026 · Anthropic API pricing page, read 28 Oct 2026 · OpenAI API pricing page, read 28 Oct 2026

Scroll to Top
FourWeekMBA