Two Giants. Two Incompatible Visions. One Winner.
Google embeds “Direct Offers” ads into AI—protecting its $264B+ advertising empire by charging CPC.
OpenAI takes a “small merchant fee” on transactions—organic results only, no advertising.
The stakes: Whoever wins merchant adoption defines the economics of AI commerce for the next decade.
The Stakes
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Google ad revenue at stake | $264B+ (incl. YouTube, 75%+ of total) |
| ChatGPT conversion rate | 11.4% vs 6% direct (nearly 2×) |
| AI traffic growth | 700% (Holiday 2025 vs 2024) |
| Competing protocols | 3 (UCP, ACP, MCP) |
Complete Breakdown
- The Numbers That Frame This Battle: 700% growth, 11.4% conversion, $264B+ at stake
- Google’s Bet: Advertising-First: “Direct Offers” CPC model, survival engineering
- OpenAI’s Bet: Transaction-Fee: Organic results, fee per purchase
- The Protocol Wars: UCP vs ACP vs MCP—infrastructure battle
- The Merchant’s Dilemma: Two taxes, different flavors
- The Strategic Comparison: Head-to-head across 8 dimensions
- The Adoption Question: User base vs infrastructure
- The Business Model Tension: Why incentive alignment decides all
The Core Thesis
This isn’t a feature war. It’s a business model war.
Google needs ads to survive; OpenAI is betting they won’t. Only one can be right.
This is part of a comprehensive analysis. Read the full analysis on The Business Engineer.
More Resources
