thestargaterealitycheck

The Stargate Reality Check

Despite partnership tensions and scaling back of the broader $500B vision, Stargate’s Texas operations represent the most significant AI infrastructure deployment in history. The Abilene facility is operationally progressing while the broader partnership struggles, creating a complex picture of infrastructure success amid organizational dysfunction.

Current Operational Status: What’s Actually Working

Abilene Stargate I – Confirmed Operational Progress

  • Construction Status: OpenAI said Tuesday that construction of the Stargate I in Abilene, Texas, is underway, and that parts of the facility are already up and running
  • GPU Deliveries: Oracle started delivering the first Nvidia GB200 racks to the facility last month
  • Job Creation: Stargate I has created “thousands” of jobs, including specialized positions for electricians, equipment operators, and technicians
  • Physical Scale: 875-acre site (larger than NYC’s Central Park)
  • Current Capacity: 200 MW deployed as of January 2025 out of 1.2 GW secured

Construction Timeline Reality

Phase 1 (Current):

  • Buildings: Two buildings totaling 980,000 square feet
  • Power: Over 200 MW of power capacity
  • Timeline: This phase is slated to be energized in the first half of 2025
  • GPU Count: 16,000 Nvidia GB200 GPUs by summer 2025

Phase 2 (In Progress):

  • Expansion: Construction of the second phase has already begun, adding six additional buildings to the campus
  • Total Scale: Eight buildings encompassing approximately 4 million square feet
  • Power Target: Total power capacity of 1.2 GW
  • GPU Capacity: Each of the data center buildings is planned to run a single network fabric with up to 50,000 of NVIDIA’s GB200 NVL72s AI GPUs
  • Completion: This expansion is anticipated to be completed by mid-2026
  • Financing: The project has secured a significant financial boost with a $7.1 billion construction loan arranged by Newmark

Infrastructure Reality vs. Partnership Fiction

What’s Actually Being Built vs. What Was Promised

MetricOriginal PromiseCurrent RealityStatusTotal Investment$500B over 4 yearsAbilene-focused executionScaled BackImmediate Deployment$100B immediately~$7B construction loan secured10x SmallerPartnership StatusUnified joint venture"Stargate is not formed yet" - Oracle CEOFailedPhysical ProgressMultiple sitesAbilene operational, expandingPartially DeliveredJob Creation100,000+ jobs promised"Thousands" created in AbileneLocalized SuccessGPU DeploymentMassive scale implied16,000 → 64,000 → 400,000 pathwayOn Track Locally

The Execution Paradox

The Abilene site demonstrates that AI infrastructure can be built at unprecedented scale when partnership complexity is removed:

  • Direct Execution: Crusoe began construction in June 2024. The first two buildings are expected to go live in the first half of 2025
  • Speed Record: “We’re trying to deliver on the fastest schedule that a 100-megawatt-or-greater data center has ever been built,” Lochmiller told reporters
  • Operational Success: Parts of the facility are already up and running despite broader partnership failures

Financial Reality Assessment

Actual Capital Deployment

What’s Been Secured:

  • Construction Financing: $7.1 billion construction loan for Phase 2
  • Crusoe Capital: According to The Wall Street Journal, Crusoe Energy has secured $11.6 billion in new capital
  • Oracle Investment: Oracle had committed $7 billion in the Stargate joint venture with an additional $25 billion in capital expenditures in 2026
  • Power Infrastructure: $500 million expected cost for 360.5MW natural gas plant

What’s Missing:

  • SoftBank Uncertainty: SoftBank has yet to develop a project financing template or begin detailed discussions with banks
  • Partnership Funds: The broader $500B partnership remains “not formed” according to Oracle CEO
  • Multi-Site Expansion: Beyond Abilene, other locations remain in planning phases

Revenue Model Reality

OpenAI’s Direct Infrastructure Strategy:

  • Oracle Deal: $30 billion annual data centre infrastructure deal with Oracle to rent 4.5GW of data centre capacity
  • Primary Customer: OpenAI will operate the center and serve as its main customer
  • Proven Demand: ChatGPT now has 500 million weekly users, validating infrastructure demand

Technical Infrastructure Analysis

Power and Energy Strategy

Multi-Source Approach:

  • Grid Power: 200 MW currently deployed from grid
  • Natural Gas: Developers have filed permits to operate natural gas turbines at the site (360.5MW capacity)
  • Renewable Plans: Discussed generating power with solar and wind projects and modular nuclear reactors
  • Environmental Concerns: Environmental groups have criticized the Stargate Project’s energy strategy, urging a shift towards renewable energy

GPU and Compute Deployment

Staged Rollout:

  • Current: Oracle started delivering the first Nvidia GB200 racks to the facility last month
  • Summer 2025: 16,000 Nvidia GB200 GPUs operational
  • End 2026: 64,000 GPUs deployed
  • Future Capacity: Up to 400,000 GPUs possible (design capacity, not confirmed timeline)
  • Network Design: Each data center building will be able to operate up to 100,000 GPUs on a single integrated network fabric

Geographic and Expansion Reality

Confirmed Locations

Operational/Under Construction:

  • Abilene, Texas: Primary site, partially operational, expanding
  • Natural Selection: Texas’ favorable business environment, access to renewable energy resources and infrastructure as key factors

Planned/Scouted:

  • Amarillo, Texas: Crusoe is eyeing Amarillo, Texas, for the next site
  • Other States: OpenAI has also scouted Oregon, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin
  • International: A separate AI data center in Abu Dhabi is in development, though it will not operate under the Stargate LLC entity

Market Context and Competition

Abilene’s Advantages:

  • Power Availability: “Power is the big stumbling block, there’s not a lot of huge tranches of power just sitting out there,” said Saavedra
  • Rural Strategy: That’s put rural places once considered far afield by data center users — such as the Dakotas and small West Texas towns — on the map
  • Cost Structure: Using low-cost renewable energy to power operations

Organizational Structure Reality

Who’s Actually Building What

Operational Roles:

  • Crusoe: Physical buildout leader, construction management
  • Oracle: Leasing the site and providing server infrastructure, GPU delivery
  • OpenAI: Primary customer, operational responsibility
  • Lancium: Original site developer, infrastructure foundation

Financial/Strategic Roles:

  • SoftBank: Supposed capital investment (stalled)
  • MGX: Strategic investor (limited operational role)
  • Microsoft: Maintained Azure relationship as backup

Partnership Dysfunction vs. Execution Success

The Abilene Paradox:

  • Local Success: Thousands of jobs created, construction progressing, GPUs being delivered
  • Partnership Failure: “Stargate is not formed yet” despite operational progress
  • Direct Relationships: OpenAI-Oracle-Crusoe triangle working effectively
  • Bureaucracy Bypass: Direct execution without mega-partnership coordination

Market Impact and Competitive Positioning

Infrastructure Precedent Setting

Scale Achievements:

  • Speed Record: Fastest 100+ MW datacenter construction timeline
  • GPU Density: Up to 100,000 GPUs on single network fabric
  • Power Integration: 1.2 GW total capacity with multi-source power strategy
  • Construction Scale: 4 million square feet across eight buildings

Industry Model Validation

Lessons for AI Infrastructure:

  • Direct Partnership Model: OpenAI-Oracle-Crusoe proves more effective than mega-partnerships
  • Rural Deployment: Abilene demonstrates viability of rural AI infrastructure
  • Integrated Approach: Power generation + datacenter + customer integration
  • Speed Premium: Fast execution beats comprehensive planning

Geopolitical and Policy Implications

U.S. AI Infrastructure Strategy

What’s Working:

  • Domestic Production: “The data centers are already under construction here in Texas” – demonstrable progress
  • Job Creation: Thousands of specialized positions created
  • Technology Leadership: Deploying latest Nvidia GB200 technology at scale
  • Energy Independence: Multi-source power strategy reduces grid dependence

What’s Not:

  • Coordinated National Strategy: Partnership failures limit broader deployment
  • Multi-State Expansion: Other locations remain in planning phases
  • International Competition: China may capitalize on U.S. coordination difficulties

Trump Administration Claims vs. Reality

Promises vs. Delivery:

  • $500B Investment: Scaled back to Abilene-focused execution
  • 100,000 Jobs: Thousands created locally, broader impact uncertain
  • 20 Locations: Only Abilene under construction
  • Immediate $100B: ~$7B actually deployed

Political Validation:

  • Physical Progress: Undeniable construction and operational progress
  • Technology Leadership: Cutting-edge AI infrastructure deployment
  • Economic Impact: Significant local economic development

Risk Assessment and Challenges

Operational Risks

Technical:

  • Power Grid Stability: 1.2 GW demand on regional Texas grid
  • Cooling Challenges: Direct-to-chip liquid cooling at unprecedented scale
  • GPU Supply: Dependence on Nvidia production schedules
  • Network Performance: 100,000 GPU network fabric complexity

Financial:

  • Revenue Concentration: Heavy dependence on OpenAI as primary customer
  • Power Costs: Natural gas price volatility
  • Competition: Other AI companies building competing infrastructure

Strategic Risks

Partnership Dependencies:

  • Oracle Relationship: Critical for infrastructure management
  • OpenAI Demand: Customer concentration risk
  • Crusoe Execution: Construction and operational capability
  • Regulatory Changes: Potential policy shifts affecting AI infrastructure

Future Outlook and Scenarios

Most Likely Scenario (70% probability)

Abilene Success with Limited Expansion:

  • Local Optimization: Abilene reaches full 1.2 GW capacity by 2026
  • Selective Expansion: 2-3 additional sites in Texas/neighboring states
  • Partnership Evolution: Direct bilateral relationships replace mega-partnership
  • Market Leadership: Abilene becomes model for AI infrastructure development

Optimistic Scenario (20% probability)

Scaled Success and Coordination:

  • Partnership Resolution: SoftBank coordination issues resolved
  • Multi-State Expansion: 5-10 locations under development by 2027
  • Technology Breakthrough: Infrastructure advantages translate to AI capability leadership
  • Policy Support: Government infrastructure support accelerates expansion

Pessimistic Scenario (10% probability)

Stagnation and Competition:

  • Expansion Stall: Abilene remains isolated success
  • Customer Diversification Failure: Over-dependence on OpenAI creates vulnerability
  • Competitive Pressure: Other infrastructure providers capture market share
  • Technology Disruption: New AI architectures reduce centralized infrastructure advantages

Strategic Recommendations

For OpenAI

  • Accelerate Abilene Optimization: Maximize learning from current deployment
  • Customer Diversification: Attract additional AI companies to Abilene infrastructure
  • Partnership Simplification: Focus on proven bilateral relationships
  • Technology Integration: Leverage infrastructure advantages for AI capability development

For Infrastructure Providers

  • Abilene Model Replication: Study and adapt successful elements
  • Rural Strategy: Explore similar rural deployment opportunities
  • Direct Partnership Approach: Avoid mega-partnership complexity
  • Speed Premium: Prioritize execution velocity over comprehensive planning

For Policymakers

  • Successful Model Support: Provide policy support for proven approaches
  • Infrastructure Incentives: Create frameworks supporting AI infrastructure development
  • Energy Coordination: Address power availability as critical constraint
  • Rural Development: Leverage AI infrastructure for rural economic development

Bottom Line: Reality vs. Rhetoric

Stargate represents both a massive partnership failure and a significant infrastructure success. While the $500 billion mega-partnership vision collapsed, the Abilene facility demonstrates that world-class AI infrastructure can be built rapidly when organizational complexity is minimized.

Key Insights:

  • Execution Excellence: “Parts of the facility are already up and running” proves infrastructure can be built at unprecedented speed
  • Partnership Paradox: The mega-partnership failed while direct relationships succeeded
  • Scale Validation: 1.2 GW capacity with 400,000 GPU potential validates AI infrastructure demand
  • Model Innovation: Rural deployment with integrated power generation creates new infrastructure paradigm

The real Stargate story isn’t about partnership success or failure – it’s about proving that AI infrastructure can be built at scale when execution is prioritized over coordination. Abilene represents the future of AI infrastructure development: direct, fast, and technically excellent, even if organizationally simplified.

For the AI industry, Stargate’s lesson is clear: infrastructure success requires execution focus over partnership complexity, and rural deployment with integrated power strategies may be more viable than urban coordination-dependent approaches.

Scroll to Top

Discover more from FourWeekMBA

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

FourWeekMBA