The Collapsing Funnel: From Linear Journey to Circular Flywheel

  • The linear marketing funnel no longer reflects how humans or agents make decisions.
  • The new model replaces sequential steps (awareness → conversion) with a circular system of priming and proving that continuously reinforce each other.
  • Success now depends on optimizing for dual audiences—human emotion and machine reasoning—within a single integrated loop.

1. The Death of the Linear Funnel

The Traditional Model (Dying)

The classic funnel assumes a stepwise human journey: awareness → consideration → decision → conversion.
It’s based on time, attention, and exposure—mechanics that fail in an agentic context.

Why This Fails in the Agentic Economy

  • Assumes humans traverse each stage manually.
  • Sequential and slow—measured in days or weeks.
  • Agents compress the full journey into seconds.
  • Humans never experience most of the funnel.
  • Optimization still orients around clicks instead of recommendations.

In short: humans no longer make linear decisions; agents reason probabilistically, pulling trusted information instantly from distributed sources.


2. The Circular Flywheel Model (Emerging)

The New Model: Priming → Proving → Priming

Instead of a one-way descent, agentic advertising forms a self-reinforcing loop where humans and machines continuously validate and amplify brand authority.

Core Components

  • Priming — Build emotional equity and mental availability.
    • Focus: awareness through cultural relevance, design, and narrative.
    • Target: humans (emotion) and agents (entity salience).
  • Proving — Build epistemic trust through machine validation.
    • Focus: factual accuracy, structured data, and reasoning credibility.
    • Target: agents (composability) and humans (proof signals like reviews, certifications, provenance).

The two cycles reinforce one another:

  • Every act of Priming creates emotional memory that invites reasoning validation.
  • Every act of Proving reinforces trust that strengthens future emotional priming.

Why This Works

  • Circular: Priming → Proving → Priming, forming perpetual feedback loops.
  • Dual-audience: Simultaneous optimization for human + agent cognition.
  • Self-reinforcing: Each layer compounds the other (emotion → trust → emotion).
  • Universal: Works across both human-led and AI-led decision systems.

The result is a flywheel of compounded credibility, not a funnel of decaying attention.


3. The Critical Shift: From Traditional to Agentic Advertising

The transformation isn’t just about channel evolution—it’s a change in cognitive architecture.
The unit of optimization moves from human perception to machine reasoning plus human emotion.

DimensionTraditional AdvertisingAgentic Advertising
Success MetricDid the user click the ad?Did the agent recommend the brand?
Time HorizonSequential, lagged (CPC, CPM, CPA)Real-time, compositional
Monetization LogicCPM (impressions), CPC (clicks), CPA (acquisitions)Entity salience (infra layer), conversational ads (consideration), transaction fees (execution)
Optimization TargetHuman attention and engagementMachine reasoning and human emotion (both)
Feedback LoopUnidirectionalCircular and compounding
Primary AudienceHumansHumans + Agents

Transformation

Advertising evolves from “interrupt and persuade”
→ to “be trusted and invoked.”


4. The Mechanism of Circular Reinforcement

The flywheel operates on dual feedback loops:

Human Loop (Emotional)

  • Builds narrative, identity, and belonging.
  • Relies on design, culture, and storytelling.
  • Strengthens memory recall and emotional priming.

Agentic Loop (Computational)

  • Validates truth, precision, and authority.
  • Relies on structured data, provenance, and composability.
  • Strengthens reasoning reliability and retrieval likelihood.

The intersection of these two loops forms the Integration Layer, where

“Human meaning meets machine validation.”


5. From Awareness to Epistemic Trust

In the linear model, awareness was a top-of-funnel event.
In the agentic model, awareness is epistemic inclusion—being part of the agent’s trusted reasoning graph.

Old Funnel LogicNew Flywheel Logic
Awareness = VisibilityAwareness = Retrievability
Consideration = ComparisonConsideration = Validation
Decision = ClickDecision = Recommendation
Conversion = PurchaseConversion = Execution

What used to be marketing persuasion now becomes epistemic engineering.


6. Measurement in the Agentic Era

Old KPI: Click-Through Rate (CTR), Cost per Acquisition (CPA).
New KPI: Recommendation Rate, Reasoning Inclusion, and Trust Velocity.

New Core Metrics

  • Entity Impression Share: % of reasoning instances in which your brand is surfaced.
  • Agent Recommendation Rate: Frequency your data is used in agentic responses.
  • Citation Frequency: Mentions in multi-source reasoning outputs.
  • Epistemic Consistency: Trustworthiness of your data across reasoning ecosystems.

These metrics measure integration, not attention.


7. Practical Implementation

Step 1: Build Dual Narratives

Align your brand story across emotional (human) and factual (machine) axes.
Example: Tesla is aspirational (human priming) and data-verifiable (machine proving).

Step 2: Create Reasoning-Ready Data

Expose APIs, structured schema, and verified knowledge graphs so agents can compose and reason.

Step 3: Build Continuous Loops

  • Each time a machine cites your data → strengthen the human brand story.
  • Each time a human interacts emotionally → trigger new data validation events.

8. Strategic Outcome

Brands that succeed will operate inside the loop, not outside it.
The advantage compounds as agents repeatedly validate your data and humans repeatedly recall your story.

In the collapsing funnel, there’s no longer a start or end—only reinforcing cycles of trust, emotion, and retrieval.


In short:

Traditional funnels decay with every step.
Agentic flywheels accelerate with every cycle.

Advertising’s new metric isn’t reach—it’s reasoning inclusion.

businessengineernewsletter
Scroll to Top

Discover more from FourWeekMBA

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

FourWeekMBA