China Logged $3.75B of Malaysia Servers; Malaysia Said $0.6B

Between April 2024 and June 2025, China recorded $3.75 billion of server imports from Malaysia. Malaysia recorded only $0.6 billion of server exports to China, a gap of $3.15 billion by our arithmetic.

Epoch AI’s analysis says the pattern is “consistent with” more than $3 billion of chips smuggled into China via Malaysia. It also says the trade data “alone does not prove smuggling”. The question bears on Nvidia stock, whose chips are the ones under US export controls.

Business Pill · Concentration Explained

An evergreen Business Engineer explainer on concentration. It teaches the general idea only and does not discuss this trade flow.

The key insight: Malaysia and China counted roughly the same 36,000 servers moving between them from April 2024 to June 2025, but China valued them at $3.75 billion and Malaysia at $0.6 billion, a 6.2x price gap that Epoch AI says is consistent with AI chip smuggling but does not prove it (our arithmetic on Epoch’s figures).

Same Servers, Two Prices

Both countries counted roughly the same number of machines: 36,700 declared by Malaysia and 35,500 recorded by China, Epoch found.

They disagreed on the value. Malaysia’s records show about $17,000 per server leaving the country. China’s show about $106,000 per server arriving, 6.2 times as much by our arithmetic.

Epoch says China’s price is far above the cost of ordinary servers. Customs records AI servers and ordinary servers under the same code, HS 847150.

Other buyers of Malaysian-origin servers paid far less over the same period, Epoch found: $1,500 per unit in the US, $6,200 in Singapore, $11,700 in Hong Kong and $23,000 in Japan.

The same Malaysia-to-China server flow, valued by each side’s customs, on Epoch AI’s figures.
The same Malaysia-to-China server flow, valued by each side’s customs, on Epoch AI’s figures.

A Window Between Two Rules

China’s imports of Malaysian-origin servers averaged $42 million a month from January 2022 to March 2024, according to Epoch. In the April 2024 to June 2025 window they averaged $250 million a month.

The jump began a few months after the US banned Nvidia’s A800 and H800 chips from China in October 2023, Epoch said. The flow collapsed after Malaysia’s trade ministry required a permit for exports and transshipments of high-performance US AI chips in July 2025.

From September 2025 to June 2026, the imports averaged $50 million a month, at about $11,600 per machine, Epoch’s figures show.

Bar chart: China's average monthly imports of Malaysian-origin servers — $42 million before April 2024, $250 million April 2024 to June 2025, $126 million July-August 2025, $50 million after
Average monthly value of China’s recorded imports of Malaysian-origin servers, by period, on Epoch AI’s figures.

Why the Gap Would Exist

Epoch’s explanation is about incentives. Export controls at the time restricted sales to China, not to Malaysia, so an intermediary could declare AI servers as cheaper ordinary servers on export paperwork.

Chinese buyers broke no Chinese law by importing them, Epoch noted, so they had less reason to under-declare. Epoch says it tested alternative explanations, such as routing through Singapore or Hong Kong, and found none satisfactory.

If the imports were AI servers, Epoch estimates they could have held roughly 150,000 Nvidia H100-equivalents. That would be about a quarter of the median in Epoch’s modelled estimate of all AI compute smuggled to China.

The Structural Read

As we read Epoch’s figures, the volume matches and only the price diverges, which is why the analysis points at mislabelled paperwork rather than missing shipments.

As we read the timeline, the flow tracked the rules: it rose after the US ban on Nvidia’s A800 and H800 chips and fell after Malaysia’s permit requirement.

Epoch AI on X, 20 Nov 2026

“This trade data alone does not prove smuggling. But the pattern matches established cases where intermediaries routed restricted chips to China through Malaysia.”

Three Implications

FOR EXPORT-CONTROL ENFORCEMENT Epoch’s data shows the flow fell to $50 million a month after Malaysia added a permit rule.

FOR NVIDIA Epoch estimates the imports could have held about 150,000 H100-equivalents if they were AI servers.

FOR TRADE DATA Comparing both sides of the same flow put a $3.15 billion gap on one corridor (our arithmetic).

What Is Not Established

Epoch’s note is dated 17 September 2026. Epoch shared it again on X on 20 November, linking it to the questions raised by Jensen Huang’s resignation.

The trade data does not identify any company, shipper or buyer. Epoch calls its compute figure “a rough estimate intended to give a sense of scale”.

Singapore has charged a fifth person over 917 servers in a separate Nvidia-linked case. SemiAnalysis has put banned Nvidia chips in China at 3.2 times Epoch’s estimate.

This Week In The AI Supercycle

AI Lost Its Central Banker, the Lab Oligopoly, and the Future of Open Source

This week’s issue: the Nvidia leadership change, read as the AI build-out losing its central banker: who now finances the GPU landlords, backstops the data centres and sponsors open models, and why two labs are becoming the bank.

Read the full issue →

Business Engineer Framework

The AI Supercycle

The Business Engineer map of who finances the AI build-out and who controls its bottlenecks.

Read the Map of AI →

The Bottom Line

For 15 months, China valued the same Malaysian server shipments at 6.2 times what Malaysia declared, a $3.15 billion gap that Epoch says matches known smuggling routes but does not prove them (our arithmetic).

97,000+ executives read Business Engineer for the AI strategy frameworks cited by ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity.

A note on sourcing. All trade figures are Epoch AI’s, from its 17 September 2026 Data Insight by Isabel Juniewicz and Lucio Melito, which uses customs records from China’s GACC, Malaysia’s DOSM, UN Comtrade, SingStat and Hong Kong’s C&SD under code HS 847150. The $3.15 billion gap, the 6.2x price ratio and the 15-month window are our arithmetic on Epoch’s figures. Epoch states the data does not prove smuggling; no company or individual is identified in the trade records.

Sources: Epoch AI, Isabel Juniewicz and Lucio Melito, ‘Trade data is consistent with more than $3 billion of chips smuggled into China via Malaysia’, Data Insight, 17 Sep 2026 · Epoch AI on X, 20 Nov 2026, 17:52 UTC · FourWeekMBA, SemiAnalysis Puts Banned Nvidia Chips in China at 3.2x Epoch · FourWeekMBA, Singapore Charges 5th Person Over 917 Servers in Nvidia Case

Scroll to Top
FourWeekMBA